[{"id":"P0001","domain":"economics","parameter":"world mine production, platinum","scope":"platinum, world","value":"170","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Platinum-Group Metals, p.2 World Mine Production table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"USGS estimate (e); 170,000 kg; 2024 = 179,000 kg"},{"id":"P0002","domain":"economics","parameter":"mine production share, South Africa","scope":"platinum, world","value":"70.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Platinum-Group Metals, p.2 World Mine Production table","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"120,000/170,000 kg from USGS table; Russia 11.8% (20,000), Zimbabwe 10.6% (18,000)"},{"id":"P0003","domain":"economics","parameter":"primary supply, platinum (refined)","scope":"platinum, world","value":"172.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM PGM Market Report May 2026, p.27 Platinum supply and demand: Tonnes","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"JM is a PGM refiner/trader; USGS mine-production basis differs (170 t)"},{"id":"P0004","domain":"economics","parameter":"secondary supply (open-loop recycling), platinum","scope":"platinum, world","value":"48.1","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.27 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"automotive 35.2 t, jewellery 10.3 t, electrical 2.6 t"},{"id":"P0005","domain":"economics","parameter":"total demand, platinum","scope":"platinum, world","value":"249.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.27 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"industrial demand net of closed-loop recycling; market deficit 28.5 t"},{"id":"P0006","domain":"economics","parameter":"automotive demand, platinum","scope":"platinum, world","value":"103.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.27 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"41% of total demand"},{"id":"P0007","domain":"economics","parameter":"jewellery demand, platinum","scope":"platinum, world","value":"46.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.27 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"up from 42.9 t in 2024; JM attributes surge to high gold prices (substitution)"},{"id":"P0008","domain":"economics","parameter":"investment demand, platinum","scope":"platinum, world","value":"17.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.27 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0009","domain":"economics","parameter":"chemical demand, platinum","scope":"platinum, world","value":"19.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.27 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"glass 13.3 t; electrical 8.1 t; dental 8.8 t; petroleum 6.6 t"},{"id":"P0010","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price, platinum","scope":"platinum, US (Engelhard)","value":"1200","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"estimate (e); 2024 = 960.70"},{"id":"P0011","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr minimum, platinum","scope":"platinum, US (Engelhard)","value":"866.94","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2019","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2021/mcs2021-platinum.pdf","locator":"MCS 2021 PGM, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"minimum over 2016-2025 from MCS 2021 (2016-19), MCS 2025 (2020), MCS 2026 (2021-25)"},{"id":"P0012","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr maximum, platinum","scope":"platinum, US (Engelhard)","value":"1200","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2025 estimate is the 2016-2025 maximum; next highest 1,094.31 (2021)"},{"id":"P0013","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price, platinum (World Bank)","scope":"platinum, world","value":"955.17","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://thedocs.worldbank.org/en/doc/5d903e848db1d1b83e0ec8f744e55570-0350012021/related/CMO-Historical-Data-Annual.xlsx","locator":"Pink Sheet annual, sheet Annual Prices (Nominal), col Platinum","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"file updated 2025-01-03; 2015-2024 range 863.99 (2019) to 1,091.13 (2021)"},{"id":"P0014","domain":"economics","parameter":"all-time high price, platinum","scope":"platinum, world","value":"2860","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, Supply and demand in 2026 section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"set January 2026; fell to 1,908 by end-March 2026"},{"id":"P0015","domain":"economics","parameter":"PGM basket price change 2017-2023","scope":"platinum, South Africa producers","value":"83","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://platinuminvestment.com/files/perspectives/WPIC_Platinum_Perspectives_June_2025(Platinumsupplyanddemandarepriceinelasticintheshort-term).pdf","locator":"WPIC Platinum Perspectives 26 Jun 2025, p.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"WPIC states total platinum supply declined 7% over the same period: commentary, not an estimate"},{"id":"P0016","domain":"economics","parameter":"total platinum supply change 2017-2023","scope":"platinum, world","value":"-7","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://platinuminvestment.com/files/perspectives/WPIC_Platinum_Perspectives_June_2025(Platinumsupplyanddemandarepriceinelasticintheshort-term).pdf","locator":"WPIC Platinum Perspectives 26 Jun 2025, p.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"used by WPIC to argue near-zero short-run supply elasticity"},{"id":"P0017","domain":"economics","parameter":"time for new PGM mine to reach full capacity","scope":"platinum, world","value":"8.5","low":"8","high":"9","unit":"years","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://platinuminvestment.com/files/perspectives/WPIC_Platinum_Perspectives_June_2025(Platinumsupplyanddemandarepriceinelasticintheshort-term).pdf","locator":"WPIC Platinum Perspectives 26 Jun 2025, p.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"\"most mines require 8-9 years to reach full production capacity\""},{"id":"P0018","domain":"economics","parameter":"platinum jewellery recycling, arc response to price 2024-25","scope":"platinum, world","value":"1.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"ratio (dlnQ/dlnP)","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026 p.27 (7.2 to 10.3 t) and MCS 2026 PGM p.1 (960.70 to 1,200 USD/oz)","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"ln(10.3/7.2)/ln(1200/960.7); descriptive co-movement, not an identified elasticity"},{"id":"P0019","domain":"economics","parameter":"world mine production, palladium","scope":"palladium, world","value":"190","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Platinum-Group Metals, p.2 World Mine Production table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"estimate; 2024 = 217,000 kg"},{"id":"P0020","domain":"economics","parameter":"mine production share, Russia","scope":"palladium, world","value":"44.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Platinum-Group Metals, p.2 World Mine Production table","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"84,000/190,000 kg; South Africa 36.8% (70,000); Canada 8.4%; Zimbabwe 7.9%"},{"id":"P0021","domain":"economics","parameter":"primary supply, palladium","scope":"palladium, world","value":"205.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.29 Palladium supply and demand: Tonnes","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0022","domain":"economics","parameter":"secondary supply (recycling), palladium","scope":"palladium, world","value":"97.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.29 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"automotive 82.6 t"},{"id":"P0023","domain":"economics","parameter":"total demand, palladium","scope":"palladium, world","value":"315.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.29 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0024","domain":"economics","parameter":"automotive demand, palladium","scope":"palladium, world","value":"255.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.29 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"81% of total demand"},{"id":"P0025","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price, palladium","scope":"palladium, US (Engelhard)","value":"1100","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"estimate; 2024 = 994.90"},{"id":"P0026","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr minimum, palladium","scope":"palladium, US (Engelhard)","value":"617.39","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2016","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2021/mcs2021-platinum.pdf","locator":"MCS 2021 PGM, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0027","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr maximum, palladium","scope":"palladium, US (Engelhard)","value":"2419.18","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0028","domain":"economics","parameter":"global recycling of palladium plus platinum","scope":"palladium and platinum, world","value":"140","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM, p.1 Recycling","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"USGS: about 140,000 kg; JM open-loop Pt+Pd 2025 = 145.5 t (48.1+97.4), consistent"},{"id":"P0029","domain":"economics","parameter":"primary supply, rhodium","scope":"rhodium, world","value":"21.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.31 Rhodium supply and demand: Tonnes","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"USGS gives no world rhodium mine production"},{"id":"P0030","domain":"economics","parameter":"primary supply share, South Africa","scope":"rhodium, world","value":"80.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.31 table","verification":"derived","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"17.6/21.8 t; Russia 9.6%"},{"id":"P0031","domain":"economics","parameter":"secondary supply (auto recycling), rhodium","scope":"rhodium, world","value":"9.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.31 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0032","domain":"economics","parameter":"total demand, rhodium","scope":"rhodium, world","value":"33.1","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.31 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"automotive 28.0 t (85%); chemical 2.8 t; glass 1.2 t"},{"id":"P0033","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price, rhodium","scope":"rhodium, US (Engelhard)","value":"5800","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"estimate; 2024 = 4,660.44"},{"id":"P0034","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr minimum, rhodium","scope":"rhodium, US (Engelhard)","value":"696.84","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2016","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2021/mcs2021-platinum.pdf","locator":"MCS 2021 PGM, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0035","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr maximum, rhodium","scope":"rhodium, US (Engelhard)","value":"20254.10","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"record annual average; 2020 = 11,205.06 (MCS 2025)"},{"id":"P0036","domain":"economics","parameter":"rhodium price low before 2016-21 rally","scope":"rhodium, world","value":"625","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2016","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-may-21.pdf/39796ec4-2b71-2ffd-6b3a-a716e428da3d","locator":"JM PGM Market Report May 2021, rhodium section (Figure 23)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"August 2016 low"},{"id":"P0037","domain":"economics","parameter":"rhodium peak spot price in 2021 squeeze","scope":"rhodium, world","value":"30000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-may-21.pdf/39796ec4-2b71-2ffd-6b3a-a716e428da3d","locator":"JM May 2021, rhodium section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"\"highs of around $30,000\" early 2021, weekly swings >$3,000; cause: 2020 Anglo American ACP converter outage plus auto demand rebound"},{"id":"P0038","domain":"economics","parameter":"rhodium primary supply change 2021 vs 2020","scope":"rhodium, world","value":"25","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/PGM-market-report-May-2022.pdf/542bcada-f4ac-a673-5f95-ad1bbfca5106","locator":"JM PGM Market Report May 2022, rhodium section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"\"primary supplies in 2021 jumped by a quarter\" as ACP backlog was processed; prices then fell ~50% from peak"},{"id":"P0039","domain":"economics","parameter":"autocatalyst share of gross rhodium demand","scope":"rhodium, world","value":"90","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/PGM-market-report-May-2022.pdf/542bcada-f4ac-a673-5f95-ad1bbfca5106","locator":"JM May 2022, rhodium section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"\"over 90% of gross demand in 2020-2021\"; JM: rhodium demand \"usually relatively price inelastic\""},{"id":"P0040","domain":"economics","parameter":"rhodium content lower limit in glass-fibre bushings before 2020-21 thrifting","scope":"rhodium, glass industry","value":"10","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/PGM-market-report-May-2022.pdf/542bcada-f4ac-a673-5f95-ad1bbfca5106","locator":"JM May 2022, rhodium section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"high prices drove some fibreglass firms below 10% Rh; documented thrifting response"},{"id":"P0041","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price change 2022 to 2023, rhodium","scope":"rhodium, US (Engelhard)","value":"-57","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2023","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM, p.1 (15,585.00 to 6,660.58)","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":""},{"id":"P0042","domain":"economics","parameter":"primary supply, iridium","scope":"iridium, world","value":"7.1","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.33 Iridium supply and demand: Tonnes","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"229 koz"},{"id":"P0043","domain":"economics","parameter":"total demand, iridium","scope":"iridium, world","value":"7.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.33 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"electrochemical 3.1 t; chemical 1.1 t; electrical 1.0 t; other 2.1 t"},{"id":"P0044","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price, iridium","scope":"iridium, US (Engelhard)","value":"4400","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"estimate; 2024 = 4,810.40"},{"id":"P0045","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr minimum, iridium","scope":"iridium, US (Engelhard)","value":"586.90","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2016","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2021/mcs2021-platinum.pdf","locator":"MCS 2021 PGM, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0046","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr maximum, iridium","scope":"iridium, US (Engelhard)","value":"5158.40","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2021 price more than tripled vs 2020 (MCS 2022)"},{"id":"P0047","domain":"economics","parameter":"primary supply, ruthenium","scope":"ruthenium, world","value":"30.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.32 Ruthenium supply and demand: Tonnes","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"972 koz"},{"id":"P0048","domain":"economics","parameter":"total demand, ruthenium","scope":"ruthenium, world","value":"39.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matthey.com/documents/161599/509428/pgm-market-report-26.pdf/a2d115af-bf7c-f589-29e9-6beacf8a4452","locator":"JM May 2026, p.32 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"chemical 17.6 t; electrical 12.8 t; electrochemical 4.2 t; deficit met from stocks (-9.1 t)"},{"id":"P0049","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price, ruthenium","scope":"ruthenium, US (Engelhard)","value":"690","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"estimate; 2024 = 451.02"},{"id":"P0050","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr minimum, ruthenium","scope":"ruthenium, US (Engelhard)","value":"42.00","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2016","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2021/mcs2021-platinum.pdf","locator":"MCS 2021 PGM, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0051","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr maximum, ruthenium","scope":"ruthenium, US (Engelhard)","value":"690","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2025 estimate; next highest 577.02 (2022)"},{"id":"P0052","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price per kg, platinum","scope":"platinum, US (Engelhard)","value":"38581","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM p.1; 1 kg = 32.1507 troy oz","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"from 1200 USD/troy oz"},{"id":"P0053","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price per kg, palladium","scope":"palladium, US (Engelhard)","value":"35366","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM p.1; 1 kg = 32.1507 troy oz","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"from 1100 USD/troy oz"},{"id":"P0054","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price per kg, rhodium","scope":"rhodium, US (Engelhard)","value":"186474","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM p.1; 1 kg = 32.1507 troy oz","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"from 5800 USD/troy oz"},{"id":"P0055","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price per kg, iridium","scope":"iridium, US (Engelhard)","value":"141463","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM p.1; 1 kg = 32.1507 troy oz","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"from 4400 USD/troy oz"},{"id":"P0056","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price per kg, ruthenium","scope":"ruthenium, US (Engelhard)","value":"22184","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-platinum-group.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 PGM p.1; 1 kg = 32.1507 troy oz","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"from 690 USD/troy oz"},{"id":"P0057","domain":"economics","parameter":"world mine production, gold","scope":"gold, world","value":"3300","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-gold.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Gold, p.2 World Mine Production table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"USGS estimate; conflicts with WGC/Metals Focus 3,671.6 t for 2025"},{"id":"P0058","domain":"economics","parameter":"world mine production, gold (WGC)","scope":"gold, world","value":"3671.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/20432/GDT-Full-Year-2025-Exec-Summary.pdf","locator":"WGC Gold Demand Trends FY2025 Exec Summary, supply-demand table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"conflict","note":"conflicts with USGS 3,300 t; WGC data by Metals Focus"},{"id":"P0059","domain":"economics","parameter":"mine production share, top five countries","scope":"gold, world","value":"41","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-gold.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Gold, p.1 Events","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"China, Russia, Australia, Canada, US; China alone 380 t = 11.5%"},{"id":"P0060","domain":"economics","parameter":"recycled gold supply","scope":"gold, world","value":"1404.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/20432/GDT-Full-Year-2025-Exec-Summary.pdf","locator":"WGC FY2025 Exec Summary, supply-demand table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"2024 = 1,365.3 t"},{"id":"P0061","domain":"economics","parameter":"jewellery consumption, gold","scope":"gold, world","value":"1542.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/20432/GDT-Full-Year-2025-Exec-Summary.pdf","locator":"WGC FY2025 Exec Summary, table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"2024 = 1,886.9 t (-18%)"},{"id":"P0062","domain":"economics","parameter":"technology demand, gold","scope":"gold, world","value":"322.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/20432/GDT-Full-Year-2025-Exec-Summary.pdf","locator":"WGC FY2025 Exec Summary, table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"electronics 270.4 t"},{"id":"P0063","domain":"economics","parameter":"bar and coin investment demand, gold","scope":"gold, world","value":"1374.1","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/20432/GDT-Full-Year-2025-Exec-Summary.pdf","locator":"WGC FY2025 Exec Summary, table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0064","domain":"economics","parameter":"ETF net inflows, gold","scope":"gold, world","value":"801.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/20432/GDT-Full-Year-2025-Exec-Summary.pdf","locator":"WGC FY2025 Exec Summary, table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0065","domain":"economics","parameter":"central bank net purchases, gold","scope":"gold, world","value":"863.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/20432/GDT-Full-Year-2025-Exec-Summary.pdf","locator":"WGC FY2025 Exec Summary, table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0066","domain":"economics","parameter":"total demand, gold","scope":"gold, world","value":"5002.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/20432/GDT-Full-Year-2025-Exec-Summary.pdf","locator":"WGC FY2025 Exec Summary, table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0067","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price, gold (LBMA PM)","scope":"gold, world","value":"3431.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/20432/GDT-Full-Year-2025-Exec-Summary.pdf","locator":"WGC FY2025 Exec Summary, table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"USGS Engelhard Jan-Nov estimate 3,300; difference reflects benchmark and months covered"},{"id":"P0068","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price, gold (Engelhard)","scope":"gold, US","value":"3300","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-gold.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Gold, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"estimate based on Jan-Nov; 2024 = 2,388"},{"id":"P0069","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr minimum, gold","scope":"gold, US (Engelhard)","value":"1252","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2016","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2021/mcs2021-gold.pdf","locator":"MCS 2021 Gold, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"World Bank 2016 = 1,248.99"},{"id":"P0070","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr maximum, gold","scope":"gold, US (Engelhard)","value":"3300","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/troy oz","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-gold.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Gold, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0071","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price per kg, gold","scope":"gold, world (LBMA)","value":"110326","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/20432/GDT-Full-Year-2025-Exec-Summary.pdf","locator":"WGC FY2025 table; 1 kg = 32.1507 troy oz","verification":"derived","bias":"advocacy","status":"must-check","note":"3,431.5 x 32.1507"},{"id":"P0072","domain":"economics","parameter":"price elasticity of jewellery fabrication demand, gold","scope":"gold, world","value":"-0.87","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity","year":"2001","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.lbma.org.uk/alchemist/issue-22/the-elasticity-of-jewellery-demand","locator":"LBMA Alchemist issue 22, Murenbeeld","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"must-check","note":"WGC-funded world model; data period and specification not on page (box missing); real local-currency price; India \"very price-elastic\""},{"id":"P0073","domain":"economics","parameter":"jewellery consumption arc response to price 2024-25, gold","scope":"gold, world","value":"-0.56","low":"","high":"","unit":"ratio (dlnQ/dlnP)","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/20432/GDT-Full-Year-2025-Exec-Summary.pdf","locator":"WGC FY2025 table (1,886.9 to 1,542.3 t; 2,386.2 to 3,431.5 USD/oz)","verification":"derived","bias":"advocacy","status":"must-check","note":"descriptive, confounded by investment boom; not an identified elasticity"},{"id":"P0074","domain":"economics","parameter":"recycling arc response to price 2024-25, gold","scope":"gold, world","value":"0.08","low":"","high":"","unit":"ratio (dlnQ/dlnP)","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/20432/GDT-Full-Year-2025-Exec-Summary.pdf","locator":"WGC FY2025 table (1,365.3 to 1,404.3 t)","verification":"derived","bias":"advocacy","status":"must-check","note":"WGC calls it \"a relatively muted response\"; descriptive only"},{"id":"P0075","domain":"economics","parameter":"world helium production","scope":"helium, world","value":"190","low":"","high":"","unit":"million m3","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-helium.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Helium, p.2 World Production table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"estimate; 2024 = 183"},{"id":"P0076","domain":"economics","parameter":"world helium production in mass","scope":"helium, world","value":"32200","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-helium.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Helium p.2 footnote 1 (27.737 m3 = 0.0047 t)","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"190e6 m3 x 0.0047/27.737 t"},{"id":"P0077","domain":"economics","parameter":"helium production share, United States","scope":"helium, world","value":"42.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-helium.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Helium p.2 table","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"81/190; Qatar 33.2% (63), Russia 9.5% (18), Algeria 5.8% (11)"},{"id":"P0078","domain":"economics","parameter":"Grade-A helium base price","scope":"helium, US","value":"12","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/m3","year":"2025","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-helium.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Helium, p.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"$330 per thousand cubic feet; producers post surcharges; excl. transport"},{"id":"P0079","domain":"economics","parameter":"Grade-A helium base price","scope":"helium, US","value":"14","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/m3","year":"2024","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2025/mcs2025-helium.pdf","locator":"MCS 2025 Helium, p.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"$390/Mcf; 2023 also $14 (MCS 2024); 2022 $11 (MCS 2023)"},{"id":"P0080","domain":"economics","parameter":"Grade-A helium base price, pre-shortage level","scope":"helium, US","value":"7.57","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/m3","year":"2021","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2022/mcs2022-helium.pdf","locator":"MCS 2022 Helium, p.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"$210/Mcf, same in FY2020 (MCS 2021); rise to $14 in 2023-24 = +85%"},{"id":"P0081","domain":"economics","parameter":"Grade-A helium base price per kg","scope":"helium, US","value":"71","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-helium.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Helium p.1-2","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"12 USD/m3 / 0.1694 kg/m3"},{"id":"P0082","domain":"economics","parameter":"US helium end use share, analytical/lab/specialty gases","scope":"helium, US","value":"22","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-helium.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Helium, p.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"semiconductors/fiber/controlled atmospheres 17%, lifting 17%, MRI 15%, aerospace 9%, welding 8%"},{"id":"P0083","domain":"economics","parameter":"world helium-3 production","scope":"helium-3, world","value":"40000","low":"","high":"","unit":"litres (STP)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-helium.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Helium, p.2 World Production","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"USGS estimate for 2024 and 2025; mostly Canada, Russia, US (tritium decay)"},{"id":"P0084","domain":"economics","parameter":"helium-3 world production in mass","scope":"helium-3, world","value":"5.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-helium.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Helium p.2; 3.016 g/mol / 22.414 L/mol","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"40,000 L x 0.1346 g/L"},{"id":"P0085","domain":"economics","parameter":"new helium-3 from US tritium decay","scope":"helium-3, US","value":"8000","low":"","high":"","unit":"litres/yr","year":"2011","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20111006_R41419_7303f1d7c70786db47dd2aa18ba24f7a85e9c23d.html","locator":"CRS R41419 (6 Oct 2011), Federal Response > Current Supply","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0086","domain":"economics","parameter":"helium-3 demand at 2008 peak","scope":"helium-3, US","value":"80000","low":"","high":"","unit":"litres/yr","year":"2008","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20111006_R41419_7303f1d7c70786db47dd2aa18ba24f7a85e9c23d.html","locator":"CRS R41419, Helium-3 Demand","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"DOE Isotope Program page gives 70,000 L/yr peak in 2008"},{"id":"P0087","domain":"economics","parameter":"helium-3 demand at 2008 peak (DOE)","scope":"helium-3, US","value":"70000","low":"","high":"","unit":"litres/yr","year":"2008","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.isotopes.gov/Supply-and-Demand-of-Helium-3","locator":"isotopes.gov Supply and Demand of He-3 (undated)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"conflict","note":"conflicts with CRS 80,000 L"},{"id":"P0088","domain":"economics","parameter":"projected federal helium-3 demand","scope":"helium-3, US","value":"6000","low":"","high":"","unit":"litres/yr","year":"","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.isotopes.gov/Supply-and-Demand-of-Helium-3","locator":"isotopes.gov Supply and Demand of He-3 (undated page, accessed 2026-11-09)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"year of figure unknown; \"less than 6,000 liters per year\"; upper bound; DOE says earlier shortage mitigated"},{"id":"P0089","domain":"economics","parameter":"US helium-3 stockpile, peak","scope":"helium-3, US","value":"235000","low":"","high":"","unit":"litres","year":"2001","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20111006_R41419_7303f1d7c70786db47dd2aa18ba24f7a85e9c23d.html","locator":"CRS R41419, Figure 1 discussion","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"~140,000 L in 1990; ~50,000 L in 2010"},{"id":"P0090","domain":"economics","parameter":"US helium-3 stockpile after drawdown","scope":"helium-3, US","value":"50000","low":"","high":"","unit":"litres","year":"2010","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20111006_R41419_7303f1d7c70786db47dd2aa18ba24f7a85e9c23d.html","locator":"CRS R41419, Current Supply","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0091","domain":"economics","parameter":"helium-3 historical auction price","scope":"helium-3, US","value":"62.5","low":"40","high":"85","unit":"USD/litre","year":"2008","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20111006_R41419_7303f1d7c70786db47dd2aa18ba24f7a85e9c23d.html","locator":"CRS R41419, How Do Consumers Obtain Supplies?","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"same report elsewhere gives historical market price $100-200/L"},{"id":"P0092","domain":"economics","parameter":"helium-3 allocated price, commercial users","scope":"helium-3, US","value":"1000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/litre","year":"2011","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20111006_R41419_7303f1d7c70786db47dd2aa18ba24f7a85e9c23d.html","locator":"CRS R41419, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"federal users $600; medical cGMP $720; 2009 all users $450; 2010 $365"},{"id":"P0093","domain":"economics","parameter":"helium-3 commercial price after shortage","scope":"helium-3, US","value":"2000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/litre","year":"2010","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20111006_R41419_7303f1d7c70786db47dd2aa18ba24f7a85e9c23d.html","locator":"CRS R41419, footnote 15","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"\"up to $2,000 per liter or more\"; 10x+ historical norm: documented shortage price response"},{"id":"P0094","domain":"economics","parameter":"marginal cost of helium-3 via dedicated tritium production","scope":"helium-3, US","value":"14500","low":"11000","high":"18000","unit":"USD/litre","year":"2011","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20111006_R41419_7303f1d7c70786db47dd2aa18ba24f7a85e9c23d.html","locator":"CRS R41419, Tritium from Light-Water Reactors","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"unsubsidised tritium $84,000-130,000/g"},{"id":"P0095","domain":"economics","parameter":"Russian helium-3 exports to US","scope":"helium-3, Russia","value":"25000","low":"","high":"","unit":"litres/yr","year":"2008","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20111006_R41419_7303f1d7c70786db47dd2aa18ba24f7a85e9c23d.html","locator":"CRS R41419, Import Helium-3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2004-2008 average; reduced exports contributed to 2008 shortage"},{"id":"P0096","domain":"economics","parameter":"helium-3 separable from US natural-gas helium","scope":"helium-3, US","value":"26000","low":"","high":"","unit":"litres/yr","year":"2011","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20111006_R41419_7303f1d7c70786db47dd2aa18ba24f7a85e9c23d.html","locator":"CRS R41419, Helium-3 from Natural Gas","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"cost estimates range $34 to $12,000 per litre excl. plant"},{"id":"P0097","domain":"economics","parameter":"DOE Isotope Program purchase of lunar helium-3","scope":"helium-3, Moon to Earth","value":"3","low":"","high":"","unit":"litres","year":"2029","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.interlune.space/press-release/u-s-department-of-energy-buys-helium-3-from-u-s-space-resources-company-interlune-in-historic-agreement","locator":"Interlune press release 7 May 2025","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"delivery by April 2029 at \"approximately today's commercial market price\"; price not disclosed"},{"id":"P0098","domain":"economics","parameter":"helium-3 current market price","scope":"helium-3, world","value":"2500","low":"2000","high":"3000","unit":"USD/litre","year":"2025","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://pulsarhelium.com/plsr-3he-discovery/about-3he/default.aspx","locator":"Pulsar Helium About 3He page (search snippet)","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"snippet: $2,000-2,500/L attributed to DOE IP; Interlune CEO reportedly ~$3,000/L (news snippet); no DOE document found"},{"id":"P0099","domain":"economics","parameter":"world rare-earth mine production","scope":"rare earths (REO), world","value":"390000","low":"","high":"","unit":"t REO","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-rare-earths.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Rare Earths, p.2 World Mine Production table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"estimate; 2024 = 380,000 t"},{"id":"P0100","domain":"economics","parameter":"mine production share, China","scope":"rare earths (REO), world","value":"69.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-rare-earths.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Rare Earths p.2 table","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"270,000/390,000; US 13.1% (51,000), Australia 7.4%, Burma 5.6%"},{"id":"P0101","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price, NdPr oxide 99%","scope":"neodymium-praseodymium, FOB","value":"69","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-rare-earths.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Rare Earths, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Argus FOB; 2024 = 55; 2022 = 124"},{"id":"P0102","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price, Nd oxide 99.5%","scope":"neodymium, FOB","value":"73","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-rare-earths.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Rare Earths, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2024 = 56"},{"id":"P0103","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr minimum, Nd oxide","scope":"neodymium, FOB","value":"40","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2016","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2021/mcs2021-rare-earths.pdf","locator":"MCS 2021 Rare Earths, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0104","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr maximum, Nd oxide","scope":"neodymium, FOB","value":"134","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2022","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-rare-earths.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Rare Earths, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0105","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price, Dy oxide 99.5%","scope":"dysprosium, FOB","value":"239","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-rare-earths-heavy.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Rare Earths (Heavy), p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Argus/Asian Metal FOB; 2024 = 257; China April 2025 export controls on Dy"},{"id":"P0106","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr minimum, Dy oxide","scope":"dysprosium, FOB","value":"179","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2018","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2021/mcs2021-rare-earths.pdf","locator":"MCS 2021 Rare Earths, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0107","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr maximum, Dy oxide","scope":"dysprosium, FOB","value":"410","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-rare-earths-heavy.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Rare Earths (Heavy), p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0108","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price, Tb oxide 99.99%","scope":"terbium, FOB","value":"1010","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-rare-earths-heavy.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Rare Earths (Heavy), p.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2022 peak 2,050"},{"id":"P0109","domain":"economics","parameter":"China rare-earth export quota","scope":"rare earths, China","value":"30259","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2010","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R41347.html","locator":"CRS R41347 (16 Dec 2013), Table 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2009 = 50,145 t (-40%); 2011 = 30,246; 2012-13 = 31,438"},{"id":"P0110","domain":"economics","parameter":"Dy metal price, start of 2010-11 spike","scope":"dysprosium metal","value":"250","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2010","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R41347.html","locator":"CRS R41347, Figure 3 notes (METI)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"April 2010"},{"id":"P0111","domain":"economics","parameter":"Dy metal price, peak of 2010-11 spike","scope":"dysprosium metal","value":"2840","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2011","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R41347.html","locator":"CRS R41347, Figure 3 notes (METI)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"July 2011; 11x April 2010"},{"id":"P0112","domain":"economics","parameter":"Nd metal price, peak of 2010-11 spike","scope":"neodymium metal","value":"334","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2011","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R41347.html","locator":"CRS R41347, Figure 3 notes (METI)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"July 2011; April 2010 = $42/kg (8x)"},{"id":"P0113","domain":"economics","parameter":"Dy oxide monthly price, peak of 2010-11 spike","scope":"dysprosium oxide, China FOB","value":"2377","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2011","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.adamasintel.com/rare-earth-export-restrictions-price-spikes-and-the-risk-of-demand-destruction/","locator":"Adamas Intelligence article 21 Apr 2025 (public excerpt)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"August 2011; Jan 2009 = $91/kg (26-fold)"},{"id":"P0114","domain":"economics","parameter":"China share of world rare-earth mine production","scope":"rare earths, world","value":"95","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2011","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R41347.html","locator":"CRS R41347, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"USGS 2012: 86%"},{"id":"P0115","domain":"economics","parameter":"world cobalt mine production","scope":"cobalt, world","value":"310000","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-cobalt.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Cobalt, p.2 World Mine Production table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"estimate; 2024 = 302,000 t"},{"id":"P0116","domain":"economics","parameter":"mine production share, Congo (Kinshasa)","scope":"cobalt, world","value":"73","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-cobalt.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Cobalt, p.2 Events","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Indonesia 14%"},{"id":"P0117","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price, cobalt LME cash","scope":"cobalt, world","value":"15","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/lb","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-cobalt.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Cobalt, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"estimate; = 33 USD/kg; US spot cathode 21 USD/lb; 2024 LME 11.84"},{"id":"P0118","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr minimum, cobalt LME cash","scope":"cobalt, world","value":"11.57","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/lb","year":"2016","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2021/mcs2021-cobalt.pdf","locator":"MCS 2021 Cobalt, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0119","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr maximum, cobalt LME cash","scope":"cobalt, world","value":"32.94","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/lb","year":"2018","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2021/mcs2021-cobalt.pdf","locator":"MCS 2021 Cobalt, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0120","domain":"economics","parameter":"US cobalt recycling share of consumption","scope":"cobalt, US","value":"25","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-cobalt.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Cobalt, p.1 Recycling","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"cobalt content of purchased scrap; global figure not given"},{"id":"P0121","domain":"economics","parameter":"US cobalt end use share, superalloys","scope":"cobalt, US","value":"51","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-cobalt.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Cobalt, p.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"chemicals 25%, other metallic 15%, carbides 9%; global leading use is Li-ion batteries"},{"id":"P0122","domain":"economics","parameter":"DRC cobalt export quota","scope":"cobalt, Congo (Kinshasa)","value":"96600","low":"","high":"","unit":"t/yr","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-cobalt.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Cobalt, p.2 Events","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2026-27; incl. 9,600 t strategic reserve; Feb-Oct 2025 export ban; 18,125 t for rest of 2025"},{"id":"P0123","domain":"economics","parameter":"cobalt LME price change 2024 to 2025 (DRC export ban)","scope":"cobalt, world","value":"27","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-cobalt.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Cobalt p.1 (11.84 to 15 USD/lb)","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"supply-shock response; annual averages, 2025 estimate"},{"id":"P0124","domain":"economics","parameter":"price elasticity of supply, cobalt, same year","scope":"cobalt, world","value":"0.32","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity","year":"2020","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/110364/1/MPRA_paper_110364.pdf","locator":"Boer, Pescatori, Stuermer (2021) IMF WP/21/243, Sec. 4.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"SVAR, annual 1925-2020, metal-specific demand shock; B0 impact estimate 0.28 [0.21, 0.37] 68% band"},{"id":"P0125","domain":"economics","parameter":"price elasticity of supply, cobalt, 20 years","scope":"cobalt, world","value":"0.86","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity","year":"2020","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/110364/1/MPRA_paper_110364.pdf","locator":"Boer et al. (2021), Sec. 4.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"10% price shock raises output 8.6% after 20 years"},{"id":"P0126","domain":"economics","parameter":"price elasticity of demand, cobalt (post-2013 break)","scope":"cobalt, world","value":"-0.45","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity","year":"2024","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/publication/70261914","locator":"Shojaeddini, Alonso, Nassar (2024) RCR 207:107664, abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2SLS; demand less elastic after structural break in 2013; data period not on abstract page"},{"id":"P0127","domain":"economics","parameter":"world nickel mine production","scope":"nickel, world","value":"3900000","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-nickel.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Nickel, p.2 World Mine Production table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"estimate; 2024 = 3,710,000 t"},{"id":"P0128","domain":"economics","parameter":"mine production share, Indonesia","scope":"nickel, world","value":"66.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-nickel.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Nickel p.2 table","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"2,600,000/3,900,000; Philippines 6.9%, Russia 5.1%, Canada 3.6%, New Caledonia 3.6%"},{"id":"P0129","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price, nickel LME cash","scope":"nickel, world","value":"15000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-nickel.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Nickel, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"estimate; 2024 = 16,812"},{"id":"P0130","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr minimum, nickel LME cash","scope":"nickel, world","value":"9594","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/t","year":"2016","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2021/mcs2021-nickel.pdf","locator":"MCS 2021 Nickel, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"World Bank 2016 = 9,595.18"},{"id":"P0131","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr maximum, nickel LME cash","scope":"nickel, world","value":"25815","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/t","year":"2022","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-nickel.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Nickel, p.1 Salient Statistics","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2022: +35% vs 2021; LME trading disrupted ~2 weeks in March 2022 after Russia-Ukraine (MCS 2023)"},{"id":"P0132","domain":"economics","parameter":"primary nickel market surplus","scope":"nickel, world","value":"182000","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-nickel.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Nickel, p.1 Events (INSG)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"98,500 t 2022; 170,000 t 2023; 189,000 t first 9 months 2025"},{"id":"P0133","domain":"economics","parameter":"price elasticity of supply, nickel, same year","scope":"nickel, world","value":"0.71","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity","year":"2020","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/110364/1/MPRA_paper_110364.pdf","locator":"Boer et al. (2021) IMF WP/21/243, Sec. 4.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"SVAR annual 1900-2020; B0 impact 0.62 [0.49, 0.79]"},{"id":"P0134","domain":"economics","parameter":"price elasticity of supply, nickel, 20 years","scope":"nickel, world","value":"1.30","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity","year":"2020","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/110364/1/MPRA_paper_110364.pdf","locator":"Boer et al. (2021), Sec. 4.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0135","domain":"economics","parameter":"price elasticity of demand, nickel (post-2009 break)","scope":"nickel, world","value":"-0.09","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity","year":"2024","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/publication/70261914","locator":"Shojaeddini et al. (2024) RCR 207:107664, abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2SLS; structural break 2009"},{"id":"P0136","domain":"economics","parameter":"price elasticity of per-capita demand, nickel, North America","scope":"nickel, North America","value":"-0.22","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity","year":"2015","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ideas.repec.org/a/eee/jrpoli/v59y2018icp160-183.html","locator":"Fernandez (2018) Resources Policy 59:160-183, abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Divisia-moment; regional 1980-2015; Africa -0.46, Oceania -0.23, Middle East -0.63"},{"id":"P0137","domain":"economics","parameter":"price elasticity of per-capita demand, nickel, Middle East","scope":"nickel, Middle East","value":"-0.63","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity","year":"2015","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ideas.repec.org/a/eee/jrpoli/v59y2018icp160-183.html","locator":"Fernandez (2018), abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"most elastic regional nickel estimate in the paper"},{"id":"P0138","domain":"economics","parameter":"world iron ore production, usable ore","scope":"iron ore, world","value":"2600","low":"","high":"","unit":"Mt","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-iron-ore.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Iron Ore, p.2 World Mine Production table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"iron content 1,600 Mt"},{"id":"P0139","domain":"economics","parameter":"mine production share, Australia","scope":"iron ore, world","value":"37.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-iron-ore.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Iron Ore p.2 table","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"980/2,600 Mt; Brazil 16.2%, India 11.9%, China 11.2%, Russia 3.3%"},{"id":"P0140","domain":"economics","parameter":"iron ore price, 62% Fe fines CFR Tianjin, Jan-Sep average","scope":"iron ore, China import","value":"99.07","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2026/mcs2026-iron-ore.pdf","locator":"MCS 2026 Iron Ore, p.1 Events","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"same period 2024 = 112.07"},{"id":"P0141","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price, iron ore CFR spot (World Bank)","scope":"iron ore, China import","value":"109.40","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/dmtu","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://thedocs.worldbank.org/en/doc/5d903e848db1d1b83e0ec8f744e55570-0350012021/related/CMO-Historical-Data-Annual.xlsx","locator":"Pink Sheet annual, col Iron ore cfr spot","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0142","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr minimum, iron ore CFR spot","scope":"iron ore, China import","value":"55.85","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/dmtu","year":"2015","method":"measured","source_url":"https://thedocs.worldbank.org/en/doc/5d903e848db1d1b83e0ec8f744e55570-0350012021/related/CMO-Historical-Data-Annual.xlsx","locator":"Pink Sheet annual, col Iron ore cfr spot","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"window 2015-2024"},{"id":"P0143","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual average price 10-yr maximum, iron ore CFR spot","scope":"iron ore, China import","value":"161.71","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/dmtu","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://thedocs.worldbank.org/en/doc/5d903e848db1d1b83e0ec8f744e55570-0350012021/related/CMO-Historical-Data-Annual.xlsx","locator":"Pink Sheet annual, col Iron ore cfr spot","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0144","domain":"economics","parameter":"price elasticity of demand, iron ore","scope":"iron ore, world","value":"-0.24","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity","year":"2012","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://saber.eaber.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/2015/04/EABER-Working-Paper-94-Hurst.pdf","locator":"Hurst, EABER WP 94, footnote 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"secondary citation of Zhu (2012) unpublished Duke honours thesis; primary not opened"},{"id":"P0145","domain":"economics","parameter":"price elasticity of supply, iron ore","scope":"iron ore, world","value":"0.45","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity","year":"2012","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://saber.eaber.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/2015/04/EABER-Working-Paper-94-Hurst.pdf","locator":"Hurst, EABER WP 94, p.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"secondary citation, attributed ambiguously to Zhu (2012) \"in Maasoumi et al., 2002\""},{"id":"P0146","domain":"economics","parameter":"mean literature price elasticity of demand, minerals","scope":"non-fuel minerals, pooled","value":"-0.148","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://economix.fr/pdf/dt/2026/WP_EcoX_2026-12.pdf","locator":"Capliez, Grekou, Hache, Mignon (2026) EconomiX WP 2026-12, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"SD 0.279, N=525 estimates; 61.9% not significant; literature survey"},{"id":"P0147","domain":"economics","parameter":"mean literature price elasticity of supply, minerals","scope":"non-fuel minerals, pooled","value":"0.330","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://economix.fr/pdf/dt/2026/WP_EcoX_2026-12.pdf","locator":"Capliez et al. (2026), Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"SD 0.461, N=182; 6.59% exceed 1 in absolute value"},{"id":"P0148","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg to LEO","scope":"Space Shuttle","value":"61720","low":"54500","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200001093/downloads/20200001093.pdf","locator":"Table A2, p.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Jones divides cost per launch (USD 1,697M, 2018 USD) by 27,500 kg LEO payload. Abstract uses USD 1.5B/27,500 kg = USD 54,500/kg; CSIS gives 65,400 USD(2021)/kg."},{"id":"P0149","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch price per kg to LEO (advertised)","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"2720","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"derived","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200001093/downloads/20200001093.pdf","locator":"Abstract p.1; Table A2 p.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Jones: advertised USD 62M / 22,800 kg (expendable max LEO). Arithmetic on list price, not a per-kg offer."},{"id":"P0150","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch price per kg to LEO (advertised)","scope":"Falcon Heavy","value":"1410","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"derived","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200001093/downloads/20200001093.pdf","locator":"Table A2, p.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Jones: USD 90M per launch over max LEO payload (63,800 kg)."},{"id":"P0151","domain":"economics","parameter":"average launch cost per kg to LEO, systems first flown 1970-2000","scope":"global launch market 1970-2000","value":"18500","low":"10000","high":"32000","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200001093/downloads/20200001093.pdf","locator":"p.2 (Fig. 1 text)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Typical range USD 10-32k/kg; 7 of 22 systems below 10k/kg, all Soviet or Chinese and possibly subsidised."},{"id":"P0152","domain":"economics","parameter":"cargo cost per kg to ISS","scope":"Space Shuttle to ISS","value":"105800","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200001093/downloads/20200001093.pdf","locator":"Table 1, p.3; App. B p.9","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"USD 1,697M / 16,050 kg ISS payload."},{"id":"P0153","domain":"economics","parameter":"cargo cost per kg to ISS","scope":"Falcon 9 + Dragon (CRS) to ISS","value":"25000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"contract","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200001093/downloads/20200001093.pdf","locator":"Table 1, p.3; App. B p.9","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"About USD 150M per CRS mission (2018 USD) / 6,000 kg; based on 2008 CRS contract USD 1.6B for 12 flights and 2015 extension estimates."},{"id":"P0154","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg to LEO","scope":"Ariane 5G","value":"13100","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200001093/downloads/20200001093.pdf","locator":"Table A1, p.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Jones Table A1, CPI-adjusted to 2018 USD; original source Futron 2002."},{"id":"P0155","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg to LEO","scope":"Soyuz","value":"7600","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200001093/downloads/20200001093.pdf","locator":"Table A1, p.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"Jones Table A1, CPI-adjusted to 2018 USD; original source Futron 2002. CSIS gives 17,900 USD(2021)/kg for Soyuz; the two series disagree by >2x beyond inflation."},{"id":"P0156","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg to LEO","scope":"Long March 3B","value":"6300","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200001093/downloads/20200001093.pdf","locator":"Table A1, p.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Jones Table A1, CPI-adjusted to 2018 USD; original source Futron 2002."},{"id":"P0157","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg to LEO","scope":"Vega","value":"10000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200001093/downloads/20200001093.pdf","locator":"Table A1, p.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"Jones Table A1, CPI-adjusted to 2018 USD; original source Wikipedia 2018. CSIS gives 20,000 USD(2021)/kg for Vega."},{"id":"P0158","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg to LEO (dedicated)","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"2600","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/kg","year":"2010","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/cost-space-launches-low-earth-orbit","locator":"OWID grapher CSV row; CSIS data page chart","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"CSIS Aerospace Security dataset (Roberts, updated 2022-09-01) via OWID CSV; dedicated launch, median total launch cost / max LEO capacity, constant 2021 USD; year column = first successful launch (2010)."},{"id":"P0159","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg to LEO (dedicated)","scope":"Falcon Heavy","value":"1500","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/kg","year":"2018","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/cost-space-launches-low-earth-orbit","locator":"OWID grapher CSV row; CSIS data page chart","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"CSIS Aerospace Security dataset (Roberts, updated 2022-09-01) via OWID CSV; dedicated launch, median total launch cost / max LEO capacity, constant 2021 USD; year column = first successful launch (2018)."},{"id":"P0160","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg to LEO (dedicated)","scope":"Electron","value":"23100","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/kg","year":"2018","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/cost-space-launches-low-earth-orbit","locator":"OWID grapher CSV row; CSIS data page chart","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"CSIS Aerospace Security dataset (Roberts, updated 2022-09-01) via OWID CSV; dedicated launch, median total launch cost / max LEO capacity, constant 2021 USD; year column = first successful launch (2018)."},{"id":"P0161","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg to LEO (dedicated)","scope":"Space Shuttle","value":"65400","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/kg","year":"1981","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/cost-space-launches-low-earth-orbit","locator":"OWID grapher CSV row; CSIS data page chart","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"CSIS Aerospace Security dataset (Roberts, updated 2022-09-01) via OWID CSV; dedicated launch, median total launch cost / max LEO capacity, constant 2021 USD; year column = first successful launch (1981)."},{"id":"P0162","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg to LEO (dedicated)","scope":"Atlas V","value":"8100","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/kg","year":"2002","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/cost-space-launches-low-earth-orbit","locator":"OWID grapher CSV row; CSIS data page chart","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"CSIS Aerospace Security dataset (Roberts, updated 2022-09-01) via OWID CSV; dedicated launch, median total launch cost / max LEO capacity, constant 2021 USD; year column = first successful launch (2002)."},{"id":"P0163","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg to LEO (dedicated)","scope":"Ariane 5G","value":"10200","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/kg","year":"1997","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/cost-space-launches-low-earth-orbit","locator":"OWID grapher CSV row; CSIS data page chart","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"CSIS Aerospace Security dataset (Roberts, updated 2022-09-01) via OWID CSV; dedicated launch, median total launch cost / max LEO capacity, constant 2021 USD; year column = first successful launch (1997)."},{"id":"P0164","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg to LEO (dedicated)","scope":"Long March 3B","value":"6200","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/kg","year":"1997","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/cost-space-launches-low-earth-orbit","locator":"OWID grapher CSV row; CSIS data page chart","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"CSIS Aerospace Security dataset (Roberts, updated 2022-09-01) via OWID CSV; dedicated launch, median total launch cost / max LEO capacity, constant 2021 USD; year column = first successful launch (1997)."},{"id":"P0165","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg to LEO (dedicated)","scope":"Long March 5","value":"7900","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/kg","year":"2016","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/cost-space-launches-low-earth-orbit","locator":"OWID grapher CSV row; CSIS data page chart","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"CSIS Aerospace Security dataset (Roberts, updated 2022-09-01) via OWID CSV; dedicated launch, median total launch cost / max LEO capacity, constant 2021 USD; year column = first successful launch (2016)."},{"id":"P0166","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg to LEO (dedicated)","scope":"Soyuz","value":"17900","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/kg","year":"1966","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/cost-space-launches-low-earth-orbit","locator":"OWID grapher CSV row; CSIS data page chart","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"CSIS Aerospace Security dataset (Roberts, updated 2022-09-01) via OWID CSV; dedicated launch, median total launch cost / max LEO capacity, constant 2021 USD; year column = first successful launch (1966). Jones 2018 Table A1 gives much lower Soyuz 7,600 / Vega 10,000 USD(2018)/kg."},{"id":"P0167","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg to LEO (dedicated)","scope":"Vega","value":"20000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/kg","year":"2012","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/cost-space-launches-low-earth-orbit","locator":"OWID grapher CSV row; CSIS data page chart","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"CSIS Aerospace Security dataset (Roberts, updated 2022-09-01) via OWID CSV; dedicated launch, median total launch cost / max LEO capacity, constant 2021 USD; year column = first successful launch (2012). Jones 2018 Table A1 gives much lower Soyuz 7,600 / Vega 10,000 USD(2018)/kg."},{"id":"P0168","domain":"economics","parameter":"estimated price per launch","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"61200000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/launch","year":"2018","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/ast/media/2018_ast_compendium.pdf","locator":"Table 1, p.17","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"FAA AST lists 13,150 kg to LEO and 4,850 kg to GTO for this price (reusable configuration)."},{"id":"P0169","domain":"economics","parameter":"estimated price per launch","scope":"Falcon Heavy","value":"270000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/launch","year":"2018","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/ast/media/2018_ast_compendium.pdf","locator":"Table 2, p.17","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"FAA prints USD 270M with 63,800 kg LEO / 26,700 kg GTO (likely fully expendable); Jones 2018 uses SpaceX advertised USD 90M. Different configurations."},{"id":"P0170","domain":"economics","parameter":"estimated price per launch","scope":"Atlas V","value":"170000000","low":"110000000","high":"230000000","unit":"USD(2018)/launch","year":"2018","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/ast/media/2018_ast_compendium.pdf","locator":"Table 1, p.17","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Range USD 110-230M by configuration; value is midpoint."},{"id":"P0171","domain":"economics","parameter":"estimated price per launch","scope":"Electron","value":"4900000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/launch","year":"2018","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/ast/media/2018_ast_compendium.pdf","locator":"Table 1, p.17","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Printed in the GTO column of the table (layout error); 150 kg LEO capacity listed. Rocket Lab 2025 10-Q revenue per launch is USD 7-10M."},{"id":"P0172","domain":"economics","parameter":"estimated price per launch","scope":"Vulcan (projected, 2018)","value":"172500000","low":"85000000","high":"260000000","unit":"USD(2018)/launch","year":"2018","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/ast/media/2018_ast_compendium.pdf","locator":"Table 2, p.17","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Range USD 85-260M by configuration; value is midpoint."},{"id":"P0173","domain":"economics","parameter":"revenue per launch","scope":"Electron (Rocket Lab), Q2 2025","value":"7900000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2025)/launch","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1819994/000162828025038936/rklb-20250630.htm","locator":"10-Q Q2 2025, MD&A Launch Services","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Same filing: Q2 2024 USD 7.1M; cost per launch Q2 2025 USD 5.0M. Includes HASTE suborbital launches."},{"id":"P0174","domain":"economics","parameter":"revenue per launch","scope":"Electron (Rocket Lab), Q3 2025","value":"10100000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2025)/launch","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1819994/000181999425000021/rklb-20250930.htm","locator":"10-Q Q3 2025, MD&A Launch Services","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Q3 2024 USD 7.0M; company attributes increase to customer mix and mission complexity."},{"id":"P0175","domain":"economics","parameter":"revenue per launch","scope":"Electron (Rocket Lab), 9 months to Sep 2025","value":"8200000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2025)/launch","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1819994/000181999425000021/rklb-20250930.htm","locator":"10-Q Q3 2025, MD&A Launch Services","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"9M 2024: USD 7.5M."},{"id":"P0176","domain":"economics","parameter":"cost per launch","scope":"Electron (Rocket Lab), 9 months to Sep 2025","value":"5500000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2025)/launch","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1819994/000181999425000021/rklb-20250930.htm","locator":"10-Q Q3 2025, MD&A Launch Services","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"9M 2024 also USD 5.5M; Q3 2025 USD 5.9M."},{"id":"P0177","domain":"economics","parameter":"implied price per kg to LEO","scope":"Electron","value":"27300","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2025)/kg","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_orbital_launch_systems","locator":"derived","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"USD 8.2M revenue per launch (9M 2025 10-Q row) / 300 kg LEO (Wikipedia comparison table). Upper bound on capacity, so a floor on USD/kg."},{"id":"P0178","domain":"economics","parameter":"dedicated launch list price","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"74000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2026)/launch","year":"2026","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://keeptrack.space/deep-dive/how-much-does-a-falcon-9-launch-cost","locator":"section on list prices (article dated 2026-10-25)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Secondary: KeepTrack attributes to SpaceX Capabilities & Services page via Spaceflight Now (Feb 2026); covers up to 5.5 t to GTO. SpaceX PDF not reachable (404/bot block)."},{"id":"P0179","domain":"economics","parameter":"dedicated launch list price","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"70000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2025)/launch","year":"2025","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://keeptrack.space/deep-dive/how-much-does-a-falcon-9-launch-cost","locator":"section on list prices","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Secondary, no explicit citation in body."},{"id":"P0180","domain":"economics","parameter":"dedicated launch list price","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"67000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022)/launch","year":"2022","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://keeptrack.space/deep-dive/how-much-does-a-falcon-9-launch-cost","locator":"section on list prices","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Secondary; March 2022 inflation increase from USD 62M (Jones 2018 advertised USD 62M)."},{"id":"P0181","domain":"economics","parameter":"dedicated launch list price","scope":"Falcon Heavy","value":"97000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022)/launch","year":"2022","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://keeptrack.space/deep-dive/how-much-does-a-falcon-9-launch-cost","locator":"section on list prices","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Secondary, unsourced in article; up from USD 90M before March 2022."},{"id":"P0182","domain":"economics","parameter":"implied list price per kg to LEO (expendable max)","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"3246","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2026)/kg","year":"2026","method":"derived","source_url":"https://keeptrack.space/deep-dive/how-much-does-a-falcon-9-launch-cost","locator":"derived","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"USD 74M list (KeepTrack row) / 22,800 kg max expendable LEO (Metzger 2023 p.17). Reusable missions carry less, so actual USD/kg is higher."},{"id":"P0183","domain":"economics","parameter":"implied list price per kg to GTO","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"13455","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2026)/kg","year":"2026","method":"derived","source_url":"https://keeptrack.space/deep-dive/how-much-does-a-falcon-9-launch-cost","locator":"derived","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"USD 74M / 5,500 kg GTO (reusable GTO capacity attached to the list price)."},{"id":"P0184","domain":"economics","parameter":"implied list price per kg to LEO (expendable max)","scope":"Falcon Heavy","value":"1520","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022)/kg","year":"2022","method":"derived","source_url":"https://keeptrack.space/deep-dive/how-much-does-a-falcon-9-launch-cost","locator":"derived","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"USD 97M / 63,800 kg (FAA 2018 Table 2 capacity); the 97M list price does not buy fully expendable flight, so this is a lower bound."},{"id":"P0185","domain":"economics","parameter":"rideshare entry price","scope":"Falcon 9 Transporter rideshare to SSO","value":"350000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2026) per 50 kg slot","year":"2026","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://newspaceeconomy.ca/2026/02/27/spacex-rideshare-pricing-as-of-february-2026-what-it-costs-whats-included-and-how-buyers-budget-a-mission/","locator":"pricing section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Secondary, states SpaceX rideshare page as source; SpaceX page itself renders no text to fetch."},{"id":"P0186","domain":"economics","parameter":"rideshare price per additional kg","scope":"Falcon 9 Transporter rideshare to SSO","value":"7000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2026)/kg","year":"2026","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://newspaceeconomy.ca/2026/02/27/spacex-rideshare-pricing-as-of-february-2026-what-it-costs-whats-included-and-how-buyers-budget-a-mission/","locator":"pricing section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"New Space Economy (Feb 2026) says SpaceX advertises USD 7,000/kg; KeepTrack (Oct 2026) says the SpaceX page did not show it and treats it as a secondary estimate."},{"id":"P0187","domain":"economics","parameter":"rideshare price per kg","scope":"Falcon 9 Transporter rideshare to SSO","value":"6500","low":"5500","high":"","unit":"USD(2023)/kg","year":"2023","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://keeptrack.space/deep-dive/how-much-does-a-falcon-9-launch-cost","locator":"rideshare section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Raised from USD 5,500/kg in March 2023 per KeepTrack citing Payload (2023-03-01)."},{"id":"P0188","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch service contract value","scope":"Falcon 9, Sentinel-6B (NASA)","value":"94000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022)/launch","year":"2022","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-awards-launch-services-contract-for-sentinel-6b-mission","locator":"press release 2022-12-20","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Firm fixed price; includes launch service and other mission-related costs. Government price above the commercial list price."},{"id":"P0189","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch service contract value","scope":"Falcon Heavy, Roman Space Telescope (NASA)","value":"255000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022)/launch","year":"2022","method":"contract","source_url":"https://roman.ipac.caltech.edu/news/nasa-awards-launch-services-contract","locator":"press release 2022-07-19","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Total cost to NASA incl. launch service and other mission-related costs."},{"id":"P0190","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch service contract value","scope":"Falcon Heavy, Europa Clipper (NASA)","value":"178000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/launch","year":"2021","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/nasa-awards-launch-services-contract-for-the-europa-clipper-mission/","locator":"press release 2021-07-23","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Interplanetary (Jupiter) trajectory; fully expendable configuration."},{"id":"P0191","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch service contract value","scope":"Falcon Heavy, Psyche (NASA)","value":"117000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2020)/launch","year":"2020","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.defensedaily.com/press-releases/nasa-awards-launch-services-contract-for-the-psyche-mission/","locator":"search snippet of NASA release","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Total cost to launch Psyche plus secondary payloads."},{"id":"P0192","domain":"economics","parameter":"NSSL Phase 3 Lane 2 order-year-2 task orders, total","scope":"SpaceX (5 missions)","value":"714000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2025)","year":"2025","method":"contract","source_url":"https://spaceflightnow.com/2025/10/04/spacex-to-launch-4-falcon-heavy-rockets-as-part-of-newest-u-s-national-security-missions-award/","locator":"article 2025-10-04","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Includes 4 Falcon Heavy; launches NET FY27. Per mission about USD 142.8M (derived)."},{"id":"P0193","domain":"economics","parameter":"NSSL Phase 3 Lane 2 order-year-2 task orders, total","scope":"ULA Vulcan (2 missions)","value":"428000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2025)","year":"2025","method":"contract","source_url":"https://spaceflightnow.com/2025/10/04/spacex-to-launch-4-falcon-heavy-rockets-as-part-of-newest-u-s-national-security-missions-award/","locator":"article 2025-10-04","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Per mission about USD 214M (derived)."},{"id":"P0194","domain":"economics","parameter":"NSSL Phase 3 Lane 2 order-year-1 task orders, total","scope":"SpaceX (7 missions)","value":"845800000","low":"845800000","high":"848800000","unit":"USD(2025)","year":"2025","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.ssc.spaceforce.mil/Newsroom/Article/4148471/Space-Systems-Command-Releases-National-Security-Space-Launch-Phase-3-Lane-2-fy","locator":"SSC release 2025-04-04 (403 on fetch)","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"Reports give USD 845.8M and 848.8M; ULA 2 missions USD 427.6M in the same round."},{"id":"P0195","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch price paid (ESA contract list)","scope":"Ariane 62, Sentinel-1D","value":"82070773","low":"","high":"","unit":"EUR(2025)/launch","year":"2025","method":"contract","source_url":"https://europeanspaceflight.com/?p=6303","locator":"article 2026-04-09, citing ESA list of contracts >EUR 15k","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"First disclosed Ariane 6 price; launched 4 Nov 2025."},{"id":"P0196","domain":"economics","parameter":"implied price per kg to LEO","scope":"Ariane 62","value":"7930","low":"","high":"","unit":"EUR(2025)/kg","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://europeanspaceflight.com/?p=6303","locator":"derived","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"EUR 82.07M (Sentinel-1D row) / 10,350 kg A62 LEO capacity (Wikipedia Ariane 6, user manual 2021)."},{"id":"P0197","domain":"economics","parameter":"implied price per kg to GTO","scope":"Ariane 62","value":"18238","low":"","high":"","unit":"EUR(2025)/kg","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://europeanspaceflight.com/?p=6303","locator":"derived","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"EUR 82.07M / 4,500 kg A62 GTO capacity."},{"id":"P0198","domain":"economics","parameter":"cost per launch (estimate)","scope":"Ariane 62","value":"100000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"EUR(2024)/launch","year":"2024","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ariane_6","locator":"infobox, cites European Spaceflight 2024-03-29","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Wikipedia; original estimates EUR 70M (A62) and 90M (A64). Disclosed Sentinel-1D price EUR 82M."},{"id":"P0199","domain":"economics","parameter":"cost per launch (estimate)","scope":"Ariane 64","value":"115000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"EUR(2018)/launch","year":"2018","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ariane_6","locator":"infobox, cites Motley Fool 2018","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Wikipedia; A64 capacity 21,650 kg LEO / 11,500 kg GTO."},{"id":"P0200","domain":"economics","parameter":"public subsidy per launch","scope":"Ariane 6","value":"35000000","low":"32000000","high":"38000000","unit":"EUR(2023)/launch","year":"2023","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ariane_6","locator":"Criticism/funding section, Aschbacher quote","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"must-check","note":"ESA DG: EUR 32-38M per launch at 9 flights/yr; member states agreed up to EUR 340M/yr from flight 16 to 42."},{"id":"P0201","domain":"economics","parameter":"typical price per mission","scope":"Vega-C","value":"40000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"EUR(2026)/launch","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://europeanspaceflight.com/?p=6303","locator":"article 2026-04-09","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"European Spaceflight estimate, not an ESA figure."},{"id":"P0202","domain":"economics","parameter":"starting price per launch","scope":"Vulcan Centaur","value":"110000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2023)/launch","year":"2023","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vulcan_Centaur","locator":"infobox (search snippet)","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Bruno 2016 cost goal < USD 100M; NSSL OY2 implies ~USD 214M per national security mission."},{"id":"P0203","domain":"economics","parameter":"price per launch (press estimate)","scope":"New Glenn","value":"65000000","low":"60000000","high":"70000000","unit":"USD(2025)/launch","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ktvz.com/cnn-other/2025/01/04/new-glenn-how-jeff-bezos-blue-origin-aims-to-challenge-elon-musks-spacex/","locator":"CNN syndicated article (search snippet)","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Blue Origin publishes no price; CNN reported roughly USD 60-70M."},{"id":"P0204","domain":"economics","parameter":"price per launch target","scope":"H3 (JAXA/MHI)","value":"5000000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"JPY(2023)/launch","year":"2023","method":"target","source_url":"https://digital-release.thehill.com/?p=4547109","locator":"search snippet (AP via The Hill)","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"About USD 33-35M; half the H-IIA price; MHI cited at USD 35M."},{"id":"P0205","domain":"economics","parameter":"average price per mission incl. GNC charge","scope":"Long March 3B/E to GTO","value":"390000000","low":"375000000","high":"405000000","unit":"CNY(2023)/launch","year":"2023","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.china-in-space.com/p/what-is-the-cost-of-a-long-march","locator":"article 2025-07-15, citing Aerospace China (Wu Xingyu)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Launch 260-290M CNY plus 115M CNY GNC; ChinaSat contracts; ~USD 54.4M. Chinese prices often bundle insurance/commissioning."},{"id":"P0206","domain":"economics","parameter":"price per kg to GTO","scope":"Long March 3B/E","value":"70900","low":"","high":"","unit":"CNY(2023)/kg","year":"2023","method":"derived","source_url":"https://www.china-in-space.com/p/what-is-the-cost-of-a-long-march","locator":"article 2025-07-15","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"390M CNY / 5,500 kg GTO; article gives USD 9,890/kg."},{"id":"P0207","domain":"economics","parameter":"price per mission to LEO","scope":"Long March 2C/2D","value":"112900000","low":"","high":"","unit":"CNY(2022)/launch","year":"2022","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.china-in-space.com/p/what-is-the-cost-of-a-long-march","locator":"article 2025-07-15","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"Changguang Satellite contract. Article states 282,000 CNY/kg (USD 39,360/kg) on 4,000 kg, but 112.9M/4,000 = 28,225 CNY/kg (~USD 3,940/kg); the article figure appears off by 10x."},{"id":"P0208","domain":"economics","parameter":"price per kg target","scope":"Zhuque-3 (LandSpace)","value":"2800","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2024)/kg","year":"2024","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.scmp.com/news/china/science/article/3290445/spacex-and-7-dwarves-chinese-space-firms-line-enter-reusable-rocket-race","locator":"search snippet","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Versus USD 8,500/kg on Zhuque-2."},{"id":"P0209","domain":"economics","parameter":"operating cost per flight target","scope":"Starship (fully reusable)","value":"2000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2019)/flight","year":"2019","method":"target","source_url":"https://techcrunch.com/2019/11/06/elon-musk-says-spacexs-starship-could-fly-for-as-little-as-2-million-per-launch","locator":"article 2019-11-06","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Musk at USAF Space Pitch Day; propellant about USD 0.9M per launch. Internal cost, not a customer price."},{"id":"P0210","domain":"economics","parameter":"all-in cost per launch target","scope":"Starship","value":"10000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2019)/flight","year":"2019","method":"target","source_url":"https://foxbusiness.com/markets/elon-musk-expects-starship-to-deliver-launches-at-lower-costs","locator":"search snippet","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Musk: less than USD 10M all-in within 2-3 years; 2024 report has Musk telling staff USD 2-3M."},{"id":"P0211","domain":"economics","parameter":"cost per launch (expendable)","scope":"Starship","value":"100000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2025)/flight","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Starship","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Wikipedia infobox; Tim Farrar estimate of ~USD 1,000/kg expendable circulates in secondary sources."},{"id":"P0212","domain":"economics","parameter":"cumulative development spend","scope":"Starship","value":"15000000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(nominal)","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://finance.yahoo.com/sectors/technology/articles/exclusive-spacex-spending-starship-tops-100213604.html","locator":"Reuters 2026-05-01, citing SpaceX IPO filing","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"2025 Starship R&D USD 3.0B (2024: 1.8B); Falcon 9 development ~USD 400M for comparison."},{"id":"P0213","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per kg claim","scope":"Starship (often-made claim)","value":"30","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2023","method":"target","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.17, Sec. 4.7","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"Metzger: \"perhaps as low as $30/kg to LEO\"; he models it only at ~8 Starship launches/day (436 kt/yr) by year 30."},{"id":"P0214","domain":"economics","parameter":"current launch cost to LEO, L0","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"2000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022)/kg","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.17, Sec. 4.7","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"Model input \"about L0 = $2,000/kg\"."},{"id":"P0215","domain":"economics","parameter":"learning rate b (Wright's law progress ratio)","scope":"launch to LEO (Metzger model)","value":"0.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"ratio (cost per doubling)","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.17, Eq. 18","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"\"typical learning rate\"; alternative fit b = 0.7 with a = 0.85."},{"id":"P0216","domain":"economics","parameter":"economies-of-scale exponent a","scope":"launch to LEO (Metzger model)","value":"0.66","low":"","high":"","unit":"exponent","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.17, Eq. 18","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"Industry average per Haldi and Whitcombe."},{"id":"P0217","domain":"economics","parameter":"modelled launch cost to LEO at year 30, 10% market","scope":"Starship-class (Metzger moderate)","value":"119","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022)/kg","year":"2052","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.19, Sec. 4.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"One Starship launch every 1.25 days."},{"id":"P0218","domain":"economics","parameter":"modelled launch cost to LEO at year 30, 1% market","scope":"Starship-class (Metzger pessimistic)","value":"436","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022)/kg","year":"2052","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.19, Sec. 4.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"One Starship launch every 12.5 days."},{"id":"P0219","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch demand elasticity threshold","scope":"space transportation (Andrews & Andrews)","value":"2200","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022)/kg","year":"2001","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.18, Sec. 4.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Original 1,320 USD(2001)/kg; as reported in Metzger 2023. Below threshold demand turns elastic."},{"id":"P0220","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch demand elasticity threshold","scope":"space transportation (Ross et al. 2009)","value":"6100","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022)/kg","year":"2009","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.18, Sec. 4.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Original 4,400 USD(2009)/kg; as reported in Metzger 2023."},{"id":"P0221","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch demand price elasticity (crude estimate 2005-)","scope":"global launch market","value":"1.9","low":"","high":"3.8","unit":"elasticity (abs.)","year":"2022","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.19, Sec. 4.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"~40% fall in global-average launch cost while annual launch mass doubled since 2005; trend since 2019 implies E ~ 3.8. Metzger calls these crude."},{"id":"P0222","domain":"economics","parameter":"implied price elasticity of launch demand, scenarios","scope":"Metzger optimistic/moderate/pessimistic","value":"1.58","low":"1.26","high":"","unit":"elasticity (abs.)","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.19, Eq. 20","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"Moderate 1.52, pessimistic 1.26."},{"id":"P0223","domain":"economics","parameter":"learning rate: cost decline per doubling of cumulative payload to orbit","scope":"global launch 1960-2025","value":"0.212","low":"","high":"","unit":"fraction per doubling","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Abstract; Results, Wright's Law","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Terzi & Nicoli, PNAS Nexus 5(7) 2026; R^2 0.791 full sample, 0.953 since 2000; 4,405 launches."},{"id":"P0224","domain":"economics","parameter":"learning rate, Cold War era","scope":"global launch to 1989","value":"0.17","low":"","high":"","unit":"fraction per doubling","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Results, Wright's Law","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0225","domain":"economics","parameter":"learning rate, post-Cold War era","scope":"global launch 1989-2025","value":"0.44","low":"","high":"","unit":"fraction per doubling","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Results, Wright's Law","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Much of the aggregate decline is a shift of payload to cheaper rockets."},{"id":"P0226","domain":"economics","parameter":"within-family learning rate (learning by doing)","scope":"rocket families 1960-2025","value":"0.06","low":"","high":"0.08","unit":"fraction per doubling","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Results, Wright's Law","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"8% post-Cold War; within-family R^2 below 0.5 in all specifications."},{"id":"P0227","domain":"economics","parameter":"average launch cost per kg to LEO","scope":"global average 2025","value":"3868","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2024)/kg","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Abstract; Results para 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"1960: 87,023 USD(2024)/kg."},{"id":"P0228","domain":"economics","parameter":"average launch cost per kg to LEO","scope":"global average 1960","value":"87023","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2024)/kg","year":"1960","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0229","domain":"economics","parameter":"forecast average launch cost per kg to LEO, 2030","scope":"global average (central scenario)","value":"1600","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2024)/kg","year":"2030","method":"model","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Abstract; Results, Technological forecasting","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"SingularityHub coverage gives 1,569."},{"id":"P0230","domain":"economics","parameter":"forecast average launch cost per kg to LEO, 2040","scope":"global average (central scenario)","value":"300","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2024)/kg","year":"2040","method":"model","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Abstract; Results, Technological forecasting","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"SingularityHub coverage gives 273."},{"id":"P0231","domain":"economics","parameter":"willingness to pay for propellant in LEO","scope":"ULA Cislunar business case (ACES)","value":"3000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"target","source_url":"https://aero.und.edu/space/_files/docs/colloquium-series/2018-02-26.pdf","locator":"slide 12","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"\"Required to close business case\"; sized on 3 ACES cargo flights/yr, 210 t/yr to LEO. ACES later cancelled."},{"id":"P0232","domain":"economics","parameter":"price of propellant on lunar surface","scope":"ULA Cislunar business case","value":"500","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"target","source_url":"https://aero.und.edu/space/_files/docs/colloquium-series/2018-02-26.pdf","locator":"slide 12","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"\"Based on cost to transport to LEO\"; aerobraking could raise affordability 2-3x."},{"id":"P0233","domain":"economics","parameter":"price of propellant at EML1","scope":"ULA Cislunar SSP business case","value":"1000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"target","source_url":"https://aero.und.edu/space/_files/docs/colloquium-series/2018-02-26.pdf","locator":"slide 20","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"\"Cost of propellant per previous business case\"."},{"id":"P0234","domain":"economics","parameter":"transport cost Earth to lunar surface (Vulcan/XEUS)","scope":"ULA concept","value":"35000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"target","source_url":"https://aero.und.edu/space/_files/docs/colloquium-series/2018-02-26.pdf","locator":"slide 13","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Never flown; CLPS prices are ~USD 0.2-1.5M/kg."},{"id":"P0235","domain":"economics","parameter":"design and production cost of mining equipment","scope":"lunar ice mining plant (Sowers)","value":"50000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://aero.und.edu/space/_files/docs/colloquium-series/2018-02-26.pdf","locator":"slide 13","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Plant development USD 2.02B for 40.5 t."},{"id":"P0236","domain":"economics","parameter":"plant operating cost","scope":"lunar ice mining plant (Sowers)","value":"3000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg-yr","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://aero.und.edu/space/_files/docs/colloquium-series/2018-02-26.pdf","locator":"slide 13","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Per kg of plant per year; 10-yr life, 10% return on sales."},{"id":"P0237","domain":"economics","parameter":"plant mass productivity","scope":"lunar ice mining plant (Sowers 2018)","value":"25.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant per kg plant per yr","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://aero.und.edu/space/_files/docs/colloquium-series/2018-02-26.pdf","locator":"slide 13","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Over 10 yr gives ~255 kg/kg; Metzger reports Sowers phi = 534 (different study version)."},{"id":"P0238","domain":"economics","parameter":"manufacturing cost at EML1","scope":"space solar power (Sowers)","value":"1000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://aero.und.edu/space/_files/docs/colloquium-series/2018-02-26.pdf","locator":"slide 20","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"SSP case: USD 10.3B non-recurring, revenue USD 1.84B/yr at USD 0.1/kWh."},{"id":"P0239","domain":"economics","parameter":"lunar delivery list price, surface","scope":"Astrobotic Peregrine payload service, lunar surface","value":"1200000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://explorers.larc.nasa.gov/2019APSMEX/MO/pdf_files/Astrobotic%20-%20Payload%20User%20Guide%20v3%202018-10.pdf","locator":"Peregrine PUG v3.0 Oct 2018, p. 3 (PDF p. 7)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"'$1.2M per kilogram of payload to the lunar surface'; payloads <1 kg may pay integration fees. Not a transaction price."},{"id":"P0240","domain":"economics","parameter":"lunar delivery list price, lunar orbit","scope":"Astrobotic Peregrine payload service, lunar orbit","value":"300000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://explorers.larc.nasa.gov/2019APSMEX/MO/pdf_files/Astrobotic%20-%20Payload%20User%20Guide%20v3%202018-10.pdf","locator":"Peregrine PUG v3.0 Oct 2018, p. 3 (PDF p. 7)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Deployment in lunar orbit before descent."},{"id":"P0241","domain":"economics","parameter":"lunar delivery list price, on rover","scope":"Astrobotic Peregrine payload service, delivery on rover","value":"2000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2018)/kg","year":"2018","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://explorers.larc.nasa.gov/2019APSMEX/MO/pdf_files/Astrobotic%20-%20Payload%20User%20Guide%20v3%202018-10.pdf","locator":"Peregrine PUG v3.0 Oct 2018, p. 3 (PDF p. 7)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Rose to 4.5M/kg in PUG v5.0 (2021), see next rows."},{"id":"P0242","domain":"economics","parameter":"lunar delivery list price, surface","scope":"Astrobotic lunar landers (Peregrine/Griffin), lunar surface","value":"1200000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/kg","year":"2021","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://science.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/astrobotic-lunar-landers-pug.pdf","locator":"Astrobotic Lunar Landers PUG v5.0 Aug 2021, Service Overview (PDF p. 5)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Unchanged nominal price 2018 to 2021, so a real-terms decline. Hosted on science.nasa.gov (2023 upload)."},{"id":"P0243","domain":"economics","parameter":"lunar delivery list price, lunar orbit","scope":"Astrobotic lunar landers, lunar orbit","value":"300000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/kg","year":"2021","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://science.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/astrobotic-lunar-landers-pug.pdf","locator":"PUG v5.0 Aug 2021, Service Overview (PDF p. 5)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0244","domain":"economics","parameter":"lunar delivery list price, on rover","scope":"Astrobotic CubeRover delivery","value":"4500000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/kg","year":"2021","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://science.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/astrobotic-lunar-landers-pug.pdf","locator":"PUG v5.0 Aug 2021, Service Overview (PDF p. 5)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Up from 2.0M/kg in 2018 PUG."},{"id":"P0245","domain":"economics","parameter":"minimum ticket price, token lunar delivery","scope":"DHL MoonBox on Astrobotic lander","value":"460","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/item","year":"2021","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://science.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/astrobotic-lunar-landers-pug.pdf","locator":"PUG v5.0 Aug 2021, PDF p. 5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"'Prices start at $460' for small items; per-kg not stated."},{"id":"P0246","domain":"economics","parameter":"CLPS IDIQ cumulative maximum contract value","scope":"NASA Commercial Lunar Payload Services, all vendors","value":"2600000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(nominal)","year":"2018","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/reference/commercial-lunar-payload-services/","locator":"CLPS reference page","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'cumulative maximum contract value of $2.6 billion through 2028'. Ceiling, not obligations."},{"id":"P0247","domain":"economics","parameter":"CLPS task order value","scope":"Astrobotic Peregrine Mission One (CLPS, 2019 award)","value":"79500000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2019)","year":"2019","method":"contract","source_url":"https://spacepolicyonline.com/?p=26346","locator":"May 31 2019 award","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Up to 14 payloads to Lacus Mortis. Peregrine failed in Jan 2024 (propulsion anomaly), no landing."},{"id":"P0248","domain":"economics","parameter":"CLPS task order value","scope":"Intuitive Machines IM-1 (CLPS, 2019 award)","value":"77000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2019)","year":"2019","method":"contract","source_url":"https://spacepolicyonline.com/?p=26346","locator":"May 31 2019 award","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Landed Feb 2024 (tipped over); delivered six NASA payloads per NASA CLPS page."},{"id":"P0249","domain":"economics","parameter":"CLPS task order value","scope":"OrbitBeyond Z-01 (CLPS, 2019 award, terminated)","value":"97000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2019)","year":"2019","method":"contract","source_url":"https://spaceflightnow.com/2019/07/30/nasa-terminates-lunar-lander-contract-with-orbitbeyond/","locator":"Jul 2019","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Vendor withdrew July 2019; no delivery."},{"id":"P0250","domain":"economics","parameter":"CLPS contract total after increase","scope":"Astrobotic Griffin Mission One with VIPER","value":"320400000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022)","year":"2022","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/missions/artemis/clps/nasa-replans-clps-delivery-of-viper-to-2024-to-reduce-risk","locator":"NASA release 18 Jul 2022","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'an additional $67.8 million has been added to Astrobotic's CLPS contract, which now totals $320.4 million'. Original Griffin order widely reported as 199.5M (2020); NASA later cancelled VIPER (2024)."},{"id":"P0251","domain":"economics","parameter":"CLPS task order value","scope":"Firefly Blue Ghost Mission 1, Mare Crisium (TO 19D)","value":"93300000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)","year":"2021","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-selects-firefly-aerospace-for-artemis-commercial-moon-delivery-in-2023/","locator":"RELEASE21-012, 4 Feb 2021","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"10 payloads, about 94 kg combined. Landed successfully Mar 2025."},{"id":"P0252","domain":"economics","parameter":"CLPS payload mass","scope":"Firefly Blue Ghost Mission 1","value":"94","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2021","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-selects-firefly-aerospace-for-artemis-commercial-moon-delivery-in-2023/","locator":"RELEASE21-012","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'about 207 lb (94 kg)'."},{"id":"P0253","domain":"economics","parameter":"implied CLPS price per kg delivered","scope":"Firefly Blue Ghost Mission 1, lunar surface","value":"992553","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/kg","year":"2021","method":"derived","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-selects-firefly-aerospace-for-artemis-commercial-moon-delivery-in-2023/","locator":"RELEASE21-012","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"93.3M / 94 kg (rows above). Task order also buys surface ops and data, so per-kg overstates pure transport."},{"id":"P0254","domain":"economics","parameter":"CLPS task order value","scope":"Intuitive Machines IM-3, Reiner Gamma","value":"77500000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)","year":"2021","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-selects-intuitive-machines-for-new-lunar-science-delivery/","locator":"RELEASE21-157, 17 Nov 2021","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Four payloads, about 92 kg."},{"id":"P0255","domain":"economics","parameter":"CLPS payload mass","scope":"Intuitive Machines IM-3","value":"92","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2021","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-selects-intuitive-machines-for-new-lunar-science-delivery/","locator":"RELEASE21-157","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'about 203 pounds (92 kg)'."},{"id":"P0256","domain":"economics","parameter":"implied CLPS price per kg delivered","scope":"Intuitive Machines IM-3, lunar surface","value":"842391","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2021)/kg","year":"2021","method":"derived","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-selects-intuitive-machines-for-new-lunar-science-delivery/","locator":"RELEASE21-157","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"77.5M / 92 kg (rows above)."},{"id":"P0257","domain":"economics","parameter":"CLPS task order value","scope":"Firefly Blue Ghost Mission 2, far side + ESA Lunar Pathfinder to orbit","value":"112000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2023)","year":"2023","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-picks-firefly-aerospace-for-robotic-delivery-to-far-side-of-moon/","locator":"RELEASE23-026, 14 Mar 2023","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'just under $112 million'; three payloads about 494.5 kg incl. Lunar Pathfinder relay satellite dropped in orbit."},{"id":"P0258","domain":"economics","parameter":"implied CLPS price per kg delivered","scope":"Firefly Blue Ghost Mission 2 (mixed orbit + far-side surface)","value":"226491","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2023)/kg","year":"2023","method":"derived","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-picks-firefly-aerospace-for-robotic-delivery-to-far-side-of-moon/","locator":"RELEASE23-026","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"112M / 494.5 kg. Most of the mass is the Pathfinder satellite released in lunar orbit, so not comparable with surface-only orders."},{"id":"P0259","domain":"economics","parameter":"CLPS task order value","scope":"Intuitive Machines CP-22, lunar south pole 2027","value":"116900000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2024)","year":"2024","method":"contract","source_url":"https://spacenews.com/?p=505012","locator":"Aug 2024 award","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Six payloads, 79 kg reported (Space.com/SpaceNews snippets). Space.com headline '$117 million' page-checked; mass not seen on page."},{"id":"P0260","domain":"economics","parameter":"implied CLPS price per kg delivered","scope":"Intuitive Machines CP-22, lunar south pole","value":"1479747","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2024)/kg","year":"2024","method":"derived","source_url":"https://space.com/nasa-intuitive-machines-moon-mission-2027","locator":"headline","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"116.9M / 79 kg; mass snippet-only. Older note had 1.5M/kg via Universe Magazine."},{"id":"P0261","domain":"economics","parameter":"CLPS task order value","scope":"Intuitive Machines IM-5, Nova-D cargo lander, Mons Malapert","value":"180400000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2026)","year":"2026","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.barchart.com/story/news/926940/intuitive-machines-expands-lunar-surface-operations-with-180-4-million-nasa-clps-award","locator":"IM release 24/25 Mar 2026","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Seven payloads incl. Honeybee rover and Roo-ver; no payload mass found."},{"id":"P0262","domain":"economics","parameter":"CLPS task order value","scope":"Draper/ispace-U.S. CP-12, Schroedinger basin","value":"73000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022)","year":"2022","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.draper.com/press-release/nasa-awards-draper-73-million-deliver-suite-payloads-moon-2025","locator":"Draper release Jul 2022","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Three payloads. Reported later: NASA ended the task order after lander redesign delays, ~43M paid to date (secondary, unverified)."},{"id":"P0263","domain":"economics","parameter":"Starship lunar cargo purchase","scope":"ispace on SpaceX Starship lunar flight (target 2030)","value":"50000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2026)","year":"2026","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.techtimes.com/articles/320019/20260709/ispace-bets-50m-starship-deliver-moon-cargo-before-spacex-takes-over.htm","locator":"article 9 Jul 2026","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Signed 8 Jul 2026 per article; 500 kg capacity incl. ispace Mobile Cargo System, so customer mass is several hundred kg. Secondary outlet."},{"id":"P0264","domain":"economics","parameter":"implied Starship lunar surface price per kg","scope":"ispace-SpaceX deal, lunar surface","value":"100000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2026)/kg","year":"2026","method":"derived","source_url":"https://www.techtimes.com/articles/320019/20260709/ispace-bets-50m-starship-deliver-moon-cargo-before-spacex-takes-over.htm","locator":"article 9 Jul 2026","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"50M / 500 kg (article's own average). Customer-facing price after ispace margin will be higher; one-customer deal, not a SpaceX rate card."},{"id":"P0265","domain":"economics","parameter":"lunar payload service target price","scope":"ispace payload services (investor presentation)","value":"1500000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2023)/kg","year":"2023","method":"target","source_url":"https://holistic-r.org/adm/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/9348230414_en.pdf","locator":"investor presentation Apr 2023","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"investor","status":"must-check","note":"Not opened; from search summary only."},{"id":"P0266","domain":"economics","parameter":"Mars cargo price","scope":"SpaceX Starship to Mars surface (target from 2030)","value":"100000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2025)/kg","year":"2025","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.benzinga.com/news/space/25/10/48168768/elon-musks-spacex-eyes-100-million-per-ton-mars-cargo-missions-by-2030-as-11th-starship-launch-approac","locator":"Oct 2025","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Reported as 100M USD per metric ton; page returned 403; original SpaceX document not located."},{"id":"P0267","domain":"economics","parameter":"Mars Sample Return lifecycle cost estimate","scope":"NASA/ESA MSR, 2023 baseline design","value":"8800000000","low":"8000000000","high":"9600000000","unit":"USD(nominal)","year":"2023","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://spacepolicyonline.com/?p=64978","locator":"article 21 Sep 2023 on IRB-2 report","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Value = midpoint of IRB-2 range 8.0-9.6B for current design; other coverage cites 8-11B incl. alternatives. Cost of returning a few hundred grams of samples, not a per-kg transport price."},{"id":"P0268","domain":"economics","parameter":"GEO refuelling price","scope":"Orbit Fab hydrazine delivery above GEO (RAFTI clients), from 2025","value":"20000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) per fill-up up to 100 kg","year":"2022","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://payloadspace.com/orbit-fab-announces-in-space-refueling-prices","locator":"Payload 2 Sep 2022","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"'flat rate price of $20M for hydrazine fill-ups in GEO'; primary orbitfab.com page timed out (504). No paid transaction confirmed as of 2026."},{"id":"P0269","domain":"economics","parameter":"GEO hydrazine price per kg","scope":"Orbit Fab, at full 100 kg","value":"200000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022)/kg","year":"2022","method":"derived","source_url":"https://payloadspace.com/orbit-fab-announces-in-space-refueling-prices","locator":"Payload 2 Sep 2022","verification":"derived","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"20M / 100 kg; higher per kg for smaller fills (flat rate)."},{"id":"P0270","domain":"economics","parameter":"refuelling port unit price","scope":"Orbit Fab RAFTI port","value":"30000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022)/unit","year":"2022","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://ca.news.yahoo.com/orbit-fab-unveils-30k-port-183411224.html","locator":"TechCrunch/Yahoo","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":""},{"id":"P0271","domain":"economics","parameter":"life-extension service price","scope":"Northrop Grumman SpaceLogistics MEV-1 for Intelsat 901","value":"13000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2019)/yr","year":"2019","method":"contract","source_url":"https://spaceflightnow.com/2020/04/21/aging-intelsat-satellite-resumes-operations-after-docking-of-robotic-servicer/","locator":"Spaceflight Now 21 Apr 2020","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"'Intelsat said last year it is paying SpaceLogistics around $13 million per year'; customer statement, terms otherwise undisclosed."},{"id":"P0272","domain":"economics","parameter":"life-extension service term","scope":"MEV-1 on Intelsat 901","value":"5","low":"","high":"","unit":"years","year":"2020","method":"contract","source_url":"https://spaceflightnow.com/2020/04/21/aging-intelsat-satellite-resumes-operations-after-docking-of-robotic-servicer/","locator":"Spaceflight Now 21 Apr 2020","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0273","domain":"economics","parameter":"life-extension contract total","scope":"MEV-1 on Intelsat 901","value":"65000000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2019)","year":"2020","method":"derived","source_url":"https://spaceflightnow.com/2020/04/21/aging-intelsat-satellite-resumes-operations-after-docking-of-robotic-servicer/","locator":"","verification":"derived","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"13M/yr x 5 yr (rows above); bcsatellite.net gives same ~65M."},{"id":"P0274","domain":"economics","parameter":"orbit transfer price per kg","scope":"Momentus Vigoride OTV","value":"15000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2020)/kg","year":"2020","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vigoride","locator":"Wikipedia citing Momentus","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"'roughly $15,000 per kg depending on the exact customer specifications'; Momentus later scaled back operations."},{"id":"P0275","domain":"economics","parameter":"orbit transfer price","scope":"Momentus Vigoride Extended, 200-400 kg LEO/GTO to GEO or lunar orbit","value":"4800000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2019)/mission","year":"2019","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://spacenews.com/?p=83181","locator":"SpaceNews 2019","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Preliminary price; implies 12k-24k USD/kg over 200-400 kg. Page returned 429."},{"id":"P0276","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch-plus-one-year insurance premium rate","scope":"typical GEO satellite on Falcon 9, start of 2023","value":"6","low":"","high":"6","unit":"% of insured value","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.satellitetoday.com/sustainability/2024/05/01/slingshot-aerospace-reveals-record-insurance-losses-in-2023-in-new-satellite-deployments-report/","locator":"article body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"less than 6% (upper bound); Via Satellite reporting Slingshot Aerospace report of 30 Apr 2024; primary report not opened. Rose to ~10% by May 2024, see next row"},{"id":"P0277","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch-plus-one-year insurance premium rate","scope":"typical GEO satellite on Falcon 9, as of May 2024","value":"10","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of insured value","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.satellitetoday.com/sustainability/2024/05/01/slingshot-aerospace-reveals-record-insurance-losses-in-2023-in-new-satellite-deployments-report/","locator":"article body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"around 10%; Via Satellite reporting Slingshot Aerospace; secondary report of a data vendor"},{"id":"P0278","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual in-orbit insurance premium rate before 2023 hardening","scope":"GEO satellites, in-orbit annual renewal","value":"0.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of insured value per year","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.slingshot.space/seradata-blog/space-insurance-promising-start-to-the-year-marred-only-by-methanesat-claim","locator":"search snippet","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"consultancy","status":"must-check","note":"circa 0.6 per cent per search snippet of Seradata/Slingshot; page returned 404 on fetch"},{"id":"P0279","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual in-orbit insurance premium rate after 2023 hardening","scope":"GEO satellites, in-orbit annual renewal","value":"1.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of insured value per year","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.slingshot.space/seradata-blog/space-insurance-promising-start-to-the-year-marred-only-by-methanesat-claim","locator":"search snippet","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"consultancy","status":"must-check","note":"close to 1.2 per cent (near doubling) per search snippet of Seradata/Slingshot; not opened"},{"id":"P0280","domain":"economics","parameter":"expected premium increase after H2 2023 losses","scope":"space insurance market renewals 2024","value":"125","low":"115","high":"160","unit":"% increase in premium","year":"2024","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.reinsurancene.ws/space-insurance-market-navigates-uncertain-terrain-in-2024-amid-capacity-shifts-gallagher/","locator":"search snippet","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"consultancy","status":"must-check","note":"Gallagher expectation \"115-135 per cent, and in some cases as high as 160 per cent\" per search snippet; fetched page did not show the figure; value = midpoint of 115-135"},{"id":"P0281","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space insurance premium income","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, risks attaching 2023","value":"557","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2023)","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.satellitetoday.com/sustainability/2024/05/01/slingshot-aerospace-reveals-record-insurance-losses-in-2023-in-new-satellite-deployments-report/","locator":"article body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"conflict","note":"Slingshot Aerospace figure via Via Satellite; AXA XL gives 584 (excl. Russian risks); Gallagher Re snippet gives ~590"},{"id":"P0282","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space insurance premium income","scope":"worldwide space insurance market 2023, excl. Russian risks","value":"584","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2023)","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matinsurance.ania.it/upload/news/28/file-10/axa-xl-space-insurance-presentation-to-ania-june-2024-first-round.pdf","locator":"slide 7","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"conflict","note":"AXA XL presentation to ANIA June 2024 (\"Net premium on risks attaching\"); conflicts with Slingshot 557"},{"id":"P0283","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space insurance claims","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, 2023 year","value":"995","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2023)","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.satellitetoday.com/sustainability/2024/05/01/slingshot-aerospace-reveals-record-insurance-losses-in-2023-in-new-satellite-deployments-report/","locator":"article body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"conflict","note":"record losses of $995 million; AXA XL gives 970 as of 31 Dec 2023 and 1,850 as of June 2024 (late-reported losses); Seradata later revised net loss to USD 1.3bn (snippet)"},{"id":"P0284","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space insurance claims as of year end","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, 2023 underwriting year","value":"970","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2023)","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matinsurance.ania.it/upload/news/28/file-10/axa-xl-space-insurance-presentation-to-ania-june-2024-first-round.pdf","locator":"slide 7","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"conflict","note":"Losses as of Dec 31st, 2023 = $970m"},{"id":"P0285","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space insurance claims as of mid-2024","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, 2023 underwriting year","value":"1850","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matinsurance.ania.it/upload/news/28/file-10/axa-xl-space-insurance-presentation-to-ania-june-2024-first-round.pdf","locator":"slide 7","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"conflict","note":"Losses as of today = $1,85b (June 2024); the slide does not state whether this counts only 2023-attaching risks; compare Gallagher ~USD 2bn notified within 18 months"},{"id":"P0286","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance net underwriting loss","scope":"worldwide space insurance market 2023","value":"438","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2023)","year":"2023","method":"derived","source_url":"https://www.satellitetoday.com/sustainability/2024/05/01/slingshot-aerospace-reveals-record-insurance-losses-in-2023-in-new-satellite-deployments-report/","locator":"article body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Slingshot figure = 995 claims - 557 premium; \"record-breaking net loss\""},{"id":"P0287","domain":"economics","parameter":"single largest insurance claim","scope":"ViaSat-3 Americas (antenna failure, 2023)","value":"445","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2023)","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.satellitetoday.com/sustainability/2024/05/01/slingshot-aerospace-reveals-record-insurance-losses-in-2023-in-new-satellite-deployments-report/","locator":"article body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Slingshot Aerospace via Via Satellite"},{"id":"P0288","domain":"economics","parameter":"second largest insurance claim","scope":"Inmarsat 6-F2 (battery failure, 2023)","value":"348","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2023)","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.satellitetoday.com/sustainability/2024/05/01/slingshot-aerospace-reveals-record-insurance-losses-in-2023-in-new-satellite-deployments-report/","locator":"article body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Slingshot Aerospace via Via Satellite"},{"id":"P0289","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance claims presented in H2 2023","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, Jul-Dec 2023","value":"826","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2023)","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-market-update-q4-2023","locator":"Space Market Update Q4 2023 (3 Jan 2024)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"broker (Gallagher); \"over 85%\" of 2023 losses from post-separation spacecraft issues"},{"id":"P0290","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance claims notified within 18 months","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, 2023-2024","value":"2000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-market-update-q4-2024","locator":"Space Market Update Q4 2024 (9 Jan 2025)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"circa. USD2bn of claims being notified within 18 months; broker statement"},{"id":"P0291","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance claims by year (as reported)","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, 2023 vs 2024","value":"1.5","low":"","high":"1.9","unit":"USD billion (nominal)","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-market-update-q4-2025","locator":"Space Market Update Q4 2025 (8 Jan 2026)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"must-check","note":"page says claims fell \"from USD1.9 billion to USD1.5 billion\" (2023/24); unclear whether these are 2023 and 2024 totals; inconsistent with Seradata 2024 claims of ~USD 50m (snippet)"},{"id":"P0292","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance claims 2024","scope":"worldwide space insurance market 2024","value":"50","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2024)","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.seradata.com/profitable-2024-for-space-insurers-does-not-make-up-for-dire-2023","locator":"search snippet","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"consultancy","status":"conflict","note":"Seradata \"revised 2024 claims down sharply, to around US$50 million\" per snippet; page moved (404); conflicts with Gallagher row USD 1.5bn"},{"id":"P0293","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance net underwriting profit","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, 2025 year of account","value":"500","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-market-update-q4-2025","locator":"Space Market Update Q4 2025","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"circa.USD500m of net profit to insurers; broker forecast before SpainSat NG-2 loss"},{"id":"P0294","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance underwriting loss ratio before SpainSat NG-2","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, 2025 year of account","value":"15","low":"","high":"","unit":"% (claims / premium)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-insurance-market-update-q1-2026","locator":"Space Insurance Market Update Q1 2026 (10 Apr 2026)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"circa 15% before the SpainSat NG-2 total loss"},{"id":"P0295","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance underwriting loss ratio after SpainSat NG-2","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, 2025 year of account","value":"75","low":"","high":"","unit":"% (claims / premium)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-insurance-market-update-q1-2026","locator":"Space Insurance Market Update Q1 2026","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"circa 75% after the SpainSat NG-2 loss"},{"id":"P0296","domain":"economics","parameter":"insured value of a single GEO satellite","scope":"SpainSat NG-2 (total loss 2025/26)","value":"400","low":"400","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-insurance-market-update-q1-2026","locator":"Space Insurance Market Update Q1 2026","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"over USD400m (lower bound); illustrates single-risk size vs market capacity"},{"id":"P0297","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance working capacity","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, per risk","value":"550","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2024)","year":"2024","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-insurance-update-q1-2025","locator":"Space Insurance Market Update Q1 2025 (4 Apr 2025)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Total 2024 Working Capacity - USD 550m; competitive capacity expected lower"},{"id":"P0298","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance working capacity","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, per risk","value":"502","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-insurance-update-q1-2025","locator":"Space Insurance Market Update Q1 2025","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Total 2025 Working Capacity - USD 502m; Volante exited Jan 2025"},{"id":"P0299","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance competitive capacity","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, per risk","value":"300","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2026)","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-insurance-market-update-q1-2026","locator":"Space Insurance Market Update Q1 2026","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"around the USD300m mark; theoretical capacity \"over 15% more\" than a year earlier"},{"id":"P0300","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space insurance annual premium volume","scope":"worldwide launch and in-orbit insurance","value":"500","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million per year (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.advanced-television.com/2025/10/29/report-satellite-insurance-sector-suffering","locator":"article body (attributed to Marsh)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"about $500 million (€429.9m) in annual premiums attributed to broker Marsh by Advanced Television; Marsh primary not opened"},{"id":"P0301","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of launches insured","scope":"worldwide orbital launches","value":"20","low":"20","high":"60","unit":"% of launches","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.advanced-television.com/2025/10/29/report-satellite-insurance-sector-suffering","locator":"article body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"barely 20 percent now vs \"about 60 percent\" at 2020-21 peak; no source named in article"},{"id":"P0302","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of LEO satellites insured","scope":"LEO satellites","value":"3","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of satellites","year":"2023","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-market-update-q4-2023","locator":"Space Market Update Q4 2023","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"3% of LEO satellites are now insured, up from 1% in 2021"},{"id":"P0303","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch vehicle failure rate (annual)","scope":"worldwide orbital launches, 12 recent years to 2023","value":"5.4","low":"3.3","high":"8.8","unit":"% of launches","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matinsurance.ania.it/upload/news/28/file-10/axa-xl-space-insurance-presentation-to-ania-june-2024-first-round.pdf","locator":"slide 10","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"AXA XL chart row \"Failure rate\" 7.7, 4.9, 3.3, 5.8, 3.5, 7.7, 4.3, 4.9, 8.8, 7.6, 4.3, 5.4; year labels not in extracted text, last value assumed 2023"},{"id":"P0304","domain":"economics","parameter":"cost of capital (WACC)","scope":"US Aerospace/Defense industry (79 firms)","value":"7.60","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year, nominal USD","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/New_Home_Page/datafile/wacc.html","locator":"wacc.html, row Aerospace/Defense (Jan 2026 data)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Damodaran; listed incumbents, not start-ups; total US market WACC 6.96%"},{"id":"P0305","domain":"economics","parameter":"cost of equity","scope":"US Aerospace/Defense industry (79 firms)","value":"8.17","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year, nominal USD","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/New_Home_Page/datafile/wacc.html","locator":"wacc.html, row Aerospace/Defense","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"beta 0.95; E/(D+E) 86.53%; pre-tax cost of debt 5.29%"},{"id":"P0306","domain":"economics","parameter":"levered beta","scope":"US Aerospace/Defense industry (79 firms)","value":"0.95","low":"","high":"","unit":"dimensionless","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/New_Home_Page/datafile/wacc.html","locator":"wacc.html, row Aerospace/Defense","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Damodaran Jan 2026"},{"id":"P0307","domain":"economics","parameter":"real discount rate for federal cost-effectiveness analysis","scope":"US government, 30-year horizon","value":"2.3","low":"1.5","high":"2.3","unit":"% per year, real","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://bidenwhitehouse.archives.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/M-25-08-2025-Discount-Rates-for-OMB-Circular-No.-A-94.pdf","locator":"Appendix C, real rates table (3-yr 1.5 to 30-yr 2.3)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"OMB M-25-08, valid for calendar year 2025; not for regulatory or public-investment BCA"},{"id":"P0308","domain":"economics","parameter":"nominal discount rate for federal lease-purchase analysis","scope":"US government, 30-year horizon","value":"4.4","low":"3.7","high":"4.4","unit":"% per year, nominal","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://bidenwhitehouse.archives.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/M-25-08-2025-Discount-Rates-for-OMB-Circular-No.-A-94.pdf","locator":"Appendix C, nominal rates table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"OMB M-25-08"},{"id":"P0309","domain":"economics","parameter":"minimum viable WACC for lunar propellant venture","scope":"commercial lunar ISRU (Charania & DePascuale 2007)","value":"21.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.22 (sec. 4.13)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023: WACC \"deemed minimally viable by Charania and DePascuale considering risk\"; original 2007 study not opened"},{"id":"P0310","domain":"economics","parameter":"discount rate path in baseline lunar propellant model","scope":"lunar ISRU, years 1-30","value":"21.7","low":"12","high":"21.7","unit":"% per year","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.22 (sec. 4.13)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023: starts at 21.7%, falls linearly to 12% at year 30 \"to represent the steady reduction of risk\""},{"id":"P0311","domain":"economics","parameter":"discount rate in normalised TEA comparison","scope":"lunar ISRU studies re-run commercially","value":"27.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.30, p.34 (Fig. 13)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 \"high discount rate of 27.2%\" for the six-study comparison"},{"id":"P0312","domain":"economics","parameter":"discount rate under public-private partnership","scope":"lunar ISRU studies re-run as PPP","value":"12","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year, constant 30 yr","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.30, p.34 (Fig. 15)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023; with 12% all studies except Jones/Bennett reach GTO advantage by year 10"},{"id":"P0313","domain":"economics","parameter":"internal rate of return of commercial lunar propellant venture","scope":"tent-sublimation lunar propellant (Sowers)","value":"8.84","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.33 (sec. 6.4)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023: Sowers IRR 8.84% \"much less than the 21.7%\" needed per Charania & DePascuale; Sowers proposes PPP"},{"id":"P0314","domain":"economics","parameter":"discount rate used for NPV","scope":"Commercial Lunar Propellant Architecture business case","value":"10","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI accepted manuscript PDF p.125 (printed p.107)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019 (ULA-led study); hardware life 10 years"},{"id":"P0315","domain":"economics","parameter":"rate of return, all-customer scenario","scope":"CLPA scenario 7 (LEO+EML1+Moon, 1,640 t/yr at LS)","value":"56","low":"4","high":"56","unit":"% (ROR)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.127 (printed p.109), Table 14","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019; single-customer scenarios: Moon 9%, EML1 19%, LEO 4% (low); NPV USD 10,092M at 10%"},{"id":"P0316","domain":"economics","parameter":"cost of Earth-launched propellant delivered","scope":"LO2/LH2 at LEO","value":"4000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (2019 USD, dollar year not stated)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.118 (printed p.100), Table 11","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019, \"From Earth\" column; based on ~USD 4,000/kg to LEO; section author B. Kutter (ULA)"},{"id":"P0317","domain":"economics","parameter":"price of lunar-derived propellant delivered","scope":"LO2/LH2 at LEO","value":"3000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (2019 USD, dollar year not stated)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.118 (printed p.100), Table 11","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019, \"From Moon\" column, assumes USD 500/kg on lunar surface; LEO figure = 25% discount on USD 4,000/kg (p.121)"},{"id":"P0318","domain":"economics","parameter":"cost of Earth-launched propellant delivered","scope":"LO2/LH2 at GTO","value":"8000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (2019 USD, dollar year not stated)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.118 (printed p.100), Table 11","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019, \"From Earth\" column; based on ~USD 4,000/kg to LEO; section author B. Kutter (ULA)"},{"id":"P0319","domain":"economics","parameter":"price of lunar-derived propellant delivered","scope":"LO2/LH2 at GTO","value":"1500","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (2019 USD, dollar year not stated)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.118 (printed p.100), Table 11","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019, \"From Moon\" column, assumes USD 500/kg on lunar surface; LEO figure = 25% discount on USD 4,000/kg (p.121)"},{"id":"P0320","domain":"economics","parameter":"cost of Earth-launched propellant delivered","scope":"LO2/LH2 at GEO","value":"16000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (2019 USD, dollar year not stated)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.118 (printed p.100), Table 11","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019, \"From Earth\" column; based on ~USD 4,000/kg to LEO; section author B. Kutter (ULA)"},{"id":"P0321","domain":"economics","parameter":"price of lunar-derived propellant delivered","scope":"LO2/LH2 at GEO","value":"1500","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (2019 USD, dollar year not stated)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.118 (printed p.100), Table 11","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019, \"From Moon\" column, assumes USD 500/kg on lunar surface; LEO figure = 25% discount on USD 4,000/kg (p.121)"},{"id":"P0322","domain":"economics","parameter":"cost of Earth-launched propellant delivered","scope":"LO2/LH2 at EML1","value":"12000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (2019 USD, dollar year not stated)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.118 (printed p.100), Table 11","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019, \"From Earth\" column; based on ~USD 4,000/kg to LEO; section author B. Kutter (ULA)"},{"id":"P0323","domain":"economics","parameter":"price of lunar-derived propellant delivered","scope":"LO2/LH2 at EML1","value":"1000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (2019 USD, dollar year not stated)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.118 (printed p.100), Table 11","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019, \"From Moon\" column, assumes USD 500/kg on lunar surface; LEO figure = 25% discount on USD 4,000/kg (p.121)"},{"id":"P0324","domain":"economics","parameter":"cost of Earth-launched propellant delivered","scope":"LO2/LH2 at lunar surface","value":"36000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (2019 USD, dollar year not stated)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.118 (printed p.100), Table 11","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019, \"From Earth\" column; based on ~USD 4,000/kg to LEO; section author B. Kutter (ULA)"},{"id":"P0325","domain":"economics","parameter":"price of lunar-derived propellant delivered","scope":"LO2/LH2 at lunar surface","value":"500","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (2019 USD, dollar year not stated)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.118 (printed p.100), Table 11","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019, \"From Moon\" column, assumes USD 500/kg on lunar surface; LEO figure = 25% discount on USD 4,000/kg (p.121)"},{"id":"P0326","domain":"economics","parameter":"initial investment for lunar propellant plant","scope":"CLPA plant, 450 t/yr propellant, 2,450 t/yr water","value":"4","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (2019 USD)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.6 (Executive Summary) and p.125","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019; earlier notes cite USD 2.5B Capture Tent figure (snippet-only); this page-checked figure supersedes"},{"id":"P0327","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual revenue of lunar propellant plant","scope":"CLPA, 450 t/yr lunar-derived propellant","value":"2.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion per year (2019 USD)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.5 (Executive Summary)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019"},{"id":"P0328","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific development cost of lunar mining hardware","scope":"CLPA business case","value":"100000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg of hardware (2019 USD)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.125 (printed p.107)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"double the rate used in the Mine Sizing section for a more conservative estimate (i.e. Sowers USD 50k/kg)"},{"id":"P0329","domain":"economics","parameter":"transport cost Earth to lunar surface for capital","scope":"CLPA business case (Vulcan/XEUS-class)","value":"35000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (2019 USD)","year":"2019","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.125 (printed p.107)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019 citing Sowers 2018; vehicle never flew"},{"id":"P0330","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual operations cost of lunar propellant plant","scope":"CLPA business case","value":"20","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million per year (2019 USD)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.125 (printed p.107)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"plus 800 kg/yr replacement parts (ISS analogy)"},{"id":"P0331","domain":"economics","parameter":"break-even lunar propellant price, Moon-only customer","scope":"CLPA scenario 1 (100 t/yr at LS)","value":"7500","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg at lunar surface (2019 USD)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.125, p.127 Table 14","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019 customer willingness to pay; scenario NPV -234 USD M, ROR 9%"},{"id":"P0332","domain":"economics","parameter":"lunar propellant price, all-customer average","scope":"CLPA scenario 7 (1,640 t/yr at LS)","value":"1482","low":"500","high":"7500","unit":"USD/kg at lunar surface (2019 USD)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.126-127, Table 14","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"demand-weighted average across LEO (500), EML1 (3,750) and Moon (7,500) customers"},{"id":"P0333","domain":"economics","parameter":"commercial satellite hardware manufacturing cost","scope":"heritage satellite bus","value":"30000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (2019 USD)","year":"2019","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.141 (printed p.123)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Kornuta et al. 2019 cost-reduction section; mining equipment ~USD 20/kg, nuclear ships ~USD 50/kg, fighter aircraft USD 5,000-20,000/kg"},{"id":"P0334","domain":"economics","parameter":"production mass ratio phi (propellant delivered over plant life per kg of plant)","scope":"Kornuta et al. 2019 (tent sublimation)","value":"442","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant / kg plant (lifetime)","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.28, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023. K = 441.8 in text (p.33)"},{"id":"P0335","domain":"economics","parameter":"production mass ratio phi (propellant delivered over plant life per kg of plant)","scope":"Sowers (tent sublimation)","value":"534","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant / kg plant (lifetime)","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.28, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023."},{"id":"P0336","domain":"economics","parameter":"production mass ratio phi (propellant delivered over plant life per kg of plant)","scope":"Pelech et al. (borehole sublimation)","value":"16.1","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant / kg plant (lifetime)","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.28, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023."},{"id":"P0337","domain":"economics","parameter":"production mass ratio phi (propellant delivered over plant life per kg of plant)","scope":"Charania & DePascuale (strip mining)","value":"26.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant / kg plant (lifetime)","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.28, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023."},{"id":"P0338","domain":"economics","parameter":"production mass ratio phi (propellant delivered over plant life per kg of plant)","scope":"Jones et al. 2019 (strip mining, MRE analogy)","value":"22.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant / kg plant (lifetime)","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.28, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023. Metzger argues the MRE analogy is inappropriate"},{"id":"P0339","domain":"economics","parameter":"production mass ratio phi (propellant delivered over plant life per kg of plant)","scope":"Bennett et al. (Jones redesign)","value":"43.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant / kg plant (lifetime)","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.28, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023."},{"id":"P0340","domain":"economics","parameter":"production mass ratio phi (propellant delivered over plant life per kg of plant)","scope":"Pelech et al. (strip mining)","value":"3.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant / kg plant (lifetime)","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.28, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023."},{"id":"P0341","domain":"economics","parameter":"production mass ratio phi (propellant delivered over plant life per kg of plant)","scope":"Metzger et al. (beneficiation, minimum viable product)","value":"36.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant / kg plant (lifetime)","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.28, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023."},{"id":"P0342","domain":"economics","parameter":"production mass ratio phi (propellant delivered over plant life per kg of plant)","scope":"Metzger 2023 baseline model","value":"167","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant / kg plant (lifetime)","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.28, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023."},{"id":"P0343","domain":"economics","parameter":"threshold phi for absolute advantage of lunar propellant","scope":"lunar water-ice propellant vs Earth-launched","value":"35","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant / kg plant (lifetime)","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.40 (Conclusions)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"The threshold of absolute advantage in this modeling is phi >~ 35; lower bound, location-dependent"},{"id":"P0344","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific development cost of lunar ISRU capital","scope":"Metzger 2023 baseline","value":"120","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD thousand/kg of hardware (2022 USD)","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"study values (footnote digits merged in extraction): K ~90.7, S 50.2, CD ~149.6, J ~122, B ~191, M ~117"},{"id":"P0345","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific fabrication cost of lunar ISRU capital","scope":"Metzger 2023 baseline","value":"40","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD thousand/kg of hardware (2022 USD)","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"study values: K ~22.7, S ~41.9, CD ~60.8, J ~30.5, B ~47.6, M ~29.4 (footnote digits merged in extraction; check PDF)"},{"id":"P0346","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific development cost of lunar ISRU capital","scope":"Kornuta et al. 2019 (K) normalised","value":"90.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD thousand/kg of hardware (2022 USD)","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023; extracted \"90.75\" read as 90.7 + footnote 5; conflicts with Kornuta own USD 100k/kg (2019 USD) because Metzger normalises"},{"id":"P0347","domain":"economics","parameter":"gear ratio on cost for capital transport (G)","scope":"Charania & DePascuale (government launchers)","value":"64.9","low":"8","high":"64.9","unit":"dimensionless (cost to land 1 kg on Moon / cost to launch 1 kg to LEO)","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.29","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023; switching to commercial launch G=8 cuts LS propellant cost 59% in year 1"},{"id":"P0348","domain":"economics","parameter":"gear ratio on cost for capital transport (G)","scope":"Jones et al. using SLS, at current prices","value":"41.8","low":"5.4","high":"41.8","unit":"dimensionless","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.30","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023: G = 5.4 at time of study, 41.8 now since commercial HLLV prices fell but SLS did not"},{"id":"P0349","domain":"economics","parameter":"gear ratio on cost for capital transport (G)","scope":"Pelech et al. using Falcon Heavy","value":"7.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"dimensionless","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.31","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023"},{"id":"P0350","domain":"economics","parameter":"elasticity of lunar/terrestrial propellant cost ratio to launch cost L0","scope":"Metzger 2023 model, G/x = 0.02 / 1 / 50","value":"-0.692","low":"-0.947","high":"-0.040","unit":"dimensionless elasticity","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.29, Table 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"value at G/x=1; -0.947 at G/x=0.02, -0.040 at G/x=50: lunar propellant insulated from falling launch cost when G >> x"},{"id":"P0351","domain":"economics","parameter":"cost premium of lunar ISRU propellant over Earth-launched","scope":"cis-lunar propellant, 59 t/yr for 14 years (Jones et al. 2019 SciTech)","value":"97","low":"","high":"","unit":"% more expensive","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205007564/downloads/ISRU-Paper3-Final.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20205007564 PDF p.4 (literature review)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Jones et al. 2020 summarising own 2019 SciTech study; also quoted in Metzger 2023; SciTech paper itself not opened"},{"id":"P0352","domain":"economics","parameter":"least-cost lunar ISRU propellant architecture cost","scope":"Jones et al. 2019 SciTech cis-lunar ISRU","value":"78000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (dollar year not stated)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.researchgate.net/publication/330196389_Cost_Breakeven_Analysis_of_Cis-lunar_ISRU_for_Propellant","locator":"ResearchGate abstract","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"from search snippet only; paper not opened"},{"id":"P0353","domain":"economics","parameter":"ISRU spares rate","scope":"NASA Langley lunar ISRU cost models (Jones et al.)","value":"10","low":"","high":"28","unit":"% of plant mass replaced per year","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205007564/downloads/ISRU-Paper3-Final.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20205007564 PDF p.6 (assumptions table: 0.1 kg/kg of system/year)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"also 10.00 wt%/yr in Jones et al. 2019 IAC p.3; Yang et al. 28%/yr for nuclear strip mining per Metzger 2023 (high)"},{"id":"P0354","domain":"economics","parameter":"time to ISRU break-even","scope":"one crewed lunar mission/yr (17 t/yr), ISRU lifetime ~3 yr","value":"3","low":"","high":"","unit":"missions (years)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200002704/downloads/20200002704.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20200002704 PDF p.11 (Conclusions)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Jones et al. 2019 IAC; extending ISRU lifetime 1->3 yr raises share of break-even cases from 0% to 49% (MREE model) and 42% to 63% (Duke model); TRL-6 development costs excluded"},{"id":"P0355","domain":"economics","parameter":"price elasticity of launch demand below threshold","scope":"commercial space launch market (Ross et al. 2009)","value":"2.0","low":"1.5","high":"2.5","unit":"absolute elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2009","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.18 (sec. 4.8)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"as reported in Metzger 2023: Ross et al. used 1.5 pessimistic, 2.0 nominal, 2.5 optimistic; Ross et al. 2009 Astropolitics not opened"},{"id":"P0356","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts per year","scope":"world","value":"87","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2015","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt Total column, row 2015","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell GCAT count"},{"id":"P0357","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts per year","scope":"world","value":"85","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2016","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt Total column, row 2016","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell GCAT count"},{"id":"P0358","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts per year","scope":"world","value":"90","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2017","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt Total column, row 2017","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell GCAT count"},{"id":"P0359","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts per year","scope":"world","value":"114","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2018","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt Total column, row 2018","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell GCAT count"},{"id":"P0360","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts per year","scope":"world","value":"102","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2019","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt Total column, row 2019","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell GCAT count"},{"id":"P0361","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts per year","scope":"world","value":"114","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2020","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt Total column, row 2020","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell GCAT count"},{"id":"P0362","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts per year","scope":"world","value":"146","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt Total column, row 2021","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell GCAT count"},{"id":"P0363","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts per year","scope":"world","value":"186","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2022","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt Total column, row 2022","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell GCAT count"},{"id":"P0364","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts per year","scope":"world","value":"223","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt Total column, row 2023","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell GCAT count"},{"id":"P0365","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts per year","scope":"world","value":"262","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt Total column, row 2024","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell GCAT count"},{"id":"P0366","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts per year","scope":"world","value":"329","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt Total column, row 2025","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"McDowell GCAT count; Wikipedia 2025_in_spaceflight gives 330 (P-row below)"},{"id":"P0367","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts year to date","scope":"world","value":"253","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt Total column, row 2026","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"partial year; tab1c data last updated 2026-10-26; Wikipedia 2026_in_spaceflight gives 257 to 2026-11-05 (different cut-off)"},{"id":"P0368","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts by US","scope":"USA","value":"181","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt US column, row 2025","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"Wikipedia 2025_in_spaceflight gives 198 for USA (counts Starship suborbital tests and attribution differ)"},{"id":"P0369","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts by China","scope":"China","value":"92","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt CN column, row 2025","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"Wikipedia gives 93"},{"id":"P0370","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts by US year to date","scope":"USA","value":"133","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt US column, row 2026","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"partial year to about 2026-10-26"},{"id":"P0371","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts by China year to date","scope":"China","value":"76","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1a.txt","locator":"tab1a.txt CN column, row 2026","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"partial year to about 2026-10-26"},{"id":"P0372","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch failures per year","scope":"world","value":"11","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1c.txt","locator":"tab1c.txt Total column, row 2023","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0373","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch failures per year","scope":"world","value":"5","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1c.txt","locator":"tab1c.txt Total column, row 2024","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0374","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch failures per year","scope":"world","value":"8","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1c.txt","locator":"tab1c.txt Total column, row 2025","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"Wikipedia 2025_in_spaceflight gives 13 failures for 2025"},{"id":"P0375","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch failures year to date","scope":"world","value":"6","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/tab1c.txt","locator":"tab1c.txt Total column, row 2026","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"data last updated 2026-10-26; Wikipedia gives 7 to 2026-11-05"},{"id":"P0376","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts per year (Wikipedia count)","scope":"world","value":"330","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2025_in_spaceflight","locator":"statistics table, world total","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"317 successes, 13 failures; conflicts with McDowell 329/8"},{"id":"P0377","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch failures per year (Wikipedia count)","scope":"world","value":"13","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2025_in_spaceflight","locator":"statistics table, world total","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"McDowell tab1c gives 8"},{"id":"P0378","domain":"technology","parameter":"orbital launch attempts year to date (Wikipedia count)","scope":"world","value":"257","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_in_spaceflight","locator":"statistics table, world total","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"250 successes, 7 failures; table runs to last launch 2026-11-05"},{"id":"P0379","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload mass launched to orbit per year","scope":"world","value":"347.1","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2015","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/msatannual.txt","locator":"msatannual.txt Total column, row 2015","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell payload tonnage; unit not stated on file, pay.html calls it payload tonnage (assumed tonnes)"},{"id":"P0380","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload mass launched to orbit per year","scope":"world","value":"399.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2019","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/msatannual.txt","locator":"msatannual.txt Total column, row 2019","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell payload tonnage; unit not stated on file, pay.html calls it payload tonnage (assumed tonnes)"},{"id":"P0381","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload mass launched to orbit per year","scope":"world","value":"572.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2020","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/msatannual.txt","locator":"msatannual.txt Total column, row 2020","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell payload tonnage; unit not stated on file, pay.html calls it payload tonnage (assumed tonnes)"},{"id":"P0382","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload mass launched to orbit per year","scope":"world","value":"797.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/msatannual.txt","locator":"msatannual.txt Total column, row 2021","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell payload tonnage; unit not stated on file, pay.html calls it payload tonnage (assumed tonnes)"},{"id":"P0383","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload mass launched to orbit per year","scope":"world","value":"1046.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2022","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/msatannual.txt","locator":"msatannual.txt Total column, row 2022","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell payload tonnage; unit not stated on file, pay.html calls it payload tonnage (assumed tonnes)"},{"id":"P0384","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload mass launched to orbit per year","scope":"world","value":"1462.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/msatannual.txt","locator":"msatannual.txt Total column, row 2023","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell payload tonnage; unit not stated on file, pay.html calls it payload tonnage (assumed tonnes)"},{"id":"P0385","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload mass launched to orbit per year","scope":"world","value":"2625.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/msatannual.txt","locator":"msatannual.txt Total column, row 2024","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell payload tonnage; unit not stated on file, pay.html calls it payload tonnage (assumed tonnes)"},{"id":"P0386","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload mass launched to orbit per year","scope":"world","value":"3194.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/msatannual.txt","locator":"msatannual.txt Total column, row 2025","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McDowell payload tonnage; unit not stated on file, pay.html calls it payload tonnage (assumed tonnes)"},{"id":"P0387","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload mass launched to orbit year to date","scope":"world","value":"2447.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/msatannual.txt","locator":"msatannual.txt Total column, row 2026","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"partial year; unit assumed tonnes"},{"id":"P0388","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload mass launched to orbit by US","scope":"USA","value":"2712.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/msatannual.txt","locator":"msatannual.txt USA column, row 2025","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"85% of world total; unit assumed tonnes"},{"id":"P0389","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload mass launched to orbit by China","scope":"China","value":"315.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/msatannual.txt","locator":"msatannual.txt PRC column, row 2025","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"unit assumed tonnes"},{"id":"P0390","domain":"technology","parameter":"payloads launched per year","scope":"world","value":"4526","low":"","high":"","unit":"satellites","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/satannual.txt","locator":"satannual.txt Total column, row 2025","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"record year"},{"id":"P0391","domain":"technology","parameter":"payloads launched year to date","scope":"world","value":"3635","low":"","high":"","unit":"satellites","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/satannual.txt","locator":"satannual.txt Total column, row 2026","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"partial year"},{"id":"P0392","domain":"technology","parameter":"payloads launched per year","scope":"world","value":"2864","low":"","high":"","unit":"satellites","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://planet4589.org/space/stats/out/satannual.txt","locator":"satannual.txt Total column, row 2024","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0393","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO, expendable","scope":"Falcon 9 Block 5","value":"22.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9","locator":"infobox / Block 5 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"manufacturer-stated capability, not flown maximum"},{"id":"P0394","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO, reusable (drone ship)","scope":"Falcon 9 Block 5","value":"17.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9","locator":"Block 5 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Full Thrust text gives 17.5 t"},{"id":"P0395","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to GTO, expendable","scope":"Falcon 9 Block 5","value":"8.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9","locator":"Block 5 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0396","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to GTO, reusable","scope":"Falcon 9 Block 5","value":"5.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9","locator":"Block 5 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Full Thrust drone-ship figure 5.5 t"},{"id":"P0397","domain":"technology","parameter":"launches per year","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"165","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2025_in_spaceflight","locator":"by family table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"165 successes, 0 failures"},{"id":"P0398","domain":"technology","parameter":"launches year to date","scope":"Falcon 9 Block 5","value":"118","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_in_spaceflight","locator":"by family table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"to 2026-11-05; Falcon Heavy 3 more"},{"id":"P0399","domain":"technology","parameter":"cumulative launches","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"701","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9","locator":"lead / infobox, as of 2026-11-07","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"698 full successes"},{"id":"P0400","domain":"technology","parameter":"cumulative mission success rate","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"99.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9","locator":"lead, as of 2026-11-07","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"698/701"},{"id":"P0401","domain":"technology","parameter":"cumulative booster landings","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"659","low":"","high":"","unit":"landings","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9","locator":"infobox, as of 2026-11-07","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"of 670 attempts"},{"id":"P0402","domain":"technology","parameter":"max flights by a single booster","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"37","low":"","high":"","unit":"flights","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9","locator":"infobox, as of 2026-11-07","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"B1067; 37th flight 2026-08-25 (AIAA, snippet); 33rd 2026-02-22"},{"id":"P0403","domain":"technology","parameter":"max flights by a single booster (date of 33rd flight)","scope":"Falcon 9 B1067","value":"2026","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://spaceflightnow.com/2026/02/21/live-coverage-spacexs-most-flown-falcon-booster-to-launch-on-record-33rd-flight/","locator":"headline","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"33rd flight 2026-02-22; previous record 32 set 2025-12-08"},{"id":"P0404","domain":"technology","parameter":"fastest booster turnaround","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"9","low":"","high":"","unit":"days","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.bgr.com/2273946/spacex-falcon-9-rocket-booster-reuse-37th-time/","locator":"search summary","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"B1088, March 2025; not verified on page"},{"id":"P0405","domain":"technology","parameter":"list price per launch","scope":"Falcon 9 Block 5","value":"74","low":"","high":"","unit":"million USD (2026)","year":"2026","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9","locator":"infobox / pricing section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0406","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO, design","scope":"Starship Block 2","value":"35","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Starship","locator":"infobox block table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"reusable vs expendable not split on page"},{"id":"P0407","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO, design","scope":"Starship Block 3 (V3)","value":"100","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Starship","locator":"infobox block table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"first flown on flight 12, 2026-05-22"},{"id":"P0408","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO, design","scope":"Starship Block 4","value":"200","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Starship","locator":"infobox block table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"page labels it estimated"},{"id":"P0409","domain":"technology","parameter":"ship propellant capacity","scope":"Starship Block 3","value":"1600","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Starship","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0410","domain":"technology","parameter":"booster propellant capacity","scope":"Super Heavy Block 3","value":"3650","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Starship","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0411","domain":"technology","parameter":"integrated flight tests to date","scope":"Starship","value":"14","low":"","high":"","unit":"flights","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Starship","locator":"status, as of 2026-09-28","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"9 successes, 5 failures per page"},{"id":"P0412","domain":"technology","parameter":"integrated flight tests per year","scope":"Starship","value":"5","low":"","high":"","unit":"flights","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Starship_vehicles","locator":"flight table (flights 7-11)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"flights 7,8,9 failed (ship); 10,11 succeeded"},{"id":"P0413","domain":"technology","parameter":"integrated flight tests year to date","scope":"Starship","value":"3","low":"","high":"","unit":"flights","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Starship_vehicles","locator":"flight table (flights 12-14)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2026-05-21/22, 2026-07-24, 2026-09-28; Wikipedia 2026_in_spaceflight family table shows only 1 (stale)"},{"id":"P0414","domain":"technology","parameter":"first Starship orbital flight","scope":"Starship","value":"2026","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starship_HLS","locator":"milestones","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"flight 14, 2026-09-28; 26 Starlink V3 deployed; early engine shutdown"},{"id":"P0415","domain":"technology","parameter":"max flights by a single booster","scope":"Super Heavy","value":"2","low":"","high":"","unit":"flights","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Super_Heavy_boosters","locator":"booster table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"B14 (flights 7,9) and B15 (flights 8,11); no reflight in 2026"},{"id":"P0416","domain":"technology","parameter":"booster tower catches to date","scope":"Super Heavy","value":"3","low":"","high":"","unit":"catches","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Super_Heavy_boosters","locator":"booster table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"B12 2024-10-13, B14 2025-01-16, B15 2025-03-06; none in 2026"},{"id":"P0417","domain":"technology","parameter":"first attempt to catch both stages (planned date)","scope":"Starship flight 15","value":"2026","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://spacepolicyonline.com/events/starship-ift-15-launch-and-catch-nov-13-2026-starbase-tx-launch-window-is-545-700-pm-et/","locator":"event listing","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"planned 2026-11-13, window 22:45-24:00 UTC; ship never caught before"},{"id":"P0418","domain":"technology","parameter":"Starlink V3 satellites deployed per flight","scope":"Starship flight 14","value":"26","low":"","high":"","unit":"satellites","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Starship_vehicles","locator":"flight table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"flight 12: 22; flight 13: 20"},{"id":"P0419","domain":"technology","parameter":"tanker launches to refuel one Starship in LEO","scope":"Starship","value":"8","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Starship","locator":"refuelling section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Musk estimate; a NASA official (2023) said high teens for a lunar landing"},{"id":"P0420","domain":"technology","parameter":"ship-to-ship propellant transfer demo, current target","scope":"Starship","value":"2027","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starship_Propellant_Transfer_Demonstration","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"NET Q1 2027; originally 2025-03, then 2026-03 (NASA OIG 2026-03-10); not flown"},{"id":"P0421","domain":"technology","parameter":"ship-to-ship propellant transfer demo, original target","scope":"Starship","value":"2025","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2023","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starship_Propellant_Transfer_Demonstration","locator":"lead","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"originally March 2025; slip about 2 years"},{"id":"P0422","domain":"technology","parameter":"ship-to-ship propellant transfer demo, SpaceX expectation","scope":"Starship","value":"2027","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://spacepolicyonline.com/news/nasa-is-full-steam-ahead-on-artemis-iii-iv-and-v/","locator":"article 2026-10-23","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"early 2027 per SpaceX at NASA briefing"},{"id":"P0423","domain":"technology","parameter":"uncrewed lunar landing demo, target","scope":"Starship HLS","value":"2027","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starship_HLS","locator":"Artemis section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"late 2027 per NASA IAC Oct 2026 schedule; originally 2025"},{"id":"P0424","domain":"technology","parameter":"HLS contract value Option A","scope":"Starship HLS","value":"2.89","low":"","high":"","unit":"billion USD","year":"2021","method":"contract","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starship_HLS","locator":"contract section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"firm fixed price"},{"id":"P0425","domain":"technology","parameter":"HLS contract value Option B","scope":"Starship HLS","value":"1.15","low":"","high":"","unit":"billion USD","year":"2022","method":"contract","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starship_HLS","locator":"contract section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"announced 2022-11-15 for a second crewed landing"},{"id":"P0426","domain":"technology","parameter":"HLS-specific milestones completed","scope":"Starship HLS","value":"30","low":"","high":"","unit":"milestones","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starship_HLS","locator":"milestones, Feb 2024","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"NASA: over 30; no later count found"},{"id":"P0427","domain":"technology","parameter":"Artemis II launch date","scope":"Artemis II / SLS-Orion","value":"2026","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artemis_II","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"launched 2026-04-01 22:35 UTC; crewed lunar flyby, success"},{"id":"P0428","domain":"technology","parameter":"Artemis II mission duration","scope":"Artemis II","value":"9.06","low":"","high":"","unit":"days","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artemis_II","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"9 d 1 h 32 min 15 s; splashdown 2026-04-11 00:07 UTC"},{"id":"P0429","domain":"technology","parameter":"Artemis II max distance from Earth","scope":"Artemis II","value":"406771","low":"","high":"","unit":"km","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artemis_II","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"record for crewed flight, beats Apollo 13"},{"id":"P0430","domain":"technology","parameter":"Artemis II closest lunar approach altitude","scope":"Artemis II","value":"6545","low":"","high":"","unit":"km","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artemis_II","locator":"mission section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2026-04-06"},{"id":"P0431","domain":"technology","parameter":"Artemis II earliest planned launch","scope":"Artemis II","value":"2023","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2011","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artemis_II","locator":"launch date history","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"2011 reviews: 2019-2021, later 2023; Sep 2025 (Jan 2024); Apr 2026 (Dec 2024); Feb 2026 window; flew 2026-04-01"},{"id":"P0432","domain":"technology","parameter":"Artemis II launch slip vs Sep 2025 target","scope":"Artemis II","value":"7","low":"","high":"","unit":"months","year":"2026","method":"derived","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artemis_II","locator":"launch date history","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"2025-09 target (Jan 2024) to 2026-04-01 actual"},{"id":"P0433","domain":"technology","parameter":"Artemis III date (LEO docking demo)","scope":"Artemis III","value":"2027","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://spacepolicyonline.com/news/nasa-is-full-steam-ahead-on-artemis-iii-iv-and-v/","locator":"article 2026-10-23","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"mid-2027; redefined 2026-03-03 from landing to LEO test; Isaacman: 90 days behind"},{"id":"P0434","domain":"technology","parameter":"first Artemis crewed lunar landing target","scope":"Artemis IV","value":"2028","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://spacepolicyonline.com/news/nasa-is-full-steam-ahead-on-artemis-iii-iv-and-v/","locator":"article 2026-10-23","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"early 2028; Artemis V also 2028; lander (Starship or Blue Moon MK2) not chosen"},{"id":"P0435","domain":"technology","parameter":"Artemis III original landing target","scope":"Artemis III","value":"2026","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2024","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starship_HLS","locator":"Artemis section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"Jan 2024: NET Sep 2026 crewed landing; landing moved to Artemis IV 2028"},{"id":"P0436","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO, reusable","scope":"New Glenn 7x2","value":"45","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Glenn","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0437","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to GTO","scope":"New Glenn 7x2","value":"13.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Glenn","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0438","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to TLI","scope":"New Glenn 7x2","value":"7","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Glenn","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0439","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO","scope":"New Glenn 9x4","value":"70","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Glenn","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":">70 t; TLI >20 t; service possibly 2027 (media)"},{"id":"P0440","domain":"technology","parameter":"launches to date","scope":"New Glenn","value":"3","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Glenn","locator":"flight history","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"NG-1 2025-01-16, NG-2 2025-11-13 success; NG-3 2026-04-19 failure (upper stage)"},{"id":"P0441","domain":"technology","parameter":"booster landings to date","scope":"New Glenn","value":"2","low":"","high":"","unit":"landings","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Glenn","locator":"flight history","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"GS1-2 landed NG-2 and NG-3 (first reuse); GS1-1 lost"},{"id":"P0442","domain":"technology","parameter":"booster design life","scope":"New Glenn","value":"25","low":"","high":"","unit":"flights","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Glenn","locator":"booster section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"minimum design target"},{"id":"P0443","domain":"technology","parameter":"Blue Moon MK1 first launch target","scope":"Blue Moon MK1","value":"2027","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Glenn","locator":"planned missions","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"MK1-101 Q1 2027; GS1-3 static-fire explosion at LC-36 2026-05-28 may delay over a year"},{"id":"P0444","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO, reusable downrange","scope":"Neutron","value":"13","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket_Lab_Neutron","locator":"applications","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"RTLS 8.5 t"},{"id":"P0445","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO, expendable","scope":"Neutron","value":"15","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket_Lab_Neutron","locator":"applications","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0446","domain":"technology","parameter":"first launch target, current","scope":"Neutron","value":"2027","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket_Lab_Neutron","locator":"design history, Oct 2026","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"originally NET July 2025 (Dec 2021); then 2026; slipped to 2027 after stage-1 dome defect"},{"id":"P0447","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO, reusable","scope":"Terran R","value":"23.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terran_R","locator":"design section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"2023 design; 2021 plan 20 t"},{"id":"P0448","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO, expendable","scope":"Terran R","value":"33.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terran_R","locator":"design section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0449","domain":"technology","parameter":"first launch target","scope":"Terran R","value":"2026","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2025","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.satellitetoday.com/launch/2025/11/12/ses-signs-on-for-multiple-terran-r-launches-with-relativity-space/","locator":"press article 2025-11-12","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"late 2026 from LC-16; trackers now expect 2027 (unconfirmed)"},{"id":"P0450","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO","scope":"Long March 10","value":"70","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_March_10","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"TLI >=27 t; uncrewed Mengzhou TLI test 2027; crewed landing 2029"},{"id":"P0451","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO, first stage recovered","scope":"Long March 10A","value":"14","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_March_10","locator":"10A section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"18 t expendable"},{"id":"P0452","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO 200 km","scope":"Long March 10B","value":"16","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_March_10","locator":"10B section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0453","domain":"technology","parameter":"first orbital flight with booster recovery, China","scope":"Long March 10B","value":"2026","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_in_spaceflight","locator":"events","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2026-07-10, first stage caught by ship-borne net"},{"id":"P0454","domain":"technology","parameter":"Long March 10A first orbital flight target","scope":"Long March 10A / Mengzhou 1","value":"2027","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_March_10","locator":"flight table vs lead","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"conflict","note":"table Q1 2027; lead late 2026"},{"id":"P0455","domain":"technology","parameter":"max-q abort test of Mengzhou on LM-10 test stage","scope":"Long March 10 / Mengzhou","value":"2026","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mengzhou_(spacecraft)","locator":"tests section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2026-02-11; abort at ~65 s; booster splashed ~200 m from recovery vessel"},{"id":"P0456","domain":"technology","parameter":"Mengzhou mass, lunar configuration","scope":"Mengzhou","value":"21.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mengzhou_(spacecraft)","locator":"specs","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"LEO configuration 14 t"},{"id":"P0457","domain":"technology","parameter":"Chinese crewed lunar landing target","scope":"Mengzhou / Lanyue","value":"2030","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mengzhou_(spacecraft)","locator":"lead","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"before 2030"},{"id":"P0458","domain":"technology","parameter":"Lanyue integrated landing and takeoff test","scope":"Lanyue","value":"2025","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://jatan.space/moon-monday-issue-237/","locator":"search summary","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"2025-08-06 at Huailai, Hebei; ground test"},{"id":"P0459","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO","scope":"Long March 9","value":"150","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_March_9","locator":"current plans","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"TLI 54 t; first flight planned 2033"},{"id":"P0460","domain":"technology","parameter":"first flight target","scope":"Long March 9","value":"2033","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_March_9","locator":"current plans","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"fully reusable two-stage version 2040s"},{"id":"P0461","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO, expendable","scope":"Zhuque-3","value":"11.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhuque-3","locator":"specs","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"8 t with downrange recovery; ZQ-3E 21.3 t"},{"id":"P0462","domain":"technology","parameter":"first successful booster landing","scope":"Zhuque-3","value":"2026","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhuque-3","locator":"flight 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2026-08-18, landed 390 km downrange then tipped over after fire; flight 1 2025-12-03 landing failed"},{"id":"P0463","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO","scope":"Ariane 64","value":"21.65","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ariane_6","locator":"specs table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"description gives 21.5 t"},{"id":"P0464","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to GTO","scope":"Ariane 64","value":"11.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ariane_6","locator":"specs table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"A62: 4.5 t GTO, 10.35 t LEO"},{"id":"P0465","domain":"technology","parameter":"launches per year","scope":"Ariane 6","value":"4","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ariane_6","locator":"flight table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"all successes"},{"id":"P0466","domain":"technology","parameter":"launches year to date","scope":"Ariane 6","value":"4","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ariane_6","locator":"flight table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"to VA270 2026-08-27; A64 maiden 2026-02-12"},{"id":"P0467","domain":"technology","parameter":"first flight slip","scope":"Ariane 6","value":"4","low":"","high":"","unit":"years","year":"2024","method":"derived","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ariane_6","locator":"development","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"planned 2020, flew 2024-07-09"},{"id":"P0468","domain":"technology","parameter":"list price per launch","scope":"Ariane 62","value":"100","low":"","high":"","unit":"million EUR","year":"2024","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ariane_6","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"2024 estimate; original 70"},{"id":"P0469","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO","scope":"Vulcan VC6","value":"27.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vulcan_Centaur","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"GTO 15.3 t, TLI 12.1 t (upgraded)"},{"id":"P0470","domain":"technology","parameter":"launches per year","scope":"Vulcan","value":"1","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vulcan_Centaur","locator":"flight table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0471","domain":"technology","parameter":"launches year to date","scope":"Vulcan","value":"1","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vulcan_Centaur","locator":"flight table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2026-02-12, second SRB anomaly; NSSL pause"},{"id":"P0472","domain":"technology","parameter":"first flight slip","scope":"Vulcan","value":"5","low":"","high":"","unit":"years","year":"2024","method":"derived","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vulcan_Centaur","locator":"development","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"planned 2019, flew 2024-01-08"},{"id":"P0473","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload to LEO","scope":"H3-24","value":"16","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H3_(rocket)","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"GTO 7.9 t"},{"id":"P0474","domain":"technology","parameter":"launches per year","scope":"H3","value":"3","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H3_(rocket)","locator":"flight table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"one failure 2025-12-22 (F8)"},{"id":"P0475","domain":"technology","parameter":"launches year to date","scope":"H3","value":"3","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H3_(rocket)","locator":"flight table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"all successes incl. MMX 2026-10-19"},{"id":"P0476","domain":"technology","parameter":"cumulative success rate","scope":"H3","value":"80","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H3_(rocket)","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"8 of 10"},{"id":"P0477","domain":"technology","parameter":"specific impulse","scope":"SPT-140 Hall thruster (Psyche)","value":"1800","low":"","high":"","unit":"s","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psyche_(spacecraft)","locator":"propulsion spec table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"flight heritage since 2023-10-13 launch"},{"id":"P0478","domain":"technology","parameter":"thrust","scope":"SPT-140 Hall thruster (Psyche)","value":"0.28","low":"","high":"","unit":"N","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psyche_(spacecraft)","locator":"propulsion spec table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"280 mN"},{"id":"P0479","domain":"technology","parameter":"max input power","scope":"SPT-140 Hall thruster (Psyche)","value":"4.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"kW","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psyche_(spacecraft)","locator":"propulsion spec table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"min 0.9 kW"},{"id":"P0480","domain":"technology","parameter":"xenon propellant mass","scope":"Psyche","value":"922","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psyche_(spacecraft)","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0481","domain":"technology","parameter":"solar array power at Earth","scope":"Psyche","value":"20","low":"","high":"","unit":"kW","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psyche_(spacecraft)","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2.3 kW at asteroid"},{"id":"P0482","domain":"technology","parameter":"Psyche arrival at asteroid","scope":"Psyche","value":"2029","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psyche_(spacecraft)","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"orbit insertion 2029-08; Mars flyby 2026-05-15 done"},{"id":"P0483","domain":"technology","parameter":"power per thruster","scope":"AEPS 12 kW Hall thruster","value":"12","low":"","high":"","unit":"kW","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20260002899/downloads/20260002899%20Final.pdf","locator":"Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"12-13 kW requirement; 3x state of the art"},{"id":"P0484","domain":"technology","parameter":"specific impulse requirement","scope":"AEPS 12 kW Hall thruster","value":"2600","low":"","high":"","unit":"s","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20260002899/downloads/20260002899%20Final.pdf","locator":"Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":">2600 s at 600 V; flight units meet it across 9-12 kW (text)"},{"id":"P0485","domain":"technology","parameter":"thrust at full power","scope":"AEPS 12 kW Hall thruster","value":"0.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"N","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20240011790/downloads/IAC%20NASA%20Progress%20on%20SEP%20Thruster%20prsnt%20rev1.pdf","locator":"IAC 2024 briefing (search summary)","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"self-assessment","status":"must-check","note":"about 600 mN, ~2800 s"},{"id":"P0486","domain":"technology","parameter":"xenon throughput requirement","scope":"AEPS 12 kW Hall thruster","value":"1770","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20260002899/downloads/20260002899%20Final.pdf","locator":"Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"plus 50% margin; 7x state of the art"},{"id":"P0487","domain":"technology","parameter":"AEPS flight thrusters delivered","scope":"Gateway PPE","value":"3","low":"","high":"","unit":"thrusters","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20260002899/downloads/20260002899%20Final.pdf","locator":"abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"acceptance-tested 2025; life qualification wear test from fall 2026; QSAR-2 mid-2027"},{"id":"P0488","domain":"technology","parameter":"DRACO programme start funding","scope":"DRACO nuclear thermal","value":"10","low":"","high":"","unit":"million USD","year":"2020","method":"contract","source_url":"https://breakingdefense.com/2025/06/darpas-draco-nuclear-propulsion-project-roars-no-more/","locator":"article 2025-06-27","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"programme ended June 2025: costs no longer match benefits (DARPA); NASA FY2026 request zeroed it"},{"id":"P0489","domain":"technology","parameter":"DRACO end year","scope":"DRACO nuclear thermal","value":"2025","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://breakingdefense.com/2025/06/darpas-draco-nuclear-propulsion-project-roars-no-more/","locator":"article 2025-06-27","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"planned flight demo never flown"},{"id":"P0490","domain":"technology","parameter":"sail area","scope":"NASA ACS3 solar sail","value":"80","low":"","high":"","unit":"m2","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Composite_Solar_Sail_System","locator":"ACS3 section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"launched 2024-04-23 on Electron; bent boom, tumbling Oct 2024"},{"id":"P0491","domain":"technology","parameter":"sail area","scope":"JAXA IKAROS","value":"196","low":"","high":"","unit":"m2","year":"2010","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Composite_Solar_Sail_System","locator":"IKAROS section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"first interplanetary solar sail"},{"id":"P0492","domain":"technology","parameter":"sail area, cancelled design","scope":"NASA Solar Cruiser","value":"1672","low":"","high":"","unit":"m2","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Composite_Solar_Sail_System","locator":"Solar Cruiser section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"not advanced to Phase C, discontinued"},{"id":"P0493","domain":"technology","parameter":"cryogenic technologies to demonstrate","scope":"LOXSAT (Eta Space/NASA)","value":"11","low":"","high":"","unit":"technologies","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://cislunarspace.cn/en/space-news/2026/05/2026-05-14-nasa-loxsat-cryogenic-demo/","locator":"news item 2026-05-14 (search summary)","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"9-month LOX mission on Electron/Photon; NET 2026-07-17 then Q4 2026; launch not confirmed"},{"id":"P0494","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar landing outcome (1 upright, 0.5 landed off-nominal, 0 lost)","scope":"Chang'e 4 (CNSA, China)","value":"1","low":"","high":"","unit":"index","year":"2019","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_missions_to_the_Moon","locator":"lead","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. landed 2019-01-03 Von Karman/Aitken basin, far side; Yutu-2 deployed"},{"id":"P0495","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar landing outcome (1 upright, 0.5 landed off-nominal, 0 lost)","scope":"Beresheet (SpaceIL, Israel)","value":"0","low":"","high":"","unit":"index","year":"2019","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beresheet","locator":"infobox; landing attempt section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. crashed 2019-04-11 after IMU failure and engine shutdown; >500 km/h impact"},{"id":"P0496","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar landing outcome (1 upright, 0.5 landed off-nominal, 0 lost)","scope":"Chandrayaan-2 Vikram (ISRO, India)","value":"0","low":"","high":"","unit":"index","year":"2019","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_missions_to_the_Moon","locator":"21st-century landers table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. crash-landed 2019-09-06"},{"id":"P0497","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar landing outcome (1 upright, 0.5 landed off-nominal, 0 lost)","scope":"Chang'e 5 (CNSA, China)","value":"1","low":"","high":"","unit":"index","year":"2020","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chang%27e_5","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. landed 2020-12-01; sample return"},{"id":"P0498","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar landing outcome (1 upright, 0.5 landed off-nominal, 0 lost)","scope":"Hakuto-R Mission 1 (ispace, Japan)","value":"0","low":"","high":"","unit":"index","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hakuto-R_Mission_1","locator":"landing attempt","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. 2023-04-25; computer rejected radar altimeter, ran out of propellant ~5 km up"},{"id":"P0499","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar landing outcome (1 upright, 0.5 landed off-nominal, 0 lost)","scope":"Luna 25 (Roscosmos, Russia)","value":"0","low":"","high":"","unit":"index","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luna_25","locator":"failure section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. crashed 2023-08-19 after engine burned 127 s instead of 84 s in pre-descent orbit; never began powered descent"},{"id":"P0500","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar landing outcome (1 upright, 0.5 landed off-nominal, 0 lost)","scope":"Chandrayaan-3 (ISRO, India)","value":"1","low":"","high":"","unit":"index","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chandrayaan-3","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. landed 2023-08-23 at ~69.37 S"},{"id":"P0501","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar landing outcome (1 upright, 0.5 landed off-nominal, 0 lost)","scope":"SLIM (JAXA, Japan)","value":"0.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"index","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_Lander_for_Investigating_Moon","locator":"infobox; landing section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. landed 2024-01-19 within 100 m of target but on its nose after engine nozzle loss"},{"id":"P0502","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar landing outcome (1 upright, 0.5 landed off-nominal, 0 lost)","scope":"Peregrine Mission One (Astrobotic, US, CLPS)","value":"0","low":"","high":"","unit":"index","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Lunar_Payload_Services","locator":"CLPS missions table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. launched 2024-01-08; propellant leak, no landing attempt; counted as a lander loss, not a descent failure"},{"id":"P0503","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar landing outcome (1 upright, 0.5 landed off-nominal, 0 lost)","scope":"IM-1 Odysseus (Intuitive Machines, US, CLPS)","value":"0.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"index","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IM-1","locator":"infobox; landing section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. landed 2024-02-22 Malapert A; broke a leg, tipped ~30 deg; NASA counts payload ops"},{"id":"P0504","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar landing outcome (1 upright, 0.5 landed off-nominal, 0 lost)","scope":"Chang'e 6 (CNSA, China)","value":"1","low":"","high":"","unit":"index","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chang%27e_6","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. landed 2024-06-01 Apollo basin, far side"},{"id":"P0505","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar landing outcome (1 upright, 0.5 landed off-nominal, 0 lost)","scope":"Blue Ghost M1 (Firefly, US, CLPS)","value":"1","low":"","high":"","unit":"index","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Ghost_Mission_1","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. landed 2025-03-02 Mare Crisium; first fully successful commercial landing"},{"id":"P0506","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar landing outcome (1 upright, 0.5 landed off-nominal, 0 lost)","scope":"IM-2 Athena (Intuitive Machines, US, CLPS)","value":"0.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"index","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IM-2","locator":"infobox; landing section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. landed 2025-03-06 Mons Mouton on its side in a shadowed crater; ops ended <13 h after landing"},{"id":"P0507","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar landing outcome (1 upright, 0.5 landed off-nominal, 0 lost)","scope":"Hakuto-R Mission 2 Resilience (ispace, Japan)","value":"0","low":"","high":"","unit":"index","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hakuto-R_Mission_2","locator":"landing section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. impacted Mare Frigoris 2025-06-05; laser range finder anomaly"},{"id":"P0508","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar landing attempts reaching the Moon (incl. Luna 25, excl. Peregrine)","scope":"all landers 2019-2026 (to 2026-11-09)","value":"13","low":"","high":"","unit":"count","year":"2026","method":"derived","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_missions_to_the_Moon","locator":"rows above","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived from the 14 outcome rows above; Peregrine never reached the Moon. No lunar landing attempt in 2026 to 2026-11-09 found (Blue Moon MK1, IM-3, Griffin, Blue Ghost M2, Chang'e 7 all slipped to 2027)"},{"id":"P0509","domain":"technology","parameter":"fully successful (upright) lunar landings","scope":"all landers 2019-2026","value":"5","low":"","high":"","unit":"count","year":"2026","method":"derived","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_missions_to_the_Moon","locator":"rows above","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Chang'e 4, 5, 6; Chandrayaan-3; Blue Ghost M1. Chinese state landers 3 of 3; all others 2 of 10 upright, 3 of 10 tipped"},{"id":"P0510","domain":"technology","parameter":"commercial lunar lander upright success rate","scope":"commercial landers 2019-2026 (Beresheet, Hakuto x2, Peregrine, IM-1, IM-2, Blue Ghost)","value":"0.14","low":"","high":"","unit":"ratio","year":"2026","method":"derived","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Lunar_Payload_Services","locator":"rows above","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"1 upright of 7 commercial attempts (incl. Peregrine); 3 of 7 reached the surface intact in some attitude"},{"id":"P0511","domain":"technology","parameter":"launch (wet) mass","scope":"Beresheet lander","value":"585","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2019","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beresheet","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. dry 150 kg; budget ~US$90-100M"},{"id":"P0512","domain":"technology","parameter":"launch (wet) mass","scope":"Hakuto-R M1/M2 lander","value":"1000","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hakuto-R_Mission_2","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. dry mass 340 kg; same design both missions"},{"id":"P0513","domain":"technology","parameter":"launch mass","scope":"Luna 25","value":"1750","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luna_25","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. science payload 30 kg"},{"id":"P0514","domain":"technology","parameter":"lander mass (Vikram, incl. rover)","scope":"Chandrayaan-3","value":"1726","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chandrayaan-3","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. total stack 3,900 kg incl. 2,148 kg propulsion module"},{"id":"P0515","domain":"technology","parameter":"rover mass","scope":"Chandrayaan-3 Pragyan","value":"26","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chandrayaan-3","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing."},{"id":"P0516","domain":"technology","parameter":"rover distance traversed","scope":"Chandrayaan-3 Pragyan","value":"101.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"m","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chandrayaan-3","locator":"rover section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. one lunar day (~12 d of ops)"},{"id":"P0517","domain":"technology","parameter":"surface operating time","scope":"Chandrayaan-3 lander","value":"12","low":"","high":"","unit":"d","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chandrayaan-3","locator":"mission section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. designed for one lunar day (~14 d); did not wake after night"},{"id":"P0518","domain":"technology","parameter":"launch mass","scope":"SLIM","value":"590","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_Lander_for_Investigating_Moon","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. dry 120 kg"},{"id":"P0519","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar nights survived","scope":"SLIM","value":"3","low":"","high":"","unit":"count","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_Lander_for_Investigating_Moon","locator":"operations section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. not designed for night survival; silent late May 2024"},{"id":"P0520","domain":"technology","parameter":"launch mass","scope":"IM-1 Nova-C Odysseus","value":"1900","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IM-1","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing."},{"id":"P0521","domain":"technology","parameter":"surface operating time","scope":"IM-1 Odysseus","value":"7","low":"","high":"","unit":"d","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IM-1","locator":"surface operations","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. landed 2024-02-22, shut down 2024-02-29"},{"id":"P0522","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload mass delivered","scope":"Blue Ghost M1 (10 NASA payloads)","value":"94","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Ghost_Mission_1","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing."},{"id":"P0523","domain":"technology","parameter":"launch mass","scope":"Blue Ghost M1 lander","value":"1517","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Ghost_Mission_1","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. dry 469 kg"},{"id":"P0524","domain":"technology","parameter":"surface operating time","scope":"Blue Ghost M1","value":"14","low":"","high":"","unit":"d","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Ghost_Mission_1","locator":"infobox dates","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"2025-03-02 landing to 2025-03-16 last contact (~5 h after sunset)"},{"id":"P0525","domain":"technology","parameter":"launch mass","scope":"IM-2 Nova-C Athena","value":"2120","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IM-2","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing."},{"id":"P0526","domain":"technology","parameter":"landing miss distance","scope":"IM-2 Athena","value":"400","low":"","high":"","unit":"m","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/missions/artemis/clps/nasas-lunar-drill-technology-passes-tests-on-the-moon/","locator":"body text","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"NASA: touched down ~400 m from intended site at Mons Mouton"},{"id":"P0527","domain":"technology","parameter":"sample mass returned","scope":"Chang'e 5","value":"1.731","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2020","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chang%27e_5","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. core ~1 m deep"},{"id":"P0528","domain":"technology","parameter":"sample mass returned","scope":"Chang'e 6 (far side)","value":"1.9353","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chang%27e_6","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. first far-side samples"},{"id":"P0529","domain":"technology","parameter":"launch mass","scope":"Chang'e 6 stack","value":"8350","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chang%27e_6","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. lander projected 3,200 kg"},{"id":"P0530","domain":"technology","parameter":"launch mass","scope":"Chang'e 7 stack (orbiter, lander, rover, hopper)","value":"8200","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chang%27e_7","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing."},{"id":"P0531","domain":"technology","parameter":"launch date slip","scope":"Chang'e 7","value":"2027","low":"2026-08-23","high":"2027","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chang%27e_7","locator":"status","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. window 2026-08-23/24 'indefinitely delayed'; value = current plan (2027), low = original window"},{"id":"P0532","domain":"technology","parameter":"payload capacity to lunar surface","scope":"Blue Moon MK1","value":"3000","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Moon_(spacecraft)","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. fueled mass 21,350 kg; MK2 cargo 20,000 kg reusable / 30,000 kg one-way"},{"id":"P0533","domain":"technology","parameter":"first landing date (slip)","scope":"Blue Moon MK1 Pathfinder Endurance","value":"2027","low":"2020","high":"2027","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Lunar_Payload_Services","locator":"CLPS missions table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. projected 2020 (2017 statement) -> 2024 -> 2026 -> early 2027 (June 2026 report); no landing as of 2026-11-09"},{"id":"P0534","domain":"technology","parameter":"HLS contract value","scope":"Blue Moon MK2 (Artemis)","value":"3400000000.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD (nominal)","year":"2023","method":"contract","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Moon_(spacecraft)","locator":"HLS section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. selected May 2023"},{"id":"P0535","domain":"technology","parameter":"CLPS task order value","scope":"Blue Origin CS-7 VIPER delivery","value":"190000000.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD (nominal)","year":"2025","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/?p=916870","locator":"release","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"NASA 2025-09-19; delivery is an option exercised after MK1 first flight; landing late 2027"},{"id":"P0536","domain":"technology","parameter":"CLPS contract value","scope":"Peregrine M1 (Astrobotic)","value":"108000000.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD (nominal)","year":"2024","method":"contract","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Lunar_Payload_Services","locator":"CLPS table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. $79.5M initial"},{"id":"P0537","domain":"technology","parameter":"CLPS contract value","scope":"IM-1 (Intuitive Machines)","value":"118000000.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD (nominal)","year":"2024","method":"contract","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Lunar_Payload_Services","locator":"CLPS table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. $77M initial"},{"id":"P0538","domain":"technology","parameter":"CLPS contract value","scope":"Blue Ghost M1 (Firefly)","value":"93300000.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD (nominal)","year":"2024","method":"contract","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Lunar_Payload_Services","locator":"CLPS table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing."},{"id":"P0539","domain":"technology","parameter":"CLPS contract value","scope":"IM-2 (Intuitive Machines)","value":"47000000.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD (nominal)","year":"2024","method":"contract","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Lunar_Payload_Services","locator":"CLPS table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. approximate"},{"id":"P0540","domain":"technology","parameter":"CLPS contract value","scope":"Griffin M1 (Astrobotic)","value":"199500000.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD (nominal)","year":"2024","method":"contract","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Lunar_Payload_Services","locator":"CLPS table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. originally carried VIPER"},{"id":"P0541","domain":"technology","parameter":"CLPS contract value","scope":"IM-3 (Intuitive Machines)","value":"77500000.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD (nominal)","year":"2024","method":"contract","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Lunar_Payload_Services","locator":"CLPS table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. ~92 kg NASA payload"},{"id":"P0542","domain":"technology","parameter":"CLPS contract value","scope":"Blue Ghost M2 (Firefly)","value":"112000000.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD (nominal)","year":"2024","method":"contract","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Lunar_Payload_Services","locator":"CLPS table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing."},{"id":"P0543","domain":"technology","parameter":"planned vs actual/current launch date","scope":"Griffin M1 (Astrobotic)","value":"2027-01","low":"2024-11","high":"2027-01","unit":"date","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Lunar_Payload_Services","locator":"schedule history","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. value and high = actual or current, low = original plan; ~26 months slip"},{"id":"P0544","domain":"technology","parameter":"planned vs actual/current launch date","scope":"IM-2 (Intuitive Machines)","value":"2025-02","low":"2022-12","high":"2025-02","unit":"date","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Lunar_Payload_Services","locator":"schedule history","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. value and high = actual or current, low = original plan; ~26 months slip (launched)"},{"id":"P0545","domain":"technology","parameter":"planned vs actual/current launch date","scope":"IM-3 (Intuitive Machines)","value":"2027 (early)","low":"2024","high":"2027 (early)","unit":"date","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Lunar_Payload_Services","locator":"schedule history","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. value and high = actual or current, low = original plan; ~3 years slip"},{"id":"P0546","domain":"technology","parameter":"planned vs actual/current launch date","scope":"Blue Ghost M1 (Firefly)","value":"2025-01","low":"2023","high":"2025-01","unit":"date","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Lunar_Payload_Services","locator":"schedule history","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. value and high = actual or current, low = original plan; ~2 years slip (launched)"},{"id":"P0547","domain":"technology","parameter":"planned vs actual/current launch date","scope":"Blue Ghost M2 (Firefly)","value":"2027 (early)","low":"2026","high":"2027 (early)","unit":"date","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Lunar_Payload_Services","locator":"schedule history","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. value and high = actual or current, low = original plan; ~1 year slip"},{"id":"P0548","domain":"technology","parameter":"successful soft landings on Mars (all time)","scope":"Mars, 1971-2026","value":"10","low":"","high":"","unit":"count","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_landing","locator":"lead","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. Viking 1/2, Pathfinder, Spirit, Opportunity, Phoenix, Curiosity, InSight, Perseverance, Tianwen-1/Zhurong; Mars 3 landed but failed after ~110 s"},{"id":"P0549","domain":"technology","parameter":"rover mass","scope":"Perseverance (Mars 2020)","value":"1025","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://science.nasa.gov/mission/mars-2020-perseverance/rover-components/","locator":"tech specs","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"heaviest Mars landed rover; MMRTG ~110 W at launch, 45 kg"},{"id":"P0550","domain":"technology","parameter":"rover mass","scope":"Zhurong (Tianwen-1)","value":"240","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhurong_(rover)","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. landed 2021-05-14 (15 May China time)"},{"id":"P0551","domain":"technology","parameter":"rover distance driven","scope":"Zhurong","value":"1921","low":"","high":"","unit":"m","year":"2022","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhurong_(rover)","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. hibernated 2022-05-18, never woke (dust)"},{"id":"P0552","domain":"technology","parameter":"rover odometer","scope":"Perseverance","value":"45220","low":"","high":"","unit":"m","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://science.nasa.gov/mission/mars-2020-perseverance/","locator":"mission page","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2026-10-11; passes Opportunity record (28.06 mi)"},{"id":"P0553","domain":"technology","parameter":"share of drive distance on AutoNav","scope":"Perseverance, cumulative","value":"0.9","low":"0.9","high":"1","unit":"ratio","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://nextgov.com/emerging-tech/2026/10/nasas-self-driving-mars-rover-sets-world-mileage-record/416718","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'more than 90%'; secondary press (Nextgov 2026-10-20)"},{"id":"P0554","domain":"technology","parameter":"share of drive distance evaluated by AutoNav","scope":"Perseverance, first Mars year (17.7 km)","value":"0.88","low":"","high":"","unit":"ratio","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/scirobotics.adi3099","locator":"abstract","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Verma et al. 2023 Science Robotics; publisher page 403; prior max autonomous distance 2.4 km (Opportunity, 14 yr)"},{"id":"P0555","domain":"technology","parameter":"total O2 produced","scope":"MOXIE on Mars (16 runs 2021-2023)","value":"0.122","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/missions/mars-2020-perseverance/perseverance-rover/nasas-oxygen-generating-experiment-moxie-completes-mars-mission/","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"final run 2023-08-07 produced 9.8 g"},{"id":"P0556","domain":"technology","parameter":"peak O2 production rate","scope":"MOXIE","value":"0.012","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg/h","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/missions/mars-2020-perseverance/perseverance-rover/nasas-oxygen-generating-experiment-moxie-completes-mars-mission/","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"twice the 6 g/h goal; purity >=98%"},{"id":"P0557","domain":"technology","parameter":"O2 purity","scope":"MOXIE","value":"0.98","low":"","high":"","unit":"mass fraction","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/missions/mars-2020-perseverance/perseverance-rover/nasas-oxygen-generating-experiment-moxie-completes-mars-mission/","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"98% or better"},{"id":"P0558","domain":"technology","parameter":"nominal O2 production rate (requirement)","scope":"MOXIE","value":"0.006","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg/h","year":"2022","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9432831/","locator":"reference segment section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Hoffman et al. 2022 Sci. Adv. 8:eabp8636; 55 g/h CO2 intake; SOXE at 800 C; expected to meet requirement >60 cycles"},{"id":"P0559","domain":"technology","parameter":"CO2 intake rate (reference)","scope":"MOXIE","value":"0.055","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg/h","year":"2022","method":"measured","source_url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9432831/","locator":"reference segment section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"max reliable intake at annual density minimum, compressor 3500 rpm"},{"id":"P0560","domain":"technology","parameter":"electrical power draw","scope":"MOXIE","value":"300","low":"","high":"","unit":"W","year":"2022","method":"measured","source_url":"https://singularityhub.com/2022/09/04/nasa-says-it-can-now-reliably-produce-a-trees-worth-of-oxygen-on-mars","locator":"PI interview","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"PI Hecht: 'up to 300 watts to produce about 8 grams per hour'; not in the paper"},{"id":"P0561","domain":"technology","parameter":"electrochemical efficiency","scope":"MOXIE","value":"0.1","low":"","high":"","unit":"ratio","year":"2022","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://singularityhub.com/2022/09/04/nasa-says-it-can-now-reliably-produce-a-trees-worth-of-oxygen-on-mars","locator":"PI interview","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"'not much more than 10 percent'; full-scale target ~90%"},{"id":"P0562","domain":"technology","parameter":"specific energy of O2 production","scope":"MOXIE","value":"37.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"kWh/kg","year":"2022","method":"derived","source_url":"https://singularityhub.com/2022/09/04/nasa-says-it-can-now-reliably-produce-a-trees-worth-of-oxygen-on-mars","locator":"300 W / 8 g/h","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived from the two MOXIE rows above; demo-scale, not representative of a plant"},{"id":"P0563","domain":"technology","parameter":"O2 production rate, scaled MOXIE for crewed Mars ascent","scope":"scaled SOXE plant (Mars)","value":"2.5","low":"2","high":"3","unit":"kg/h","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9432831/","locator":"introduction","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'scaled up several hundred times'; enough for a MAV over one 26-month cycle; PI says ~10 kW reactor-powered"},{"id":"P0564","domain":"technology","parameter":"O2 mass in a 6-crew Mars ascent vehicle","scope":"Mars ascent vehicle (MAV)","value":"31000","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9432831/","locator":"introduction","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"of ~50 t MAV; ~9 t methane; 12-13 t in LEO per t landed on Mars"},{"id":"P0565","domain":"technology","parameter":"regolith processed per batch","scope":"NASA KSC / Lunar Resources LR-1 molten regolith electrolysis","value":"25","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20260006167","locator":"abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"ICES-2026-300; late-2024 test; ground, vacuum"},{"id":"P0566","domain":"technology","parameter":"O2 production rate","scope":"molten regolith electrolysis, LR-1 reactor (ground, vacuum)","value":"0.07","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg/h","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20260006167","locator":"abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"average; electrolysis sustained 9 h; no energy figure in abstract"},{"id":"P0567","domain":"technology","parameter":"sustained electrolysis duration","scope":"molten regolith electrolysis, LR-1 reactor","value":"9","low":"","high":"","unit":"h","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20260006167","locator":"abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0568","domain":"technology","parameter":"O2 yield per thermal energy, program goal","scope":"Sierra Space COPR carbothermal reactor","value":"3.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"g/kWh(th)","year":"2024","method":"target","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20250004151/downloads/Carbothermal_Paper_Final.pdf","locator":"sec. III","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Haggerty et al. ICES-2025-200 (Sierra Space + NASA)"},{"id":"P0569","domain":"technology","parameter":"O2 yield per thermal energy, measured","scope":"Sierra Space COPR carbothermal reactor (laser heated, initial tests)","value":"20","low":"20","high":"","unit":"g/kWh(th)","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20250004151/downloads/Carbothermal_Paper_Final.pdf","locator":"sec. II","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"'over 20 grams of oxygen ... for every kilowatt hour of thermal energy'; TVAC summer 2024 at NASA JSC, TRL 6"},{"id":"P0570","domain":"technology","parameter":"thermal energy per kg O2","scope":"Sierra Space COPR carbothermal reactor","value":"50","low":"","high":"50","unit":"kWh(th)/kg","year":"2024","method":"derived","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20250004151/downloads/Carbothermal_Paper_Final.pdf","locator":"1000/20","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"upper bound from >20 g/kWh row"},{"id":"P0571","domain":"technology","parameter":"regolith melt temperature","scope":"Sierra Space COPR carbothermal reactor","value":"2056","low":"","high":"","unit":"K","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20250004151/downloads/Carbothermal_Paper_Final.pdf","locator":"sec. III","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"1782.9 C pyrometer (emissivity 0.8)"},{"id":"P0572","domain":"technology","parameter":"O2 yield per energy delivered to reactor","scope":"carbothermal field demo 2010 (Hawaii)","value":"1.45","low":"","high":"","unit":"g/kWh","year":"2010","method":"measured","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.05823","locator":"sec. 4 (carbothermal)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Azami et al. 2024 review (arXiv 2408.05823) citing primary tests; 2010"},{"id":"P0573","domain":"technology","parameter":"O2 yield per energy delivered to reactor","scope":"NASA CaRD solar carbothermal, ambient","value":"13.42","low":"","high":"","unit":"g/kWh","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.05823","locator":"sec. 4 (carbothermal)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Azami et al. 2024 review (arXiv 2408.05823) citing primary tests; 2023"},{"id":"P0574","domain":"technology","parameter":"O2 yield per energy delivered to reactor","scope":"NASA CaRD solar carbothermal, vacuum (best of 3)","value":"15.79","low":"10.77","high":"","unit":"g/kWh","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.05823","locator":"sec. 4 (carbothermal)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Azami et al. 2024 review (arXiv 2408.05823) citing primary tests; 2023; other vacuum runs 11.53 and 10.77"},{"id":"P0575","domain":"technology","parameter":"planned vs actual surface operating time","scope":"PRIME-1 (TRIDENT drill + MSOLO) on IM-2","value":"10","low":"","high":"","unit":"h","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/missions/artemis/clps/nasas-lunar-drill-technology-passes-tests-on-the-moon/","locator":"quote J. Kleinhenz","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"planned ~10 days; ~10 h achieved; drill (1 m) and MSOLO worked; only anthropogenic gases detected; no ice sampled"},{"id":"P0576","domain":"technology","parameter":"icy simulant mass per run","scope":"DLR LUWEX thermal water extraction (vacuum chamber)","value":"13","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/215814/1/1-s2.0-S0273117726000669-main.pdf","locator":"abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Kiewiet et al. 2026 Adv. Space Res.; 5 wt% ice"},{"id":"P0577","domain":"technology","parameter":"peak water recovery fraction","scope":"DLR LUWEX","value":"0.73","low":"","high":"","unit":"ratio","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/215814/1/1-s2.0-S0273117726000669-main.pdf","locator":"abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0578","domain":"technology","parameter":"water recovered per energy","scope":"DLR LUWEX, icy regolith simulant","value":"22.88","low":"","high":"66.33","unit":"g/kWh","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/215814/1/1-s2.0-S0273117726000669-main.pdf","locator":"abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"66.33 g/kWh with icy glass beads; includes thermal maintenance in PSR-like conditions"},{"id":"P0579","domain":"technology","parameter":"energy per kg water recovered","scope":"DLR LUWEX, icy regolith simulant","value":"43.7","low":"15.1","high":"","unit":"kWh/kg","year":"2026","method":"derived","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/215814/1/1-s2.0-S0273117726000669-main.pdf","locator":"1000/22.88","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"low = glass beads (1000/66.33)"},{"id":"P0580","domain":"technology","parameter":"water recovery rate","scope":"DLR LUWEX","value":"0.00776","low":"0.00206","high":"0.00776","unit":"kg/h","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/215814/1/1-s2.0-S0273117726000669-main.pdf","locator":"abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"0.05-0.19 kg/day"},{"id":"P0581","domain":"technology","parameter":"NASA Tipping Point value","scope":"Blue Origin Blue Alchemist (regolith to solar cells, O2 by-product)","value":"34700000.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD (nominal)","year":"2023","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.space.com/blue-origin-solar-cells-moon-dirt-simulant","locator":"body","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"autonomous demo in simulated lunar environment targeted 2026 after Sept 2025 CDR; no result found by 2026-11-09"},{"id":"P0582","domain":"technology","parameter":"contract value","scope":"ICON Olympus lunar construction system (NASA MMPACT, SBIR III)","value":"57200000.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD (nominal)","year":"2022","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/?p=285043","locator":"release","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"runs through 2028; no lunar flight demo date on page"},{"id":"P0583","domain":"technology","parameter":"compressive strength","scope":"ICON/NASA KSC Laser VMX sintered highland regolith simulant (vacuum)","value":"344.7","low":"251.66","high":"","unit":"MPa","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.05823","locator":"sec. 5 (laser)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"low = after 1 yr lunar TVAC cycling; flexural 37.92 MPa; review citing ICON"},{"id":"P0584","domain":"technology","parameter":"compressive strength","scope":"laser-melted EAC-1A simulant tiles (3 kW, 5 mm/min)","value":"93.97","low":"56.19","high":"216.29","unit":"MPa","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.05823","locator":"sec. 5 (laser)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"SD 55.88 MPa; review citing primary"},{"id":"P0585","domain":"technology","parameter":"compressive strength","scope":"RegoLight solar-sintered simulant (ESA project)","value":"2.49","low":"","high":"","unit":"MPa","year":"2020","method":"measured","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.05823","locator":"sec. 5 (solar)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Young modulus 0.21 GPa; ambient atmosphere"},{"id":"P0586","domain":"technology","parameter":"compressive strength","scope":"Outward Technologies solar-fused CSM-LHT-1 simulant","value":"25","low":"","high":"","unit":"MPa","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.05823","locator":"sec. 5 (solar)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Young modulus 10.3 GPa; flexural 3.5 MPa; 95% density"},{"id":"P0587","domain":"technology","parameter":"compressive strength","scope":"L-PBF NU-LHT-2M highland simulant (Caprio et al.)","value":"31.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"MPa","year":"2020","method":"measured","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.05823","locator":"sec. 5 (laser)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0588","domain":"technology","parameter":"compressive strength","scope":"SLM-printed simulant (Goulas et al.)","value":"4.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"MPa","year":"2017","method":"measured","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.05823","locator":"sec. 5 (laser)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"porosity 44-49%"},{"id":"P0589","domain":"technology","parameter":"compressive strength","scope":"microwave-sintered KLS-1 simulant at 1120 C","value":"37.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"MPa","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ar5iv.labs.arxiv.org/html/2308.14331","locator":"abstract","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"from search summary; +-4.8 MPa"},{"id":"P0590","domain":"technology","parameter":"required compressive strength for lunar structures","scope":"lunar construction (1/6 g)","value":"5.4","low":"4.2","high":"6.7","unit":"MPa","year":"2024","method":"derived","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.05823","locator":"sec. 5 intro","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"review: 1/6 of terrestrial 25-40 MPa (Montes et al.); arithmetic mine"},{"id":"P0591","domain":"technology","parameter":"printing rate","scope":"D-Shape regolith-simulant printer (ESA/Foster+Partners study)","value":"2","low":"","high":"3.5","unit":"m/h","year":"2013","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.esa.int/Enabling_Support/Space_Engineering_Technology/Building_a_lunar_base_with_3D_printing","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Monolite founder statement; dimension of 'm per hour' unspecified; high = next-gen target; 1.5 t demo block"},{"id":"P0592","domain":"technology","parameter":"demo block mass","scope":"D-Shape regolith-simulant block","value":"1500","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2013","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.esa.int/Enabling_Support/Space_Engineering_Technology/Building_a_lunar_base_with_3D_printing","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0593","domain":"technology","parameter":"brick printing test on the Moon","scope":"Chang'e 8 (ILRS precursor)","value":"2028","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2024","method":"target","source_url":"https://globalconstructionreview.com/china-sets-out-plans-for-network-of-lunar-research-stations-by-2050","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"tests printing bricks from lunar regolith"},{"id":"P0594","domain":"technology","parameter":"steady-state thermal power","scope":"KRUSTY fission test (Kilopower, NNSS)","value":"4000","low":"4000","high":"","unit":"W(th)","year":"2018","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20205008482","locator":"Table III","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"McClure et al. 2020 Nucl. Tech. 206; >4 kWt at 800 C; 28 h full-power test ended 2018-03-21"},{"id":"P0595","domain":"technology","parameter":"Stirling converter efficiency","scope":"KRUSTY","value":"0.3","low":"0.3","high":"","unit":"ratio","year":"2018","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20205008482","locator":"Table III","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":">30% vs >25% goal"},{"id":"P0596","domain":"technology","parameter":"full-power test duration","scope":"KRUSTY","value":"28","low":"","high":"","unit":"h","year":"2018","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20205008482","locator":"sec. II.E.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0597","domain":"technology","parameter":"electric power turn-down ratio","scope":"KRUSTY","value":"16","low":"16","high":"","unit":"ratio","year":"2018","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20205008482","locator":"Table III","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":">16:1 vs >2:1 goal"},{"id":"P0598","domain":"technology","parameter":"design electrical power class","scope":"Kilopower family","value":"1000","low":"1000","high":"10000","unit":"W(e)","year":"2018","method":"target","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20205008482","locator":"abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"KRUSTY = 1 kWe-class; extensible to 10 kWe; test used 2 x 70 We Stirlings + 6 simulators"},{"id":"P0599","domain":"technology","parameter":"reactor electrical power requirement","scope":"NASA Fission Surface Power Phase 1 (2022)","value":"40000","low":"","high":"","unit":"W(e)","year":"2022","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.powermag.com/nasa-picks-three-nuclear-power-concepts-for-demonstration-on-the-moon/","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":">=10 yr continuous; three ~$5M 12-month awards (Lockheed/BWXT, Westinghouse/Aerojet, IX)"},{"id":"P0600","domain":"technology","parameter":"Phase 1 award value per team","scope":"NASA Fission Surface Power 2022","value":"5000000.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD (nominal)","year":"2022","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.powermag.com/nasa-picks-three-nuclear-power-concepts-for-demonstration-on-the-moon/","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0601","domain":"technology","parameter":"reactor electrical power requirement","scope":"NASA FSP after 2025 directive","value":"100000","low":"100000","high":"","unit":"W(e)","year":"2025","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/?p=901246","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'at least 100 kilowatts'; closed Brayton; on Moon by Q1 FY2030"},{"id":"P0602","domain":"technology","parameter":"reactor mass cap","scope":"NASA FSP after 2025 directive","value":"15000","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2025","method":"target","source_url":"https://thespacereview.com/article/5065/1","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'15 tons'; Space Review"},{"id":"P0603","domain":"technology","parameter":"target date reactor on Moon","scope":"NASA FSP after 2025 directive","value":"2030","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2025","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/?p=901246","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Q1 FY2030 = Oct-Dec 2029; FSP placed in 2033-36 phase of the 2026 Moon-base plan (see Moon base rows)"},{"id":"P0604","domain":"technology","parameter":"program cost scenarios","scope":"lunar fission reactor (INL report)","value":"1000000000.0","low":"1000000000.0","high":"3000000000.0","unit":"USD (nominal)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://thespacereview.com/article/5065/1","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0605","domain":"technology","parameter":"mid-power reactor class","scope":"US OSTP NSTM-3 space nuclear initiative","value":"20000","low":"","high":"","unit":"W(e)","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.ans.org/news/2026-04-16/article-7943/ostp-memo-guides-space-nuclear-plan/","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"lunar FSP variant 'ready for launch by 2030'; low 1 kWe, high 100 kWe 'in the 2030s'"},{"id":"P0606","domain":"technology","parameter":"mid-power reactor required life on lunar surface","scope":"US OSTP NSTM-3","value":"5","low":"","high":"","unit":"yr","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.powermag.com/white-house-launches-space-nuclear-initiative-sets-timeline-for-lunar-reactors/","locator":"body","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"3 yr in orbit; from search summary"},{"id":"P0607","domain":"technology","parameter":"space reactors to be built (assessment)","scope":"US DOE industrial base","value":"4","low":"","high":"","unit":"count","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.ans.org/news/2026-04-16/article-7943/ostp-memo-guides-space-nuclear-plan/","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'up to four space reactors within five years'"},{"id":"P0608","domain":"technology","parameter":"reactor electrical power","scope":"NASA SR-1 Freedom NEP demo","value":"20000","low":"","high":"","unit":"W(e)","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.ans.org/news/2026-03-25/article-7879/nasa-announces-plan-for-space-nuclear-propulsion-by-2028/","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"launch target Dec 2028 to Mars; HALEU; thrusters up to 48 kW; Lunar Reactor-1 planned 2030"},{"id":"P0609","domain":"technology","parameter":"mast height","scope":"NASA Lunar VSAT (Astrobotic award)","value":"10","low":"","high":"10","unit":"m","year":"2021","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.highergov.com/contract-opportunity/lunar-vertical-solar-80hqtr20noa01-20gcd-c1-award-80larc21ca007-astrobotic-technology-inc-da3e1","locator":"award notice","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"10 kW array; TRL 6 goal; deployment circa 2028"},{"id":"P0610","domain":"technology","parameter":"array power","scope":"NASA Lunar VSAT","value":"10000","low":"","high":"","unit":"W(e)","year":"2021","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.highergov.com/contract-opportunity/lunar-vertical-solar-80hqtr20noa01-20gcd-c1-award-80larc21ca007-astrobotic-technology-inc-da3e1","locator":"award notice","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0611","domain":"technology","parameter":"award value","scope":"NASA Lunar VSAT, Astrobotic","value":"7762882","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD (nominal)","year":"2021","method":"contract","source_url":"https://www.highergov.com/contract-opportunity/lunar-vertical-solar-80hqtr20noa01-20gcd-c1-award-80larc21ca007-astrobotic-technology-inc-da3e1","locator":"award notice","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Honeybee $7.71M and Lockheed Martin $5.91M awards from search snippets only"},{"id":"P0612","domain":"technology","parameter":"array power","scope":"Astrobotic VSAT-XL","value":"50000","low":"","high":"","unit":"W(e)","year":"2024","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.astrobotic.com/astrobotic-awarded-lunar-power-study-with-vsat-xl/","locator":"release","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"34 m tall, 12.5 m wide; SBIR ~$150k"},{"id":"P0613","domain":"technology","parameter":"burdened specific energy","scope":"regenerative fuel cell for crewed lunar outpost (NASA trade)","value":"510","low":"","high":"","unit":"Wh/kg","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20190001140","locator":"slide 'Crewed Surface Outpost Trade Study Results'","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"PEM RFC; batteries win below ~10-18 h storage"},{"id":"P0614","domain":"technology","parameter":"cost to lunar surface used in trade","scope":"NASA lunar energy storage trade","value":"1650000.0","low":"1500000.0","high":"1800000.0","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2019","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20190001140","locator":"trade slide","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"currency year not stated"},{"id":"P0615","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar day-night cycle length","scope":"Moon","value":"682","low":"655.7","high":"708.7","unit":"h","year":"2019","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20190001140","locator":"background slide","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"sidereal to synodic month"},{"id":"P0616","domain":"technology","parameter":"electrical power at beginning of mission","scope":"MMRTG","value":"110","low":"","high":"","unit":"W(e)","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://science.nasa.gov/mission/mars-2020-perseverance/rover-components/","locator":"tech specs","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"declines a few percent per year"},{"id":"P0617","domain":"technology","parameter":"Pu-238 production goal","scope":"US DOE/ORNL","value":"1.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg/yr","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.ornl.gov/news/pu-238-shipment-quantity-opens-tap-space-missions","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'1.5 kilograms annually by 2026'; earlier target 2025; no confirmation it was reached"},{"id":"P0618","domain":"technology","parameter":"Pu-238 shipment","scope":"ORNL to LANL","value":"0.55","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.ornl.gov/news/pu-238-shipment-quantity-opens-tap-space-missions","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"June 2023; 50 g first batch after 2015 restart"},{"id":"P0619","domain":"technology","parameter":"pellet throughput after automation","scope":"ORNL Pu-238 line","value":"275","low":"80","high":"","unit":"pellets/week","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.energy.gov/node/3987879","locator":"body","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"up from 80/week"},{"id":"P0620","domain":"technology","parameter":"ISS water recovery","scope":"ISS ECLSS with Brine Processor Assembly","value":"0.98","low":"0.93","high":"","unit":"ratio","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/missions/station/iss-research/nasa-achieves-water-recovery-milestone-on-international-space-station/","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"93-94% before BPA"},{"id":"P0621","domain":"technology","parameter":"max O2 recovery from CO2, Sabatier with methane venting","scope":"ISS-type ECLSS","value":"0.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"ratio","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20240004053/downloads/ICES-2024-156-Final.pdf","locator":"sec. I","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"stoichiometric limit; Chen ICES-2024-156"},{"id":"P0622","domain":"technology","parameter":"O2 recovery, Sabatier + CVD methane pyrolysis (integrated, closed loop)","scope":"NASA lab simulation","value":"0.95","low":"0.95","high":"","unit":"ratio","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20240004053/downloads/ICES-2024-156-Final.pdf","locator":"abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"open loop only 40.7-43.1% system recovery"},{"id":"P0623","domain":"technology","parameter":"O2 recovery target for exploration ECLSS","scope":"NASA","value":"0.825","low":"0.75","high":"0.9","unit":"ratio","year":"2017","method":"target","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20170008967/downloads/20170008967.pdf","locator":"abstract","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"ICES 2017 paper per search summary"},{"id":"P0624","domain":"technology","parameter":"mass closure","scope":"Lunar Palace 365 (Beihang, 4 crew)","value":"0.982","low":"","high":"","unit":"ratio","year":"2018","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ev.buaa.edu.cn/info/1022/3019.htm","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"370 days, May 2017-May 2018"},{"id":"P0625","domain":"technology","parameter":"mission duration","scope":"Lunar Palace 365","value":"370","low":"","high":"","unit":"d","year":"2018","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ev.buaa.edu.cn/info/1022/3019.htm","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0626","domain":"technology","parameter":"mass closure","scope":"Lunar Palace 1, 2014 run (3 crew)","value":"0.97","low":"","high":"","unit":"ratio","year":"2014","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ev.buaa.edu.cn/info/1022/3019.htm","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"105 days"},{"id":"P0627","domain":"technology","parameter":"water closure","scope":"BIOS-3 (Krasnoyarsk), 180-day run, 3 crew","value":"0.95","low":"","high":"","unit":"ratio","year":"1973","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ksc.krasn.ru/en/news/osnovoy_lunnoy_bazy_dolzhna_stat_zamknutaya_sistema_zhizneobespecheniya_novogo_tipa/","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":"1972-12-24 to 1973-06-22; O2/CO2 fully closed; Salisbury 1997 gives 80-85% for 1968 runs"},{"id":"P0628","domain":"technology","parameter":"plant food share of diet","scope":"BIOS-3 180-day run","value":"0.6","low":"0.5","high":"0.7","unit":"ratio","year":"1973","method":"measured","source_url":"https://ksc.krasn.ru/en/news/osnovoy_lunnoy_bazy_dolzhna_stat_zamknutaya_sistema_zhizneobespecheniya_novogo_tipa/","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"self-assessment","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0629","domain":"technology","parameter":"assembled mass (design)","scope":"Lunar Gateway","value":"63000","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_Gateway","locator":"infobox","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. paused 'in its current form' March 2026"},{"id":"P0630","domain":"technology","parameter":"HALO spend vs contract","scope":"Lunar Gateway HALO (Northrop)","value":"1900000000.0","low":"1300000000.0","high":"","unit":"USD (nominal)","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_Gateway","locator":"HALO section","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wikipedia (secondary); re-check against agency/company primary before citing. low = contract value"},{"id":"P0631","domain":"technology","parameter":"Moon base phase 1 mass to surface","scope":"NASA Moon base plan 2026-2028","value":"4000","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.ans.org/news/2026-03-25/article-7879/nasa-announces-plan-for-space-nuclear-propulsion-by-2028/","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"~24 launches, ~$10B, one crewed mission; NASA itself calls it 'very challenging'"},{"id":"P0632","domain":"technology","parameter":"Moon base phase 2 mass to surface","scope":"NASA Moon base plan 2029-2032","value":"60000","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.ans.org/news/2026-03-25/article-7879/nasa-announces-plan-for-space-nuclear-propulsion-by-2028/","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"~27 launches, ~$10B, two crewed missions/yr, RTG power hundreds of W"},{"id":"P0633","domain":"technology","parameter":"Moon base phase 3 mass to surface","scope":"NASA Moon base plan 2033-2036","value":"150000","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.ans.org/news/2026-03-25/article-7879/nasa-announces-plan-for-space-nuclear-propulsion-by-2028/","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"~29 launches, >$10B, 4-crew 28-day missions, fission surface power"},{"id":"P0634","domain":"technology","parameter":"crewed lunar flyby launch","scope":"Artemis II","value":"2026-04-01","low":"2026-04-01","high":"2026-04-01","unit":"date","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.foxweather.com/earth-space/nasa-announces-artemis-ii-mission-phases-plans-future-artemis-program-launches","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"flew 2026-04-01 to ~04-10/11; originally planned 2024 (not re-checked here)"},{"id":"P0635","domain":"technology","parameter":"first crewed landing target","scope":"Artemis IV (after 2026 restructure)","value":"2028","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.foxweather.com/earth-space/nasa-announces-artemis-ii-mission-phases-plans-future-artemis-program-launches","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Artemis III became LEO lander test mid-2027; Artemis V second landing late 2028"},{"id":"P0636","domain":"technology","parameter":"basic station target","scope":"China/Russia ILRS (south pole)","value":"2035","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2024","method":"target","source_url":"https://globalconstructionreview.com/china-sets-out-plans-for-network-of-lunar-research-stations-by-2050","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"network to equator and far side by 2050; Chang'e 7 (planned 2026, now 2027) and Chang'e 8 (2028) precursors"},{"id":"P0637","domain":"technology","parameter":"extended network target","scope":"China/Russia ILRS","value":"2050","low":"","high":"","unit":"year","year":"2024","method":"target","source_url":"https://globalconstructionreview.com/china-sets-out-plans-for-network-of-lunar-research-stations-by-2050","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0638","domain":"technology","parameter":"regolith excavated in 5-day autonomy test","scope":"NASA IPEx (ISRU Pilot Excavator), TRL 5, KSC Swamp Works","value":"10000","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://aerospaceamerica.aiaa.org/year-in-review/tests-and-technology-development-push-in-situ-resource-utilization-forward/","locator":"body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"334 excavation cycles, ~58 km driven, 35 autonomous dockings, Aug 2024; ground test"},{"id":"P0639","domain":"technology","parameter":"excavation rate","scope":"NASA IPEx TRL 5 test","value":"2000","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg/d","year":"2024","method":"derived","source_url":"https://aerospaceamerica.aiaa.org/year-in-review/tests-and-technology-development-push-in-situ-resource-utilization-forward/","locator":"10,000 kg / 5 d","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":""},{"id":"P0640","domain":"technology","parameter":"excavator mass","scope":"NASA RASSOR 2.0","value":"66","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2016","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20210011366","locator":"abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"0.38 kg vehicle mass per kg/h of excavation rate; TRL 4 lab test"},{"id":"P0641","domain":"technology","parameter":"excavation capacity","scope":"NASA RASSOR 2.0","value":"2700","low":"2700","high":"","unit":"kg/d","year":"2016","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20210011366","locator":"abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'minimum of 2.7 metric tons ... per day'"},{"id":"P0642","domain":"technology","parameter":"excavation power intensity","scope":"NASA RASSOR 2.0","value":"4","low":"","high":"","unit":"W per (kg/h)","year":"2016","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20210011366","locator":"abstract","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0643","domain":"technology","parameter":"nominal haul","scope":"NASA RASSOR 1 mission plan","value":"700","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg/d","year":"2015","method":"derived","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20150022134","locator":"fact sheet","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"35 trips x 20 kg per 24 h (search summary)"},{"id":"P0644","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of supply, platinum","scope":"platinum, world","value":"0.29","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened"},{"id":"P0645","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, platinum","scope":"platinum, world","value":"-0.47","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened"},{"id":"P0646","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of supply, palladium","scope":"palladium, world","value":"0.28","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened"},{"id":"P0647","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, palladium","scope":"palladium, world","value":"-0.25","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened"},{"id":"P0648","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of supply, rhodium","scope":"rhodium, world","value":"0.04","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened"},{"id":"P0649","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, rhodium","scope":"rhodium, world","value":"-0.09","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened"},{"id":"P0650","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of supply, iridium","scope":"iridium, world","value":"0.09","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.88","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened"},{"id":"P0651","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, iridium","scope":"iridium, world","value":"-0.24","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.88","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened"},{"id":"P0652","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of supply, ruthenium","scope":"ruthenium, world","value":"0.11","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened"},{"id":"P0653","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, ruthenium","scope":"ruthenium, world","value":"-0.27","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened"},{"id":"P0654","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of supply, gold","scope":"gold, world","value":"0.04","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.88","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened"},{"id":"P0655","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, gold","scope":"gold, world","value":"-0.19","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.88","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened"},{"id":"P0656","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of supply, helium","scope":"helium, world","value":"0.58","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.88","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened"},{"id":"P0657","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, helium","scope":"helium, world","value":"-0.23","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.88","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened"},{"id":"P0658","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of supply, neodymium","scope":"neodymium, world","value":"0.18","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened; PES based on refined production"},{"id":"P0659","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, neodymium","scope":"neodymium, world","value":"-0.07","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened; PES based on refined production"},{"id":"P0660","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of supply, dysprosium","scope":"dysprosium, world","value":"0.13","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened; PES based on refined production"},{"id":"P0661","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, dysprosium","scope":"dysprosium, world","value":"-0.11","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened; PES based on refined production"},{"id":"P0662","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of supply, cobalt","scope":"cobalt, world","value":"0.22","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.88","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened; refined-cobalt PES = mined PES x (refined/mined copper PES); PED differs from P0126 (-0.45, Shojaeddini et al. 2024 2SLS post-2013 break): different specification; PES vs P0124 0.32 (Boer et al. SVAR)"},{"id":"P0663","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, cobalt","scope":"cobalt, world","value":"-0.17","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.88","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened; refined-cobalt PES = mined PES x (refined/mined copper PES); PED differs from P0126 (-0.45, Shojaeddini et al. 2024 2SLS post-2013 break): different specification; PES vs P0124 0.32 (Boer et al. SVAR)"},{"id":"P0664","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of supply, nickel, mined","scope":"nickel, mined, world","value":"0.31","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened; PED from static panel framework; PED equals P0135 (-0.09, Shojaeddini et al. 2024)"},{"id":"P0665","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, nickel, mined","scope":"nickel, mined, world","value":"-0.09","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened; PED from static panel framework; PED equals P0135 (-0.09, Shojaeddini et al. 2024)"},{"id":"P0666","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of supply, nickel, primary refined","scope":"nickel, primary refined, world","value":"0.43","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened; refined PES = mined PES x (refined/mined copper PES)"},{"id":"P0667","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, nickel, primary refined","scope":"nickel, primary refined, world","value":"-0.09","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2025/1047/ofr20251047.pdf","locator":"USGS OFR 2025-1047 ver. 2.0, App. 3, Table 3.2, p.89","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Shojaeddini et al. (2025) Mineral Economics 38:985-996 (doi 10.1007/s13563-025-00537-3) as tabulated by USGS; short run = 1 year; paper uses FE panel, 2S-DOLS and ARDL (USGS abstract page); per-commodity specification and data period not in table; primary paper paywalled, not opened; refined PES = mined PES x (refined/mined copper PES)"},{"id":"P0668","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of supply, gold (literature average)","scope":"gold, various","value":"-0.355","low":"-0.522","high":"-0.140","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"1999","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 1, PDF p.7","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=11 estimates from 3 studies 1983-1999; median -0.422; negative short-run gold supply response (backward-bending)"},{"id":"P0669","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run price elasticity of supply, gold (literature average)","scope":"gold, various","value":"0.617","low":"0.090","high":"1.049","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"1999","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 1, PDF p.7","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=8 from 3 studies 1983-1999; median 0.738"},{"id":"P0670","domain":"economics","parameter":"static price elasticity of demand, gold (literature average)","scope":"gold, various","value":"-0.413","low":"-2.500","high":"2.500","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2002","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3, PDF p.15","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=9 from 2 studies 1986-2002; median -0.600; SD 1.520"},{"id":"P0671","domain":"economics","parameter":"static income elasticity of demand, gold (literature)","scope":"gold, various","value":"1.042","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2002","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3, PDF p.15","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; single estimate"},{"id":"P0672","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of supply, cobalt (literature average)","scope":"cobalt, various","value":"0.230","low":"0.210","high":"0.250","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"1985","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 1, PDF p.6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=2, studies 1980-1985"},{"id":"P0673","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run price elasticity of supply, cobalt (literature average)","scope":"cobalt, various","value":"0.395","low":"0.350","high":"0.440","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"1985","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 1, PDF p.6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=3, studies 1980-1985"},{"id":"P0674","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, cobalt (literature average)","scope":"cobalt, various","value":"-0.165","low":"-1.375","high":"-0.012","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"1984","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3, PDF p.14","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=26 from 5 studies 1971-1984; median -0.070"},{"id":"P0675","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run price elasticity of demand, cobalt (literature average)","scope":"cobalt, various","value":"-1.734","low":"-21.810","high":"0.134","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"1984","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3, PDF p.14","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=24; median -0.542 (mean driven by outliers; Dahl attributes high values to US catalyst demand 1967-1975)"},{"id":"P0676","domain":"economics","parameter":"static income elasticity of demand, cobalt (literature average)","scope":"cobalt, various","value":"1.598","low":"0.280","high":"15.697","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"1984","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3, PDF p.14","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=30; median 1.040"},{"id":"P0677","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of supply, nickel (literature average)","scope":"nickel, various","value":"0.718","low":"0.133","high":"1.280","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"1990","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 1, PDF p.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=6 from 3 studies 1975-1990; median 0.750; compare P0133 0.71 (Boer et al.)"},{"id":"P0678","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run price elasticity of supply, nickel (literature average)","scope":"nickel, various","value":"2.922","low":"1.200","high":"5.500","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"1990","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 1, PDF p.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=6; median 2.015"},{"id":"P0679","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, nickel (literature average)","scope":"nickel, various","value":"-0.032","low":"-0.712","high":"0.682","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2020","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3, PDF p.16","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=58 from 7 studies 1996-2020; median -0.030"},{"id":"P0680","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run price elasticity of demand, nickel (literature average)","scope":"nickel, various","value":"-0.054","low":"-2.950","high":"11.690","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2020","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3, PDF p.16","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=79; median -0.105"},{"id":"P0681","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run income elasticity of demand, nickel (literature average)","scope":"nickel, various","value":"1.092","low":"-3.536","high":"16.198","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2020","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3, PDF p.16","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=98; median 0.666"},{"id":"P0682","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run income elasticity of demand, nickel (literature average)","scope":"nickel, various","value":"1.863","low":"-10.522","high":"31.241","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2020","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3, PDF p.16","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=69; median 1.079"},{"id":"P0683","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, palladium (literature)","scope":"palladium, various","value":"-0.200","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"1974","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3, PDF p.16","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; single 1974 estimate (Burrows 1974 via Fally and Sayre 2018); predates autocatalysts"},{"id":"P0684","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run price elasticity of demand, palladium (literature)","scope":"palladium, various","value":"-0.700","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"1974","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3, PDF p.16","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; single 1974 estimate; predates autocatalysts"},{"id":"P0685","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, platinum (literature average)","scope":"platinum, various","value":"-0.458","low":"-0.700","high":"-0.330","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2004","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3, PDF p.17","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=3 from 3 studies 1974-2004; median -0.344"},{"id":"P0686","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run price elasticity of demand, platinum (literature average)","scope":"platinum, various","value":"-1.279","low":"-2.050","high":"-0.636","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2004","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3, PDF p.17","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=3; median -1.150"},{"id":"P0687","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run income elasticity of demand, platinum (literature average)","scope":"platinum, various","value":"1.300","low":"0.830","high":"1.770","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2004","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3, PDF p.17","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=2"},{"id":"P0688","domain":"economics","parameter":"static income elasticity of demand, platinum (literature average)","scope":"platinum, various","value":"4.103","low":"0.620","high":"7.586","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2004","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3, PDF p.17","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Dahl Mineral Elasticity of Demand and Supply (MEDS) database summary; value = average of literature estimates, low/high = min/max; n=2; upper value from Evans and Lewis (2002), which Dahl doubts (PDF p.20)"},{"id":"P0689","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run price elasticity of demand, platinum (TIAX 2004)","scope":"platinum, US","value":"-1.15","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2004","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, PDF p.20, text","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"secondary citation in Dahl: TIAX (2004) regressed quantity on price and income, 1975-2000; primary not opened"},{"id":"P0690","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run income elasticity of demand, platinum (TIAX 2004)","scope":"platinum, US","value":"0.83","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2004","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, PDF p.20, text","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"secondary citation in Dahl: TIAX (2004), 1975-2000; primary not opened"},{"id":"P0691","domain":"economics","parameter":"static price elasticity of demand, platinum (Evans and Lewis 2002)","scope":"platinum, world","value":"-3.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2002","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, PDF p.20, text","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"secondary; data 1980-1999; elasticity from inverting estimated price functions with activity elasticity constrained across 14 metals; Dahl calls it questionable; conflicts with TIAX (2004) long-run -1.15 (row above); primary not opened"},{"id":"P0692","domain":"economics","parameter":"static income elasticity of demand, platinum (Evans and Lewis 2002)","scope":"platinum, world","value":"7.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2002","method":"estimated","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, PDF p.20, text","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"secondary; Dahl calls it questionable; conflicts with TIAX (2004) income elasticity 0.83 (row above); primary not opened"},{"id":"P0693","domain":"economics","parameter":"static price elasticity of demand, rare earths (aggregate)","scope":"rare earths, world","value":"-0.4","low":"-0.5","high":"-0.3","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2014","method":"model","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3 PDF p.17 and text PDF p.21","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Pothen (2014); Dahl: values appear to come from expert judgement, not econometric estimation; primary not opened"},{"id":"P0694","domain":"economics","parameter":"static price elasticity of demand, light rare earths","scope":"light REE, world","value":"-0.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2016","method":"model","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3 PDF p.17 and text PDF p.21","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Nguyen and Imholte (2016); expert judgement per Dahl; primary not opened"},{"id":"P0695","domain":"economics","parameter":"static price elasticity of demand, heavy rare earths","scope":"heavy REE, world","value":"-0.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2016","method":"model","source_url":"http://econbus-papers.mines.edu/working-papers/wp202002v2.pdf","locator":"Dahl (2020) CSM WP 2020-02 v2, Table 3 PDF p.17 and text PDF p.21","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Nguyen and Imholte (2016); expert judgement per Dahl; primary not opened"},{"id":"P0696","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of demand, helium","scope":"helium, world","value":"-0.16","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2014","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://openaccess.city.ac.uk/id/eprint/22222/1/MASSOL_RIFAAT_Helium.pdf","locator":"App. B, p.43 (Table B.2 on PDF p.53)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Massol and Rifaat (2018) Resource and Energy Economics 54:186-211, accepted manuscript; Koyck partial-adjustment demand, OLS in levels, annual 1995-2014, world (high and upper-middle income countries), USGS Minerals Yearbook prices; evaluated at 2014 point (6,561.6 MMcf, 200 USD/Mcf); price coefficient 5.514 (SE 2.536), lagged demand 0.795 (SE 0.110), Table B.2 Panel 2"},{"id":"P0697","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run price elasticity of demand, helium","scope":"helium, world","value":"-0.82","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2014","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://openaccess.city.ac.uk/id/eprint/22222/1/MASSOL_RIFAAT_Helium.pdf","locator":"App. B, p.43 (Table B.2 on PDF p.53)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Massol and Rifaat (2018) Resource and Energy Economics 54:186-211, accepted manuscript; Koyck partial-adjustment demand, OLS in levels, annual 1995-2014, world (high and upper-middle income countries), USGS Minerals Yearbook prices; evaluated at 2014 point (6,561.6 MMcf, 200 USD/Mcf); price coefficient 5.514 (SE 2.536), lagged demand 0.795 (SE 0.110), Table B.2 Panel 2"},{"id":"P0698","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run income elasticity of demand, helium","scope":"helium, world","value":"0.37","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2014","method":"derived","source_url":"https://openaccess.city.ac.uk/id/eprint/22222/1/MASSOL_RIFAAT_Helium.pdf","locator":"Table B.2 Panel 2 (PDF p.53); point values p.43-44","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"computed here: 33.435 x 71.809 trillion USD / 6,561.6 MMcf; GDP coefficient SE 14.531; not reported by the authors"},{"id":"P0699","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run income elasticity of demand, helium","scope":"helium, world","value":"1.78","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2014","method":"derived","source_url":"https://openaccess.city.ac.uk/id/eprint/22222/1/MASSOL_RIFAAT_Helium.pdf","locator":"Table B.2 Panel 2 (PDF p.53); point values p.43-44","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"computed here: 0.366 / (1 - 0.795); not reported by the authors"},{"id":"P0700","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run price elasticity of consumer demand, gold","scope":"gold, India consumer demand","value":"-0.42","low":"-0.75","high":"-0.09","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2021","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/18332/Indias-Gold-Market-Reform-and-Growth.pdf","locator":"WGC India Gold Market: Reform and growth, App. 8, Table 1, p.127","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"World Gold Council, India gold market report (chapter first published 10/2021), appendix econometrics; error-correction model, annual 1990-2020, India; low/high = estimate +/- 1.96 SE (SE reported); rupee price; jewellery plus bars and coins; long-run cointegrating equation with income and import duty"},{"id":"P0701","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run income elasticity of consumer demand, gold","scope":"gold, India consumer demand","value":"0.91","low":"0.60","high":"1.22","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2021","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/18332/Indias-Gold-Market-Reform-and-Growth.pdf","locator":"WGC India Gold Market: Reform and growth, App. 8, Table 1, p.127","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"World Gold Council, India gold market report (chapter first published 10/2021), appendix econometrics; error-correction model, annual 1990-2020, India; low/high = estimate +/- 1.96 SE (SE reported); income = GNI per capita"},{"id":"P0702","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of consumer demand, gold","scope":"gold, India consumer demand","value":"-1.15","low":"-1.58","high":"-0.72","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2021","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/18332/Indias-Gold-Market-Reform-and-Growth.pdf","locator":"WGC India Gold Market: Reform and growth, App. 8, Table 2, p.128","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"World Gold Council, India gold market report (chapter first published 10/2021), appendix econometrics; error-correction model, annual 1990-2020, India; low/high = estimate +/- 1.96 SE (SE reported); short run = 1 year; ECM adjustment -0.61"},{"id":"P0703","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run price elasticity of jewellery demand, gold","scope":"gold, India jewellery","value":"-0.66","low":"-0.97","high":"-0.35","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2021","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/18332/Indias-Gold-Market-Reform-and-Growth.pdf","locator":"WGC India Gold Market: Reform and growth, App. 8, Table 3, p.128","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"World Gold Council, India gold market report (chapter first published 10/2021), appendix econometrics; error-correction model, annual 1990-2020, India; low/high = estimate +/- 1.96 SE (SE reported); jewellery 77% of Indian demand"},{"id":"P0704","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run income elasticity of jewellery demand, gold","scope":"gold, India jewellery","value":"1.01","low":"0.72","high":"1.30","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2021","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/18332/Indias-Gold-Market-Reform-and-Growth.pdf","locator":"WGC India Gold Market: Reform and growth, App. 8, Table 3, p.128","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"World Gold Council, India gold market report (chapter first published 10/2021), appendix econometrics; error-correction model, annual 1990-2020, India; low/high = estimate +/- 1.96 SE (SE reported)"},{"id":"P0705","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of jewellery demand, gold","scope":"gold, India jewellery","value":"-1.36","low":"-1.79","high":"-0.93","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2021","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/18332/Indias-Gold-Market-Reform-and-Growth.pdf","locator":"WGC India Gold Market: Reform and growth, App. 8, Table 4, p.129","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"World Gold Council, India gold market report (chapter first published 10/2021), appendix econometrics; error-correction model, annual 1990-2020, India; low/high = estimate +/- 1.96 SE (SE reported); compare P0072 (-0.87, Murenbeeld world jewellery)"},{"id":"P0706","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run income elasticity of bar and coin demand, gold","scope":"gold, India bars and coins","value":"1.13","low":"0.91","high":"1.35","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2021","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/18332/Indias-Gold-Market-Reform-and-Growth.pdf","locator":"WGC India Gold Market: Reform and growth, App. 8, Table 5, p.129","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"World Gold Council, India gold market report (chapter first published 10/2021), appendix econometrics; error-correction model, annual 1990-2020, India; low/high = estimate +/- 1.96 SE (SE reported); price not significant in long run"},{"id":"P0707","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of bar and coin demand, gold","scope":"gold, India bars and coins","value":"-0.87","low":"-1.56","high":"-0.18","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2021","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/18332/Indias-Gold-Market-Reform-and-Growth.pdf","locator":"WGC India Gold Market: Reform and growth, App. 8, Table 6, p.130","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"World Gold Council, India gold market report (chapter first published 10/2021), appendix econometrics; error-correction model, annual 1990-2020, India; low/high = estimate +/- 1.96 SE (SE reported)"},{"id":"P0708","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run price elasticity of technology demand, gold","scope":"gold, India technology","value":"-0.66","low":"-1.52","high":"0.20","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2021","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/18332/Indias-Gold-Market-Reform-and-Growth.pdf","locator":"WGC India Gold Market: Reform and growth, App. 8, Table 7, p.131","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"conflict","note":"World Gold Council, India gold market report (chapter first published 10/2021), appendix econometrics; error-correction model, annual 1990-2020, India; low/high = estimate +/- 1.96 SE (SE reported); text on p.131 says a 1% price rise cuts demand 1.1%, table says -0.66: text/table mismatch"},{"id":"P0709","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run GDP elasticity of technology demand, gold","scope":"gold, India technology","value":"0.82","low":"0.35","high":"1.29","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2021","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/18332/Indias-Gold-Market-Reform-and-Growth.pdf","locator":"WGC India Gold Market: Reform and growth, App. 8, Table 7, p.131","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"World Gold Council, India gold market report (chapter first published 10/2021), appendix econometrics; error-correction model, annual 1990-2020, India; low/high = estimate +/- 1.96 SE (SE reported)"},{"id":"P0710","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run price elasticity of recycling supply, gold","scope":"gold, India recycling","value":"0.57","low":"-0.16","high":"1.30","unit":"elasticity (dimensionless)","year":"2021","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.gold.org/download/file/18332/Indias-Gold-Market-Reform-and-Growth.pdf","locator":"WGC India Gold Market: Reform and growth, App. 8, Table 9, p.132","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"World Gold Council, India gold market report (chapter first published 10/2021), appendix econometrics; error-correction model, annual 1990-2020, India; low/high = estimate +/- 1.96 SE (SE reported); not significant (t=1.53); R2 15.7%"},{"id":"P0711","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space investment, all deal types","scope":"world, start-up space companies (BryceTech)","value":"7.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2024)","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2025/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2025.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2025, PDF p.3 and p.6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"220 deals (2023: 242), 198 recipients. VC 92% of funds (188 deals). BryceTech definition: seed, VC, PE, debt, M&A and IPO in companies that began as angel/VC-backed start-ups, upstream and midstream (hardware, launch, satellite operations) plus direct users of satellite imagery. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0712","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space investment, all deal types","scope":"world, start-up space companies (BryceTech)","value":"10.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2026/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2026.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2026, PDF p.3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"235 deals, 208 recipients; highest since 2021. VC 79% of funds (214 deals), public offerings 12%, debt 6%, acquisitions 3%. BryceTech definition: seed, VC, PE, debt, M&A and IPO in companies that began as angel/VC-backed start-ups, upstream and midstream (hardware, launch, satellite operations) plus direct users of satellite imagery. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0713","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space venture capital investment","scope":"world, start-up space companies (BryceTech)","value":"8.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2026/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2026.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2026, PDF p.4 (caption)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Caption: \"driven by $8.6B from venture capital, $1.3B from IPOs\". VC in space rose 18% 2024-25 vs 72% for all VC (PDF p.5). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0714","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space venture capital investment","scope":"world, start-up space companies (BryceTech)","value":"2","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal, year of deal)","year":"2015","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2025/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2025.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2025, PDF p.5 chart data label","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Chart labels rounded to whole USD billion; VC only (total incl. debt/IPO/M&A is higher, e.g. 2024 total 7.8). Source of global VC comparison: CB Insights. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0715","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space venture capital investment","scope":"world, start-up space companies (BryceTech)","value":"2","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal, year of deal)","year":"2016","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2025/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2025.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2025, PDF p.5 chart data label","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Chart labels rounded to whole USD billion; VC only (total incl. debt/IPO/M&A is higher, e.g. 2024 total 7.8). Source of global VC comparison: CB Insights. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0716","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space venture capital investment","scope":"world, start-up space companies (BryceTech)","value":"2","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal, year of deal)","year":"2017","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2025/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2025.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2025, PDF p.5 chart data label","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Chart labels rounded to whole USD billion; VC only (total incl. debt/IPO/M&A is higher, e.g. 2024 total 7.8). Source of global VC comparison: CB Insights. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0717","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space venture capital investment","scope":"world, start-up space companies (BryceTech)","value":"3","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal, year of deal)","year":"2018","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2025/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2025.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2025, PDF p.5 chart data label","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Chart labels rounded to whole USD billion; VC only (total incl. debt/IPO/M&A is higher, e.g. 2024 total 7.8). Source of global VC comparison: CB Insights. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0718","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space venture capital investment","scope":"world, start-up space companies (BryceTech)","value":"6","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal, year of deal)","year":"2019","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2025/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2025.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2025, PDF p.5 chart data label","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Chart labels rounded to whole USD billion; VC only (total incl. debt/IPO/M&A is higher, e.g. 2024 total 7.8). Source of global VC comparison: CB Insights. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0719","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space venture capital investment","scope":"world, start-up space companies (BryceTech)","value":"6","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal, year of deal)","year":"2020","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2025/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2025.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2025, PDF p.5 chart data label","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Chart labels rounded to whole USD billion; VC only (total incl. debt/IPO/M&A is higher, e.g. 2024 total 7.8). Source of global VC comparison: CB Insights. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0720","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space venture capital investment","scope":"world, start-up space companies (BryceTech)","value":"11","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal, year of deal)","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2025/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2025.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2025, PDF p.5 chart data label","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Chart labels rounded to whole USD billion; VC only (total incl. debt/IPO/M&A is higher, e.g. 2024 total 7.8). Source of global VC comparison: CB Insights. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0721","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space venture capital investment","scope":"world, start-up space companies (BryceTech)","value":"7","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal, year of deal)","year":"2022","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2025/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2025.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2025, PDF p.5 chart data label","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Chart labels rounded to whole USD billion; VC only (total incl. debt/IPO/M&A is higher, e.g. 2024 total 7.8). Source of global VC comparison: CB Insights. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0722","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space venture capital investment","scope":"world, start-up space companies (BryceTech)","value":"7","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal, year of deal)","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2025/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2025.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2025, PDF p.5 chart data label","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Chart labels rounded to whole USD billion; VC only (total incl. debt/IPO/M&A is higher, e.g. 2024 total 7.8). Source of global VC comparison: CB Insights. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0723","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space venture capital investment","scope":"world, start-up space companies (BryceTech)","value":"7","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal, year of deal)","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2025/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2025.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2025, PDF p.5 chart data label","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Chart labels rounded to whole USD billion; VC only (total incl. debt/IPO/M&A is higher, e.g. 2024 total 7.8). Source of global VC comparison: CB Insights. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0724","domain":"economics","parameter":"cumulative start-up space investment 2015-2024","scope":"world, start-up space companies (BryceTech)","value":"65.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal, sum of years)","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2025/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2025.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2025, PDF p.6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"VC 81%, public offering 8%, acquisition 6%, debt 4%, PE 1%. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0725","domain":"economics","parameter":"cumulative start-up space investment 2016-2025","scope":"world, start-up space companies (BryceTech)","value":"73.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal, sum of years)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2026/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2026.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2026, PDF p.15","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"1,789 deals 2016-2025 (per newspaceeconomy.ca summary of the report); VC 81%. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0726","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of global VC going to start-up space companies","scope":"world, 2015-2024","value":"2","low":"1","high":"3","unit":"% of global VC investment","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2025/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2025.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2025, PDF p.5 caption","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Caption: \"Share of global VC investment in start-up space companies between 1%-3% since 2015\". Value = midpoint. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0727","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space investment in US companies","scope":"United States start-ups (BryceTech)","value":"4.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2024)","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2025/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2025.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2025, PDF p.8 (regional split chart); also pp.12, 14","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"2023: 5.3. BryceTech definition: seed, VC, PE, debt, M&A and IPO in companies that began as angel/VC-backed start-ups, upstream and midstream (hardware, launch, satellite operations) plus direct users of satellite imagery. [batch finance_insurance_round2] Locator corrected 2026-11-12 after hand check (figure not on p.3)."},{"id":"P0728","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space investment in US companies","scope":"United States start-ups (BryceTech)","value":"7.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2026/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2026.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2026, PDF p.3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"About two-thirds of world total; 83 of 208 recipients. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0729","domain":"economics","parameter":"start-up space investment in Chinese companies","scope":"China start-ups (BryceTech)","value":"1.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2024)","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2025/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2025.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2025, PDF p.3 and p.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"2023: USD 542M. 24% of world total in 2024, driven by megaconstellation satellite makers and launch providers. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0730","domain":"economics","parameter":"IPO proceeds of start-up space companies","scope":"world (BryceTech)","value":"1.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/start_up_space_2026/BryceTech_Start_Up_Space_2026.pdf","locator":"Start-Up Space 2026, PDF p.3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"4 IPOs; 2024: USD 281M. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0731","domain":"economics","parameter":"SpaceTech venture investment, trailing 12 months","scope":"world, SpaceTech (Seraphim), TTM to Q4 2025","value":"12.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://seraphim.vc/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Seraphim-Index-Q4-2025.pdf","locator":"Seraphim Space Index Q4 2025, PDF p.2-3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"All-time high; TTM to Q4 2024 = 8.4; previous peak 10.9 (TTM Q2 2021). 604 deals (593 TTM Q4 2024). Seraphim definition: third-party capital invested at arm's length in SpaceTech (Build, Launch, Platform, Downlink, Analyse, Product, Beyond Earth); excludes founders' own money (e.g. Bezos in Blue Origin) (PDF p.7). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0732","domain":"economics","parameter":"SpaceTech venture investment, trailing 12 months","scope":"world, SpaceTech (Seraphim), TTM to Q4 2024","value":"8.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2024)","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://seraphim.vc/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Seraphim-Index-Q4-2025.pdf","locator":"Seraphim Space Index Q4 2025, PDF p.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"Comparison figure printed in Q4 2025 index. Seraphim definition: third-party capital invested at arm's length in SpaceTech (Build, Launch, Platform, Downlink, Analyse, Product, Beyond Earth); excludes founders' own money (e.g. Bezos in Blue Origin) (PDF p.7). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0733","domain":"economics","parameter":"SpaceTech venture investment, trailing 12 months, cycle peak","scope":"world, SpaceTech (Seraphim), TTM to Q2 2021","value":"10.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2021)","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://seraphim.vc/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Seraphim-Index-Q4-2025.pdf","locator":"Seraphim Space Index Q4 2025, PDF p.2-3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"2021 peak before the 2022 downturn. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0734","domain":"economics","parameter":"SpaceTech venture investment, single quarter","scope":"world, SpaceTech (Seraphim), Q4 2025","value":"3.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://seraphim.vc/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Seraphim-Index-Q4-2025.pdf","locator":"Seraphim Space Index Q4 2025, PDF p.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"Record quarter; Q3 2025 3.5; 147 deals; top-10 deals USD 2.4bn (Stoke Space 510M largest). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0735","domain":"economics","parameter":"median SpaceTech deal size","scope":"world, SpaceTech (Seraphim), Q4 2025","value":"8.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://seraphim.vc/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Seraphim-Index-Q4-2025.pdf","locator":"Seraphim Space Index Q4 2025, PDF p.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"Q3 2025 median 5.8M; Q4 2025 average 35M (Q3 30M). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0736","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of SpaceTech investment to US companies","scope":"world, SpaceTech (Seraphim), 2025","value":"60","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of USD invested","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://seraphim.vc/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Seraphim-Index-Q4-2025.pdf","locator":"Seraphim Space Index Q4 2025, PDF p.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"USD 7.3bn, c.130% above 2024; Europe +c.25%; China down c.10%. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0737","domain":"economics","parameter":"SpaceTech investment in Chinese companies","scope":"China, SpaceTech (Seraphim), TTM to Q4 2025","value":"2","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://seraphim.vc/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Seraphim-Index-Q4-2025.pdf","locator":"Seraphim Space Index Q4 2025, PDF p.5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"approximately $2bn of the total $2.7bn invested in Asia; 119 Chinese deals. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0738","domain":"economics","parameter":"private investment in space-economy companies","scope":"world, space economy (Space Capital)","value":"55.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.morningstar.com/news/marketwatch/20260114133/the-space-economy-is-booming-heres-where-most-of-the-money-is-going","locator":"MarketWatch 2026-01-14 article body, citing Space Capital Q4 2025 report","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"431 companies, +65% vs 2024. Space Capital primary report not opened (download gated). Space Capital definition: private-market equity investment in space-economy companies across Infrastructure, Distribution and Applications (includes GNSS/GEOINT application companies), far broader than BryceTech/Seraphim. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0739","domain":"economics","parameter":"private investment in space-economy companies, single quarter","scope":"world, space economy (Space Capital), Q4 2025","value":"17.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.morningstar.com/news/marketwatch/20260114133/the-space-economy-is-booming-heres-where-most-of-the-money-is-going","locator":"MarketWatch 2026-01-14 article body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"135 firms; Q4 2024: USD 9.5bn across 99 companies. Space Capital definition: private-market equity investment in space-economy companies across Infrastructure, Distribution and Applications (includes GNSS/GEOINT application companies), far broader than BryceTech/Seraphim. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0740","domain":"economics","parameter":"private investment in space-economy companies","scope":"world, space economy (Space Capital)","value":"33.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2024)","year":"2024","method":"derived","source_url":"https://www.morningstar.com/news/marketwatch/20260114133/the-space-economy-is-booming-heres-where-most-of-the-money-is-going","locator":"55.3 / 1.65","verification":"derived","bias":"investor","status":"must-check","note":"Back-calculated from the 2025 total and the stated +65% growth; not a published figure. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0741","domain":"economics","parameter":"cumulative private equity investment in space-economy companies since 2009","scope":"world, space economy (Space Capital), to Q3 2025","value":"393","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal, sum of years)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.exterrajsc.com/p/defense-drives-surge-in-space-investments","locator":"Journal of Space Commerce article on Space Capital Q3 2025 report","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"2,286 unique companies. Q3 2025 alone: USD 5.8bn across 115 companies. Space Capital definition: private-market equity investment in space-economy companies across Infrastructure, Distribution and Applications (includes GNSS/GEOINT application companies), far broader than BryceTech/Seraphim. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0742","domain":"economics","parameter":"cumulative investment in space-economy companies since 2009","scope":"world, space economy (Space Capital), to Q3 2026","value":"519","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal, sum of years)","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.spacecapital.com/space-iq","locator":"Space IQ landing page (Q3 2026 report)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"$519 billion invested across the space economy since 2009; implies about USD 126bn added between Q3 2025 and Q3 2026 (derived), incl. Q1 2026 record quarter reported elsewhere. Space Capital definition: private-market equity investment in space-economy companies across Infrastructure, Distribution and Applications (includes GNSS/GEOINT application companies), far broader than BryceTech/Seraphim. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0743","domain":"economics","parameter":"private investment in space, annual","scope":"world (WEF/McKinsey), 2021 and 2022","value":"70","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion per year (nominal)","year":"2022","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Space_2024.pdf","locator":"WEF Space: The $1.8 Trillion Opportunity (Apr 2024), p.5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"must-check","note":"private sector investment reaching all-time highs of more than $70 billion in 2021 and 2022 (lower bound); definition and underlying tracker not stated in text; far above BryceTech/Seraphim. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0744","domain":"economics","parameter":"space ETF total return since inception (NAV)","scope":"Procure Space ETF (UFO), 2019-04-11 to 2026-10-31","value":"78.76","low":"","high":"","unit":"% cumulative, USD","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.procureetfs.com/ufo","locator":"procureetfs.com/ufo, Performance table, month end 10/31/2026","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Table labels it \"SINCE INCEPTION\"; page footnote says periods >1 yr are annualised, but 78.76%/yr is impossible for this fund, so read as cumulative. Market value: 78.41%. Quarter end 9/30/2026: 87.70%. Fund holds SpaceX (14.8%) after its 2026 IPO. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0745","domain":"economics","parameter":"space ETF annualised total return since inception (NAV)","scope":"Procure Space ETF (UFO), 2019-04-11 to 2026-10-31","value":"8.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year, USD nominal","year":"2026","method":"derived","source_url":"https://www.procureetfs.com/ufo","locator":"(1.7876)^(1/7.56)-1","verification":"derived","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Assumes the 78.76% figure is cumulative; 7.56 years from inception. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0746","domain":"economics","parameter":"space ETF 1-year total return (NAV)","scope":"Procure Space ETF (UFO), year to 2026-09-30","value":"19.26","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year, USD nominal","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.procureetfs.com/ufo","locator":"procureetfs.com/ufo, Performance table, quarter end 09/30/2026","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Year to 10/31/2026: 7.49%; 6 months to 10/31/2026: -21.69%. Expense ratio 0.75%. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0747","domain":"economics","parameter":"share price gain over 2025","scope":"Planet Labs (public SpaceTech)","value":"390","low":"","high":"","unit":"% (calendar 2025)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://seraphim.vc/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Seraphim-Index-Q4-2025.pdf","locator":"Seraphim Space Index Q4 2025, PDF p.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"c.390%; AST SpaceMobile c.245%, Rocket Lab c.175%; other listed SpaceTech \"mixed\". [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0748","domain":"economics","parameter":"share price gain over 2025","scope":"AST SpaceMobile (public SpaceTech)","value":"245","low":"","high":"","unit":"% (calendar 2025)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://seraphim.vc/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Seraphim-Index-Q4-2025.pdf","locator":"Seraphim Space Index Q4 2025, PDF p.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"c.245%. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0749","domain":"economics","parameter":"share price gain over 2025","scope":"Rocket Lab (public SpaceTech)","value":"175","low":"","high":"","unit":"% (calendar 2025)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://seraphim.vc/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Seraphim-Index-Q4-2025.pdf","locator":"Seraphim Space Index Q4 2025, PDF p.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"c.175%. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0750","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of space SPAC listings where holders lost money","scope":"16 space companies listed via SPAC 2009-2023, prices at 2026-10-19","value":"68.75","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of companies","year":"2026","method":"derived","source_url":"https://spaceq.ca/space-spacs-poor-record-investors/","locator":"SpaceQ 2026-10-20 article body (\"lost money on 11 of them\")","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"11 of 16; prices vs USD 10 SPAC unit, split-adjusted. Five of 16 trade above USD 10 on latest price. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0751","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of space SPAC listings graded failure","scope":"16 space companies listed via SPAC 2009-2023","value":"62.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of companies","year":"2026","method":"derived","source_url":"https://spaceq.ca/space-spacs-poor-record-investors/","locator":"SpaceQ 2026-10-20, scorecard","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"10 failed, 3 mixed (AST, Planet, Redwire), 3 passed (Rocket Lab, Iridium, Intuitive Machines) on SpaceQ 5-test score (price at 1 yr, 3 yr, latest; survival; revenue vs forecast). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0752","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of space SPAC listings no longer listed","scope":"16 space companies listed via SPAC 2009-2023","value":"25","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of companies","year":"2026","method":"derived","source_url":"https://spaceq.ca/space-spacs-poor-record-investors/","locator":"SpaceQ 2026-10-20 article body","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"4 of 16: Virgin Orbit bankrupt, Astra taken private, Terran Orbital and SatixFy acquired below USD 10. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0753","domain":"economics","parameter":"revenue delivered vs SPAC-pitch forecast","scope":"16 space SPACs, years with forecasts","value":"21","low":"13","high":"21","unit":"% of projected revenue","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://spaceq.ca/space-spacs-poor-record-investors/","locator":"SpaceQ 2026-10-20, section \"The promise gap\"","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Excluding Rocket Lab: about 13%. Momentus forecast ~USD 2bn 2025 revenue, reported ~USD 1M. All six with <USD 10M revenue at close failed. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0754","domain":"economics","parameter":"median value of a USD 10 SPAC share","scope":"16 space SPACs, split-adjusted, 2026-10-19 close or final price","value":"2.12","low":"0","high":"51.36","unit":"USD per original USD 10 share (nominal)","year":"2026","method":"derived","source_url":"https://spaceq.ca/space-spacs-poor-record-investors/","locator":"SpaceQ table, median of \"Adjusted for splits\" column","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Median of 16 values (8th 2.10 SatixFy, 9th 2.14 BlackSky); Virgin Orbit set to 0, Momentus \"under 0.01\" set to 0.01. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0755","domain":"economics","parameter":"mean value of a USD 10 SPAC share (equal-weighted)","scope":"16 space SPACs, split-adjusted, 2026-10-19","value":"11.28","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD per original USD 10 share (nominal)","year":"2026","method":"derived","source_url":"https://spaceq.ca/space-spacs-poor-record-investors/","locator":"SpaceQ table, mean of \"Adjusted for splits\" column","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Sum 180.41/16. Skewed by Rocket Lab 51.36, Iridium 44.18, AST 41.85; no time or market adjustment, holding periods 3-17 years. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0756","domain":"economics","parameter":"public-share redemption at SPAC close","scope":"Intuitive Machines (2023) and NorthStar Earth & Space (2026)","value":"93","low":"93","high":"96","unit":"% of public shares redeemed","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://spaceq.ca/space-spacs-poor-record-investors/","locator":"SpaceQ 2026-10-20 article body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Intuitive Machines ~93%; NorthStar ~96% (kept ~9% of the USD 260M trust after costs). Virgin Orbit raised ~USD 228M of USD 483M targeted. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0757","domain":"economics","parameter":"share price fall from post-merger peak","scope":"Astra (SPAC 2021), to 2022-10-24","value":"96","low":"","high":"","unit":"% decline","year":"2022","method":"measured","source_url":"https://thespacereview.com/article/4470/1","locator":"The Space Review 2022-10 (\"The space investment crunch\") article body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Peak close USD 15.47 to USD 0.5175; then no space SPAC traded above USD 10. Space Capital YTD Q3 2022 investment down 47% to USD 17.2bn (same article). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0758","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of tracked small launch vehicles defunct","scope":"small launch vehicles (<=1,000 kg to LEO), Niederstrasser survey 2022","value":"35.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of tracked vehicles","year":"2022","method":"derived","source_url":"https://spaceq.ca/the-number-of-small-launch-vehicles-under-development-shrinks/","locator":"SpaceQ article on 2022 survey: 166 tracked, 11 operational, 49 in development, 47 watch list","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"166-11-49-47 = 59 defunct (no update in 2 years or cancelled); defunct count not printed in article. Tracked vehicles rose from 31 (2015) to 166 (2022). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0759","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch vehicles retired after fewer than 10 flights","scope":"launch vehicles active since 2000 (AXA XL survey)","value":"16","low":"","high":"","unit":"vehicles","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.iuai.org/resource/collection/B0855536-B20C-4535-B255-07D045B0064B/2023_SRSG_Space_Insurance_Update_Chris_Kunstadter.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) 2023 Space Insurance Update, slide 8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"16 launch vehicles active since 2000 have flown fewer than 10 times and have subsequently been retired. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0760","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-term launch vehicle failure rate beyond first 10 launches","scope":"world launch vehicles (AXA XL)","value":"4","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of launches","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/04_kunstadter_space_insurance_update_axa_xl_scaf_220111.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) Space Insurance Update Jan 2022, slide 19","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Long-term failure rate beyond first 10 launches ~4%; failure = launch causing (or would cause) an insurance claim. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0761","domain":"economics","parameter":"discount rate in LCOE capital recovery factor","scope":"NASA OTPS space-based solar power study (government financing)","value":"3","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/otps-sbsp-report-final-tagged-approved-1-8-24-tagged-v2.pdf","locator":"NASA OTPS SBSP report (Jan 2024), PDF p.73, LCOE inputs","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Capital Recovery Factor, with a default discount rate of 3% (NREL default); baseline assumes government financing, no return on equity; same rate for comparison technologies. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0762","domain":"economics","parameter":"real discount rate in economic assessment","scope":"UK space-based solar power study (Frazer-Nash for UK government)","value":"3.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year, real","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.fnc.co.uk/media/cfsodaxg/fnc-004456-51624r-phase-2-annex-c-economic-assessment-data-tables.pdf","locator":"FNC 004456-51624R Phase 2 Annex C, PDF p.5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Values in 2018 NPV terms, inflation stripped out, 3.5% real (UK Green Book rate). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0763","domain":"economics","parameter":"discount rate in cost-benefit analysis of UK space exploration","scope":"UK space exploration options (London Economics for BNSC)","value":"3.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year, real","year":"2009","method":"model","source_url":"https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a80de1f40f0b62302695f3b/Space_Exploration_Review_Economic_Analysis_March_2009.pdf","locator":"Space Exploration Review Economic Analysis (Mar 2009), PDF p.13 and p.76","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Green Book rate for 0-30-year impacts; p.76 NPVs assume 3.5% long-term rate and 2.0% inflation. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0764","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch vehicle failure rate (annual)","scope":"worldwide orbital launches 2023 (AXA XL)","value":"5.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of launches","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matinsurance.ania.it/upload/news/28/file-10/axa-xl-space-insurance-presentation-to-ania-june-2024-first-round.pdf","locator":"AXA XL to ANIA June 2024, slide 10 (rendered image)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"confirms P0303: rendered slide shows year labels 2012-2023; 2023 = 12 failures, 211 successes. Series 2012-2023: 7.7, 4.9, 3.3, 5.8, 3.5, 7.7, 4.3, 4.9, 8.8, 7.6, 4.3, 5.4. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0765","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance net premium on risks attaching","scope":"worldwide space insurance market 2012 (AXA XL)","value":"980","low":"955","high":"1005","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2012","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matinsurance.ania.it/upload/news/28/file-10/axa-xl-space-insurance-presentation-to-ania-june-2024-first-round.pdf","locator":"AXA XL to ANIA June 2024, slide 7 bar chart (read from rendered image)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Read off unlabelled bar chart, +/-25M; peak of 2001-2023 series. Losses at date of loss. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0766","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance net premium on risks attaching","scope":"worldwide space insurance market 2016 (AXA XL)","value":"640","low":"615","high":"665","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2016","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matinsurance.ania.it/upload/news/28/file-10/axa-xl-space-insurance-presentation-to-ania-june-2024-first-round.pdf","locator":"AXA XL to ANIA June 2024, slide 7 bar chart (read from rendered image)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Read off unlabelled bar chart, +/-25M; losses that year ~75M, lowest of series. Losses at date of loss. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0767","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance net premium on risks attaching","scope":"worldwide space insurance market 2019 (AXA XL)","value":"530","low":"505","high":"555","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2019","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matinsurance.ania.it/upload/news/28/file-10/axa-xl-space-insurance-presentation-to-ania-june-2024-first-round.pdf","locator":"AXA XL to ANIA June 2024, slide 7 bar chart (read from rendered image)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Read off unlabelled bar chart, +/-25M; losses ~790M. Losses at date of loss. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0768","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance net premium on risks attaching","scope":"worldwide space insurance market 2020 (AXA XL)","value":"455","low":"430","high":"480","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2020","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matinsurance.ania.it/upload/news/28/file-10/axa-xl-space-insurance-presentation-to-ania-june-2024-first-round.pdf","locator":"AXA XL to ANIA June 2024, slide 7 bar chart (read from rendered image)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Read off unlabelled bar chart, +/-25M; lowest premium of series; losses ~360M. Losses at date of loss. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0769","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance pricing index","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, 2018 trough (AXA XL)","value":"28","low":"25","high":"31","unit":"% of 2002 level","year":"2018","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matinsurance.ania.it/upload/news/28/file-10/axa-xl-space-insurance-presentation-to-ania-june-2024-first-round.pdf","locator":"AXA XL to ANIA June 2024, slide 8 (read from rendered line chart)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Chart read +/-3 pts; 2003 peak ~122%, 2023 ~58% and rising. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0770","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance capacity index","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, 2019 peak (AXA XL)","value":"147","low":"144","high":"150","unit":"% of 2002 level","year":"2019","method":"measured","source_url":"https://matinsurance.ania.it/upload/news/28/file-10/axa-xl-space-insurance-presentation-to-ania-june-2024-first-round.pdf","locator":"AXA XL to ANIA June 2024, slide 8 (read from rendered line chart)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Chart read +/-3 pts; 2004 trough ~67%; 2023 ~93%. Capacity and price move inversely. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0771","domain":"economics","parameter":"average annual net launch + 1 year insurance rate","scope":"worldwide market, policies placed 2003 (AXA XL)","value":"21","low":"20","high":"21","unit":"% of insured value","year":"2003","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/04_kunstadter_space_insurance_update_axa_xl_scaf_220111.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) Jan 2022, slide 18 (read from rendered line chart, left axis)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Market average by year placed, chart read; 1988 ~21%, 1998 trough ~9%. Higher than the Aerospace Corp 2-3% for mature risks in 2019 (definition differs: average vs mature risk). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0772","domain":"economics","parameter":"average annual net launch + 1 year insurance rate","scope":"worldwide market, policies placed 2018 (AXA XL)","value":"5","low":"5","high":"5.5","unit":"% of insured value","year":"2018","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/04_kunstadter_space_insurance_update_axa_xl_scaf_220111.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) Jan 2022, slide 18 (read from rendered line chart, left axis)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Market average by year placed, chart read; 1988 ~21%, 1998 trough ~9%. Higher than the Aerospace Corp 2-3% for mature risks in 2019 (definition differs: average vs mature risk). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0773","domain":"economics","parameter":"average annual net launch + 1 year insurance rate","scope":"worldwide market, policies placed 2021 (AXA XL)","value":"8","low":"7.8","high":"8.5","unit":"% of insured value","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/04_kunstadter_space_insurance_update_axa_xl_scaf_220111.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) Jan 2022, slide 18 (read from rendered line chart, left axis)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Market average by year placed, chart read; 1988 ~21%, 1998 trough ~9%. Higher than the Aerospace Corp 2-3% for mature risks in 2019 (definition differs: average vs mature risk). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0774","domain":"economics","parameter":"average annual net in-orbit insurance rate","scope":"worldwide market, policies placed 2003 (AXA XL)","value":"2.75","low":"2.6","high":"2.8","unit":"% of insured value per year","year":"2003","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/04_kunstadter_space_insurance_update_axa_xl_scaf_220111.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) Jan 2022, slide 18 (read from rendered line chart, right axis)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Chart read; slide says rates had returned to 2011-2014 levels by 2021. Compare P0278/P0279 (0.6% to 1.2% GEO, 2023-24). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0775","domain":"economics","parameter":"average annual net in-orbit insurance rate","scope":"worldwide market, policies placed 2018 (AXA XL)","value":"0.5","low":"0.45","high":"0.55","unit":"% of insured value per year","year":"2018","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/04_kunstadter_space_insurance_update_axa_xl_scaf_220111.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) Jan 2022, slide 18 (read from rendered line chart, right axis)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Chart read; slide says rates had returned to 2011-2014 levels by 2021. Compare P0278/P0279 (0.6% to 1.2% GEO, 2023-24). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0776","domain":"economics","parameter":"average annual net in-orbit insurance rate","scope":"worldwide market, policies placed 2021 (AXA XL)","value":"1.05","low":"1.0","high":"1.1","unit":"% of insured value per year","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/04_kunstadter_space_insurance_update_axa_xl_scaf_220111.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) Jan 2022, slide 18 (read from rendered line chart, right axis)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Chart read; slide says rates had returned to 2011-2014 levels by 2021. Compare P0278/P0279 (0.6% to 1.2% GEO, 2023-24). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0777","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance net premium","scope":"worldwide space insurance market 2021 (AXA XL)","value":"517","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2021)","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/04_kunstadter_space_insurance_update_axa_xl_scaf_220111.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) Jan 2022, slide 17","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Net premium on risks attaching; losses USD 365M at date of loss. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0778","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance net premium","scope":"worldwide space insurance market 2022, excl. Russian risks (AXA XL)","value":"570","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2022)","year":"2022","method":"measured","source_url":"https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.iuai.org/resource/collection/B0855536-B20C-4535-B255-07D045B0064B/2023_SRSG_Space_Insurance_Update_Chris_Kunstadter.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) 2023 update (rev. 30-May-23), slide 6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Losses USD 310M; excludes USD 75M Russian-risk premium from 1 Mar 2022. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0779","domain":"economics","parameter":"total insured exposure in orbit","scope":"insured satellites in orbit, end 2021 (AXA XL)","value":"24.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal)","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/04_kunstadter_space_insurance_update_axa_xl_scaf_220111.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) Jan 2022, slides 14-15","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"278 insured satellites (231 GEO/MEO, 47 LEO) of ~5,100 active; max single risk USD 545M, mean 106M, median 86M; LEO insured value USD 2.8bn. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0780","domain":"economics","parameter":"total insured exposure in orbit","scope":"insured satellites in orbit, May 2023 (AXA XL)","value":"28.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal)","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.iuai.org/resource/collection/B0855536-B20C-4535-B255-07D045B0064B/2023_SRSG_Space_Insurance_Update_Chris_Kunstadter.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) 2023 update, slide 4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"322 insured satellites; max USD 492M, mean 98M, median 78M; LEO 78 satellites, USD 3.3bn (slide 5). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0781","domain":"economics","parameter":"mean insured value per satellite in orbit","scope":"insured satellites in orbit, May 2023 (AXA XL)","value":"98","low":"78","high":"492","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.iuai.org/resource/collection/B0855536-B20C-4535-B255-07D045B0064B/2023_SRSG_Space_Insurance_Update_Chris_Kunstadter.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) 2023 update, slide 4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Median 78M; max 492M. End 2021: mean 106M, median 86M, max 545M. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0782","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of satellites in orbit insured","scope":"GEO satellites, May 2023 (AXA XL)","value":"45","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of satellites","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.iuai.org/resource/collection/B0855536-B20C-4535-B255-07D045B0064B/2023_SRSG_Space_Insurance_Update_Chris_Kunstadter.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) 2023 update, slide 4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"226 insured GEO satellites; MEO 18 (10%). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0783","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of satellites in orbit insured","scope":"LEO satellites, May 2023 (AXA XL)","value":"1","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of satellites","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.iuai.org/resource/collection/B0855536-B20C-4535-B255-07D045B0064B/2023_SRSG_Space_Insurance_Update_Chris_Kunstadter.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) 2023 update, slide 4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"conflict","note":"78 insured LEO satellites; P0302 (Gallagher Q4 2023) gives 3% of LEO satellites insured for 2023. Same year, different broker counts. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0784","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of launches insured","scope":"worldwide orbital launches (AXA XL)","value":"50","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of launches","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.iuai.org/resource/collection/B0855536-B20C-4535-B255-07D045B0064B/2023_SRSG_Space_Insurance_Update_Chris_Kunstadter.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) 2023 update, slide 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"must-check","note":"Half of all launches carry insurance (chart annotation, period not stated); compare P0301 (~20% in 2025, ~60% at 2020-21 peak). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0785","domain":"economics","parameter":"insured value required for largest launch risks","scope":"worldwide space insurance market (AXA XL)","value":"650","low":"500","high":"800","unit":"USD million (nominal 2023)","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.iuai.org/resource/collection/B0855536-B20C-4535-B255-07D045B0064B/2023_SRSG_Space_Insurance_Update_Chris_Kunstadter.pdf","locator":"Kunstadter (AXA XL) 2023 update, slide 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Market requires $500m to $800m for largest risks; small insured launches (<USD 100M) increasing. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0786","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch + 1 year insurance rate for a mature risk","scope":"satellites on mature launchers, 2003","value":"20","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of insured value","year":"2003","method":"measured","source_url":"https://aerospace.org/sites/default/files/2019-11/Chaney_SatelliteInsurance_11132019.pdf","locator":"Aerospace Corp CSPS (Chaney 2019), printed p.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Launch plus one rates for a risk perceived as mature have decreased from 20 percent of the amount insured in 2003 to 2-3 percent in 2019. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0787","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch + 1 year insurance rate for a mature risk","scope":"satellites on mature launchers, 2019","value":"2.5","low":"2","high":"3","unit":"% of insured value","year":"2019","method":"measured","source_url":"https://aerospace.org/sites/default/files/2019-11/Chaney_SatelliteInsurance_11132019.pdf","locator":"Aerospace Corp CSPS (Chaney 2019), printed p.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Range 2-3% (value = midpoint); buyer's market before the 2023 hardening (cf. P0276 <6% early 2023, P0277 ~10% 2024). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0788","domain":"economics","parameter":"theoretical space insurance capacity per risk","scope":"worldwide space insurance market 2019","value":"750","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2019)","year":"2019","method":"measured","source_url":"https://aerospace.org/sites/default/files/2019-11/Chaney_SatelliteInsurance_11132019.pdf","locator":"Aerospace Corp CSPS (Chaney 2019), printed p.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"hovers around $750 million per risk; most launches need USD 100-150M of cover. Compare P0297-P0299 (USD 502-550M working, ~300M competitive, 2024-26). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0789","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of launched satellites insured","scope":"satellites launched worldwide 2018","value":"67","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of satellites launched","year":"2018","method":"measured","source_url":"https://aerospace.org/sites/default/files/2019-11/Chaney_SatelliteInsurance_11132019.pdf","locator":"Aerospace Corp CSPS (Chaney 2019), printed p.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"roughly two-thirds of launched satellites globally carried some form of insurance - a ten-year high. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0790","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance events per year","scope":"worldwide space insurance market","value":"30","low":"","high":"","unit":"events per year","year":"2019","method":"measured","source_url":"https://aerospace.org/sites/default/files/2019-11/Chaney_SatelliteInsurance_11132019.pdf","locator":"Aerospace Corp CSPS (Chaney 2019), printed p.6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"(around 30 each year) insurance events; small sample limits actuarial pricing. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0791","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance claims","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, calendar 2024 (Seradata)","value":"210.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2024)","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://satnews.com/2025/08/17/space-insurance-promising-start-to-the-year-marred-only-by-methanesat-claim/","locator":"Satnews 2025-08-17 reprint of Slingshot Seradata article, body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"conflict","note":"Against estimated gross premium USD 580M (before broker deductions); conflicts with P0292 (~USD 50M, Seradata revision snippet). Largest 2024 claim EROS C3-1 USD 114M (63% partial loss). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0792","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance gross premium income","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, calendar 2024 (Seradata)","value":"580","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2024)","year":"2024","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://satnews.com/2025/08/17/space-insurance-promising-start-to-the-year-marred-only-by-methanesat-claim/","locator":"Satnews 2025-08-17 reprint of Seradata article, body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Gross before broker deductions; 2025 expected USD 550-600M, \"typical of the last five years\". [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0793","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance loss ratio","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, calendar 2024 (Seradata figures)","value":"36.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"% (claims / gross premium)","year":"2024","method":"derived","source_url":"https://satnews.com/2025/08/17/space-insurance-promising-start-to-the-year-marred-only-by-methanesat-claim/","locator":"210.8 / 580","verification":"derived","bias":"consultancy","status":"must-check","note":"Derived from the two Seradata rows above; inherits the claims conflict with P0292. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0794","domain":"economics","parameter":"in-orbit insurance rate surcharge for high-value spacecraft","scope":"satellites insured above USD 250M (Seradata)","value":"0.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"percentage points of insured value","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://satnews.com/2025/08/17/space-insurance-promising-start-to-the-year-marred-only-by-methanesat-claim/","locator":"Satnews 2025-08-17 reprint of Seradata article, body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"H1 2025: L+1 and post-launch in-orbit rates falling slightly; LVF rates depend on launcher record. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0795","domain":"economics","parameter":"space insurance claims, 2023 and 2024 combined (revised)","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, 2023-24","value":"1.5","low":"1.5","high":"1.9","unit":"USD billion (nominal)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-market-update-q4-2025","locator":"Gallagher Space Market Update Q4 2025, section \"Reduction of overall 2023/2024 claims\"","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"confirms P0291 and resolves its ambiguity: \"Overall claims for 2023/24 have decreased from USD1.9 billion to USD1.5 billion\" = combined two-year total after settlements, not 2024 alone. Six commercial GEO orders in both 2024 and 2025 (same page). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0796","domain":"economics","parameter":"year-on-year change in space insurance capacity","scope":"worldwide space insurance market, 2026 vs 2025","value":"100","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal 2026)","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-insurance-market-update-q1-2026","locator":"Gallagher Space Insurance Market Update Q1 2026 (10 Apr 2026), body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"approximately USD100m year on year; theoretical capacity >15% higher than a year earlier. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0797","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of space insurance capacity by region","scope":"worldwide space insurance market 2026, UK","value":"43","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of capacity","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-insurance-market-update-q1-2026","locator":"Gallagher Q1 2026, chart \"Capacity by region\" (chart data in page source)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Shares sum to 100 across UK, Europe, USA, Dubai, Asia. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0798","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of space insurance capacity by region","scope":"worldwide space insurance market 2026, Europe (ex-UK)","value":"25","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of capacity","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-insurance-market-update-q1-2026","locator":"Gallagher Q1 2026, chart \"Capacity by region\" (chart data in page source)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Shares sum to 100 across UK, Europe, USA, Dubai, Asia. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0799","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of space insurance capacity by region","scope":"worldwide space insurance market 2026, USA","value":"19","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of capacity","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-insurance-market-update-q1-2026","locator":"Gallagher Q1 2026, chart \"Capacity by region\" (chart data in page source)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Shares sum to 100 across UK, Europe, USA, Dubai, Asia. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0800","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of space insurance capacity by region","scope":"worldwide space insurance market 2026, Dubai","value":"9","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of capacity","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-insurance-market-update-q1-2026","locator":"Gallagher Q1 2026, chart \"Capacity by region\" (chart data in page source)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Shares sum to 100 across UK, Europe, USA, Dubai, Asia. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0801","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of space insurance capacity by region","scope":"worldwide space insurance market 2026, Asia","value":"4","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of capacity","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://specialty.ajg.com/plane-talking/space-insurance-market-update-q1-2026","locator":"Gallagher Q1 2026, chart \"Capacity by region\" (chart data in page source)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Shares sum to 100 across UK, Europe, USA, Dubai, Asia. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0802","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space economy size","scope":"world (Space Foundation)","value":"686","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.spacefoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/SF-GSE-REPORT-2026July-FOR-RELEASE.pdf","locator":"Space Foundation Global Space Economy Report Jul 2026, printed p.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"+12% y/y; 5-yr CAGR 9.8%; 2021 gain 15.5%. Space Foundation definition: commercial space products and services + commercial infrastructure and support industries (incl. GNSS devices, ground equipment) + 53 government space budgets. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0803","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space economy, commercial revenue","scope":"world (Space Foundation)","value":"544.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.spacefoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/SF-GSE-REPORT-2026July-FOR-RELEASE.pdf","locator":"Space Foundation Jul 2026, printed p.2-3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"79% of total; 2024 revised 481.5. PNT + ground equipment 419.8. Commercial space products and services 385.9; infrastructure and support 158.3. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0804","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space economy, commercial revenue","scope":"world (Space Foundation), revised","value":"481.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2024)","year":"2024","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.spacefoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/SF-GSE-REPORT-2026July-FOR-RELEASE.pdf","locator":"Space Foundation Jul 2026, printed p.2-3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"Revised 2024 figure; with government 131 gives ~612.5 (2025 report had 613 for 2024). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0805","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space economy size","scope":"world (Space Foundation)","value":"344","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2015)","year":"2015","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.spacefoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/SF-GSE-REPORT-2026July-FOR-RELEASE.pdf","locator":"Space Foundation Jul 2026, printed p.1, chart \"Global Space Activity, 2005-2025\" data label","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"Space Foundation definition: commercial space products and services + commercial infrastructure and support industries (incl. GNSS devices, ground equipment) + 53 government space budgets. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0806","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space economy size","scope":"world (Space Foundation)","value":"177","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2005)","year":"2005","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.spacefoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/SF-GSE-REPORT-2026July-FOR-RELEASE.pdf","locator":"Space Foundation Jul 2026, printed p.1, chart data label","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"Start of Space Foundation series. Space Foundation definition: commercial space products and services + commercial infrastructure and support industries (incl. GNSS devices, ground equipment) + 53 government space budgets. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0807","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space economy size","scope":"world (SIA/BryceTech)","value":"415","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2024)","year":"2024","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://sia.org/historic-number-of-launches-powers-commercial-satellite-industry-growth-satellite-industry-association-releases-the-28th-annual-state-of-the-satellite-industry-report/","locator":"SIA 28th State of the Satellite Industry release, body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"Satellite industry 293 (71%); manufacturing 20, launch 9.3, services 108.3, ground 155.3. SIA/BryceTech definition: commercial satellite industry (manufacturing, launch, satellite services, ground equipment incl. GNSS) plus government space budgets and commercial human spaceflight. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0808","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space economy size","scope":"world (SIA/BryceTech)","value":"429","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://sia.org/affordability-productivity-drive-historic-satellite-industry-growth-satellite-industry-association-releases-29th-annual-state-of-the-satellite-industry-report/","locator":"SIA 29th State of the Satellite Industry release (13 May 2026), body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"+3%; satellite industry 303 (71%); launch 12.4, manufacturing 20.4, services 105.0, ground 165.2. Differs from Space Foundation 686 by definition, not a conflict. SIA/BryceTech definition: commercial satellite industry (manufacturing, launch, satellite services, ground equipment incl. GNSS) plus government space budgets and commercial human spaceflight. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0809","domain":"economics","parameter":"commercial satellite industry revenue","scope":"world (SIA/BryceTech)","value":"303","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://sia.org/affordability-productivity-drive-historic-satellite-industry-growth-satellite-industry-association-releases-29th-annual-state-of-the-satellite-industry-report/","locator":"SIA 29th release, body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"2024: 293. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0810","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space economy size","scope":"world (WEF/McKinsey)","value":"630","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (2023)","year":"2023","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Space_2024.pdf","locator":"WEF Space: The $1.8 Trillion Opportunity (Apr 2024), p.3-4 and p.9 Fig. 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"Backbone (space hardware and services) 330 + reach (revenues of non-space firms enabled by space, e.g. ride-hailing, delivery) 300. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0811","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space economy size, projection","scope":"world (WEF/McKinsey), base case","value":"1790","low":"1400","high":"2300","unit":"USD billion (constant 2023 USD, inflation assumed 3%/yr)","year":"2035","method":"model","source_url":"https://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_Space_2024.pdf","locator":"WEF Apr 2024, p.9 Fig. 2; p.5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"9%/yr 2023-35; backbone 755, reach 1,035; 2030: 1,160. Low case 1.4 trillion, upside 2.3 trillion. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0812","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space industry size","scope":"world (Morgan Stanley, SIA base)","value":"350","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2016)","year":"2016","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.morganstanley.com/ideas/investing-in-space","locator":"morganstanley.com/ideas/investing-in-space, chart \"The Space Economy's Next Giant Leap\"","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"roughly $350 billion global space industry; chart base year 2016, source SIA. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0813","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space industry size, projection","scope":"world (Morgan Stanley)","value":"1000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal)","year":"2040","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.morganstanley.com/ideas/investing-in-space","locator":"morganstanley.com/ideas/investing-in-space, chart","verification":"page-checked","bias":"investor","status":"ok","note":"could surge to over $1 trillion by 2040 (lower bound). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0814","domain":"economics","parameter":"global government space spending","scope":"world, 53 budgets (Space Foundation)","value":"141","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.spacefoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/SF-GSE-REPORT-2026July-FOR-RELEASE.pdf","locator":"Space Foundation Jul 2026, printed p.37","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"+7.4% from 131 in 2024; top five = 122.4 (87%); smaller budgets 18.4. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0815","domain":"economics","parameter":"government space spending","scope":"United States (Space Foundation)","value":"78.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.spacefoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/SF-GSE-REPORT-2026July-FOR-RELEASE.pdf","locator":"Space Foundation Jul 2026, printed p.1 and p.37","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"57% of world government spending; +1.4%. Civil + national security. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0816","domain":"economics","parameter":"government space spending (estimate)","scope":"China (Space Foundation)","value":"19","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.spacefoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/SF-GSE-REPORT-2026July-FOR-RELEASE.pdf","locator":"Space Foundation Jul 2026, printed p.32 and p.37","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"+10.3% from 2024; \"about 0.25% of its gross domestic product\"; military-civil overlap and opacity make it an estimate. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0817","domain":"economics","parameter":"government space spending","scope":"Europe: EU + ESA + EUMETSAT + national programmes (Space Foundation)","value":"15.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.spacefoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/SF-GSE-REPORT-2026July-FOR-RELEASE.pdf","locator":"Space Foundation Jul 2026, printed p.37","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"Japan 5.5, Russia 3.9 (pie chart p.37). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0818","domain":"economics","parameter":"global government space spending","scope":"world (Novaspace, ex-Euroconsult)","value":"135","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2024)","year":"2024","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.advanced-television.com/?p=255989","locator":"Advanced Television / APDR articles on Novaspace Government Space Programs 2024 (24th ed.)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"+10% vs 2023; defence USD 73bn (54%); US share fell from >75% (2000) to 59% (2024); projects ~1%/yr growth to 2030. Space Foundation 2024: 131. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0819","domain":"economics","parameter":"global government space spending","scope":"world (Euroconsult)","value":"117","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2023)","year":"2023","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://spaceq.ca/defence-expenditures-again-drive-record-government-spending-in-space/","locator":"SpaceQ article on Euroconsult GSP 2023 report","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"+15% vs 2022; US >USD 73bn (63% share). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0820","domain":"economics","parameter":"government space budgets, OECD countries","scope":"OECD members (OECD)","value":"75","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (nominal 2022)","year":"2022","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/the-space-economy-in-figures_fa5494aa-en.html","locator":"The Space Economy in Figures (2023), search snippet","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"about 0.1% of OECD GDP, conservative, civil + military where available; OECD pages returned 403, not opened. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0821","domain":"economics","parameter":"NASA total budget authority","scope":"NASA, FY2021","value":"23271","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2021","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/2026-06-22_R43419_6dcc6ad79653fc081e8f8c8adb354071ad7930dc.pdf","locator":"CRS R43419 (2026-06-22), Table 1, p.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Includes regular, supplemental and additional appropriations, rescissions, transfers. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0822","domain":"economics","parameter":"NASA total budget authority","scope":"NASA, FY2022","value":"24041","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2022","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/2026-06-22_R43419_6dcc6ad79653fc081e8f8c8adb354071ad7930dc.pdf","locator":"CRS R43419 (2026-06-22), Table 1, p.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Includes regular, supplemental and additional appropriations, rescissions, transfers. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0823","domain":"economics","parameter":"NASA total budget authority","scope":"NASA, FY2023","value":"25384","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2023","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/2026-06-22_R43419_6dcc6ad79653fc081e8f8c8adb354071ad7930dc.pdf","locator":"CRS R43419 (2026-06-22), Table 1, p.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Includes regular, supplemental and additional appropriations, rescissions, transfers. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0824","domain":"economics","parameter":"NASA total budget authority","scope":"NASA, FY2024","value":"24877","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/2026-06-22_R43419_6dcc6ad79653fc081e8f8c8adb354071ad7930dc.pdf","locator":"CRS R43419 (2026-06-22), Table 1, p.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Includes regular, supplemental and additional appropriations, rescissions, transfers. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0825","domain":"economics","parameter":"NASA total budget authority","scope":"NASA, FY2025","value":"25382","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/2026-06-22_R43419_6dcc6ad79653fc081e8f8c8adb354071ad7930dc.pdf","locator":"CRS R43419 (2026-06-22), Table 1, p.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Includes regular, supplemental and additional appropriations, rescissions, transfers. Includes USD 575M from P.L. 119-21; NASA tech supplement gives 24,838.3 enacted before P.L. 119-21. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0826","domain":"economics","parameter":"NASA total budget authority","scope":"NASA, FY2026","value":"28448","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/2026-06-22_R43419_6dcc6ad79653fc081e8f8c8adb354071ad7930dc.pdf","locator":"CRS R43419 (2026-06-22), Table 1, p.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Includes regular, supplemental and additional appropriations, rescissions, transfers. Includes ~USD 4bn of FY2025 P.L. 119-21 money budgeted in FY2026; regular FY2026 enacted appropriation 24,438 (CRS Table 2). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0827","domain":"economics","parameter":"NASA budget request","scope":"NASA, FY2027 President's request","value":"18829","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2027","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/2026-06-22_R43419_6dcc6ad79653fc081e8f8c8adb354071ad7930dc.pdf","locator":"CRS R43419 (2026-06-22), Table 2, p.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"vs FY2026 enacted 24,438; House committee 24,438; Senate committee authorisation 25,287. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0828","domain":"economics","parameter":"NASA budget request","scope":"NASA, FY2026 President's request","value":"18809.1","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million (nominal)","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/fy-2026-budget-technical-supplement-002.pdf","locator":"NASA FY2026 Budget Technical Supplement, PDF p.2 table","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Flat 18,809.1 through FY2030 in the request; Congress enacted 24,438 regular appropriation. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0829","domain":"economics","parameter":"ESA annual budget","scope":"European Space Agency","value":"8.26","low":"","high":"","unit":"EUR billion (nominal 2026)","year":"2026","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.key4biz.it/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/DGAnnualPressBriefing2026_slides.pdf","locator":"ESA DG Annual Press Briefing 2026 slides, PDF p.23","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"ESA activities and programmes 5.56; +7.6% y/y; two-thirds from member states, EU 23.4% (Advanced Television 2026-01-12). Earth observation 2,439 M EUR, navigation 1,207 M EUR (p.24). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0830","domain":"economics","parameter":"ESA annual budget","scope":"European Space Agency","value":"7.68","low":"","high":"","unit":"EUR billion (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://www.advanced-television.com/2026/01/12/esa-2026-budget-rises-7-6","locator":"8.26 / 1.076","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Back-calculated from 2026 budget and +7.6%; matches the 7.68 reported for 2025; preliminary Dec 2024 figure 7.7 (European Spaceflight). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0831","domain":"economics","parameter":"ESA annual budget","scope":"European Space Agency","value":"7.79","low":"","high":"","unit":"EUR billion (nominal 2024)","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://europeanspaceflight.com/esa-council-approves-initial-e7-7b-2025-budget","locator":"European Spaceflight article (Dec 2024) body","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2025 preliminary: 4.8 member states, ~1.7 EU, 1.2 other. 2024 largest member contributions: Germany 1.17, France 1.05, Italy 0.881 (EUR bn). [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0832","domain":"economics","parameter":"ESA three-year budget envelope","scope":"European Space Agency, 2026-2028 (CM25)","value":"22.3","low":"22.07","high":"22.3","unit":"EUR billion (nominal)","year":"2026","method":"target","source_url":"https://www.advanced-television.com/2026/01/12/esa-2026-budget-rises-7-6","locator":"Advanced Television 2026-01-12 body; ESA slides PDF p.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"+31% vs previous 3-year period, +17% after inflation (ESA statement). Other reports give 22.07-22.1. [batch finance_insurance_round2]"},{"id":"P0833","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific development cost of lunar ISRU capital","scope":"Kornuta et al. 2019 (tent sublimation)","value":"90.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) thousand/kg of hardware","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1 (read from rendered table image)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"confirms P0346; Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study K, normalised to 2022 USD; dev includes RLL fabrication prorated from B (fn 5); fab approximated (fn 5,6); buildup not given, estimated by Metzger (fn 8)"},{"id":"P0834","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific fabrication cost of lunar ISRU capital","scope":"Kornuta et al. 2019 (tent sublimation)","value":"22.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) thousand/kg of hardware","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study K, normalised to 2022 USD; dev includes RLL fabrication prorated from B (fn 5); fab approximated (fn 5,6); buildup not given, estimated by Metzger (fn 8)"},{"id":"P0835","domain":"technology","parameter":"mass of lunar-surface ISRU capital (plant)","scope":"Kornuta et al. 2019 (tent sublimation)","value":"30","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study K, normalised to 2022 USD; dev includes RLL fabrication prorated from B (fn 5); fab approximated (fn 5,6); buildup not given, estimated by Metzger (fn 8); lifetime 10 y, output 1640 t/yr at LS"},{"id":"P0836","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual operations cost of lunar ISRU plant","scope":"Kornuta et al. 2019 (tent sublimation)","value":"23.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) million/yr","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study K, normalised to 2022 USD; dev includes RLL fabrication prorated from B (fn 5); fab approximated (fn 5,6); buildup not given, estimated by Metzger (fn 8)"},{"id":"P0837","domain":"technology","parameter":"operational life of lunar ISRU plant","scope":"Kornuta et al. 2019 (tent sublimation)","value":"10","low":"","high":"","unit":"years","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study K, normalised to 2022 USD; dev includes RLL fabrication prorated from B (fn 5); fab approximated (fn 5,6); buildup not given, estimated by Metzger (fn 8)"},{"id":"P0838","domain":"technology","parameter":"yearly propellant output at lunar surface","scope":"Kornuta et al. 2019 (tent sublimation)","value":"1640","low":"","high":"","unit":"t/yr","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study K, normalised to 2022 USD; dev includes RLL fabrication prorated from B (fn 5); fab approximated (fn 5,6); buildup not given, estimated by Metzger (fn 8); plant mass 30 t, buildup 5 y"},{"id":"P0839","domain":"technology","parameter":"plant mass productivity (annual output / LS capital mass)","scope":"Kornuta et al. 2019 (tent sublimation)","value":"54.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant per kg plant per yr","year":"2023","method":"derived","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1; yearly product / mass of LS capital","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 1640 t/yr / 30 t from the Table A-1 rows for study K; excludes space segment (RLL/OTV) mass; compare lifetime phi in P0334-P0342"},{"id":"P0840","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific development cost of lunar ISRU capital","scope":"Sowers (tent sublimation)","value":"50.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) thousand/kg of hardware","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study S, normalised to 2022 USD; fab assumes $1,684M/kg from Global Security AMCM tool (fn 7)"},{"id":"P0841","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific fabrication cost of lunar ISRU capital","scope":"Sowers (tent sublimation)","value":"41.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) thousand/kg of hardware","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study S, normalised to 2022 USD; fab assumes $1,684M/kg from Global Security AMCM tool (fn 7)"},{"id":"P0842","domain":"technology","parameter":"mass of lunar-surface ISRU capital (plant)","scope":"Sowers (tent sublimation)","value":"17.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study S, normalised to 2022 USD; fab assumes $1,684M/kg from Global Security AMCM tool (fn 7); lifetime 10 y, output 1100 t/yr at LS"},{"id":"P0843","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual operations cost of lunar ISRU plant","scope":"Sowers (tent sublimation)","value":"78.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) million/yr","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study S, normalised to 2022 USD; fab assumes $1,684M/kg from Global Security AMCM tool (fn 7)"},{"id":"P0844","domain":"technology","parameter":"operational life of lunar ISRU plant","scope":"Sowers (tent sublimation)","value":"10","low":"","high":"","unit":"years","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study S, normalised to 2022 USD; fab assumes $1,684M/kg from Global Security AMCM tool (fn 7)"},{"id":"P0845","domain":"technology","parameter":"yearly propellant output at lunar surface","scope":"Sowers (tent sublimation)","value":"1100","low":"","high":"","unit":"t/yr","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study S, normalised to 2022 USD; fab assumes $1,684M/kg from Global Security AMCM tool (fn 7); plant mass 17.6 t, buildup 5.5 y"},{"id":"P0846","domain":"technology","parameter":"plant mass productivity (annual output / LS capital mass)","scope":"Sowers (tent sublimation)","value":"62.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant per kg plant per yr","year":"2023","method":"derived","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1; yearly product / mass of LS capital","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 1100 t/yr / 17.6 t from the Table A-1 rows for study S; excludes space segment (RLL/OTV) mass; compare lifetime phi in P0334-P0342"},{"id":"P0847","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific development cost of lunar ISRU capital","scope":"Charania & DePascuale 2007 (strip mine then sublimation)","value":"149.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) thousand/kg of hardware","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study CD, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab split assumes 80% of hardware cost is development, 20% fabrication (fn 4); CD assumed 1% ice"},{"id":"P0848","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific fabrication cost of lunar ISRU capital","scope":"Charania & DePascuale 2007 (strip mine then sublimation)","value":"60.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) thousand/kg of hardware","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study CD, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab split assumes 80% of hardware cost is development, 20% fabrication (fn 4); CD assumed 1% ice"},{"id":"P0849","domain":"technology","parameter":"mass of lunar-surface ISRU capital (plant)","scope":"Charania & DePascuale 2007 (strip mine then sublimation)","value":"20.94","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study CD, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab split assumes 80% of hardware cost is development, 20% fabrication (fn 4); CD assumed 1% ice; lifetime 10 y, output 69.1 t/yr at LS"},{"id":"P0850","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual operations cost of lunar ISRU plant","scope":"Charania & DePascuale 2007 (strip mine then sublimation)","value":"53.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) million/yr","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study CD, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab split assumes 80% of hardware cost is development, 20% fabrication (fn 4); CD assumed 1% ice"},{"id":"P0851","domain":"technology","parameter":"operational life of lunar ISRU plant","scope":"Charania & DePascuale 2007 (strip mine then sublimation)","value":"10","low":"","high":"","unit":"years","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study CD, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab split assumes 80% of hardware cost is development, 20% fabrication (fn 4); CD assumed 1% ice"},{"id":"P0852","domain":"technology","parameter":"yearly propellant output at lunar surface","scope":"Charania & DePascuale 2007 (strip mine then sublimation)","value":"69.1","low":"","high":"","unit":"t/yr","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study CD, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab split assumes 80% of hardware cost is development, 20% fabrication (fn 4); CD assumed 1% ice; plant mass 20.94 t, buildup 8 y"},{"id":"P0853","domain":"technology","parameter":"plant mass productivity (annual output / LS capital mass)","scope":"Charania & DePascuale 2007 (strip mine then sublimation)","value":"3.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant per kg plant per yr","year":"2023","method":"derived","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1; yearly product / mass of LS capital","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 69.1 t/yr / 20.94 t from the Table A-1 rows for study CD; excludes space segment (RLL/OTV) mass; compare lifetime phi in P0334-P0342"},{"id":"P0854","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific development cost of lunar ISRU capital","scope":"Jones et al. 2019 (strip mine then sublimation, MRE analogy)","value":"122","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) thousand/kg of hardware","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study J, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab approximated, not given by J, estimated by Metzger (fn 6,8); ops not given, K prorated by capital mass (fn 10)"},{"id":"P0855","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific fabrication cost of lunar ISRU capital","scope":"Jones et al. 2019 (strip mine then sublimation, MRE analogy)","value":"30.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) thousand/kg of hardware","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study J, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab approximated, not given by J, estimated by Metzger (fn 6,8); ops not given, K prorated by capital mass (fn 10)"},{"id":"P0856","domain":"technology","parameter":"mass of lunar-surface ISRU capital (plant)","scope":"Jones et al. 2019 (strip mine then sublimation, MRE analogy)","value":"214.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study J, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab approximated, not given by J, estimated by Metzger (fn 6,8); ops not given, K prorated by capital mass (fn 10); lifetime 14 y, output 393.33 t/yr at LS"},{"id":"P0857","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual operations cost of lunar ISRU plant","scope":"Jones et al. 2019 (strip mine then sublimation, MRE analogy)","value":"158.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) million/yr","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study J, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab approximated, not given by J, estimated by Metzger (fn 6,8); ops not given, K prorated by capital mass (fn 10)"},{"id":"P0858","domain":"technology","parameter":"operational life of lunar ISRU plant","scope":"Jones et al. 2019 (strip mine then sublimation, MRE analogy)","value":"14","low":"","high":"","unit":"years","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study J, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab approximated, not given by J, estimated by Metzger (fn 6,8); ops not given, K prorated by capital mass (fn 10)"},{"id":"P0859","domain":"technology","parameter":"yearly propellant output at lunar surface","scope":"Jones et al. 2019 (strip mine then sublimation, MRE analogy)","value":"393.33","low":"","high":"","unit":"t/yr","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study J, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab approximated, not given by J, estimated by Metzger (fn 6,8); ops not given, K prorated by capital mass (fn 10); plant mass 214.8 t, buildup 5 y"},{"id":"P0860","domain":"technology","parameter":"plant mass productivity (annual output / LS capital mass)","scope":"Jones et al. 2019 (strip mine then sublimation, MRE analogy)","value":"1.83","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant per kg plant per yr","year":"2023","method":"derived","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1; yearly product / mass of LS capital","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 393.33 t/yr / 214.8 t from the Table A-1 rows for study J; excludes space segment (RLL/OTV) mass; compare lifetime phi in P0334-P0342"},{"id":"P0861","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific development cost of lunar ISRU capital","scope":"Bennett et al. (Jones redesign, strip mine then sublimation)","value":"191","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) thousand/kg of hardware","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study B, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab approximated (fn 6); ops not given, K prorated by capital mass (fn 10); 190 t/yr is capacity, demand given as 166.44 t/yr (fn 11)"},{"id":"P0862","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific fabrication cost of lunar ISRU capital","scope":"Bennett et al. (Jones redesign, strip mine then sublimation)","value":"47.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) thousand/kg of hardware","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study B, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab approximated (fn 6); ops not given, K prorated by capital mass (fn 10); 190 t/yr is capacity, demand given as 166.44 t/yr (fn 11)"},{"id":"P0863","domain":"technology","parameter":"mass of lunar-surface ISRU capital (plant)","scope":"Bennett et al. (Jones redesign, strip mine then sublimation)","value":"26.84","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study B, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab approximated (fn 6); ops not given, K prorated by capital mass (fn 10); 190 t/yr is capacity, demand given as 166.44 t/yr (fn 11); lifetime 10 y, output 190 t/yr at LS"},{"id":"P0864","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual operations cost of lunar ISRU plant","scope":"Bennett et al. (Jones redesign, strip mine then sublimation)","value":"20.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) million/yr","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study B, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab approximated (fn 6); ops not given, K prorated by capital mass (fn 10); 190 t/yr is capacity, demand given as 166.44 t/yr (fn 11)"},{"id":"P0865","domain":"technology","parameter":"operational life of lunar ISRU plant","scope":"Bennett et al. (Jones redesign, strip mine then sublimation)","value":"10","low":"","high":"","unit":"years","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study B, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab approximated (fn 6); ops not given, K prorated by capital mass (fn 10); 190 t/yr is capacity, demand given as 166.44 t/yr (fn 11)"},{"id":"P0866","domain":"technology","parameter":"yearly propellant output at lunar surface","scope":"Bennett et al. (Jones redesign, strip mine then sublimation)","value":"190","low":"","high":"","unit":"t/yr","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study B, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab approximated (fn 6); ops not given, K prorated by capital mass (fn 10); 190 t/yr is capacity, demand given as 166.44 t/yr (fn 11); plant mass 26.84 t, buildup 5 y"},{"id":"P0867","domain":"technology","parameter":"plant mass productivity (annual output / LS capital mass)","scope":"Bennett et al. (Jones redesign, strip mine then sublimation)","value":"7.08","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant per kg plant per yr","year":"2023","method":"derived","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1; yearly product / mass of LS capital","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 190 t/yr / 26.84 t from the Table A-1 rows for study B; excludes space segment (RLL/OTV) mass; compare lifetime phi in P0334-P0342"},{"id":"P0868","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific development cost of lunar ISRU capital","scope":"Metzger et al. (strip mine, beneficiate; minimum viable product)","value":"117","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) thousand/kg of hardware","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study M, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab not given, estimated by Metzger for much smaller system (fn 6,9)"},{"id":"P0869","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific fabrication cost of lunar ISRU capital","scope":"Metzger et al. (strip mine, beneficiate; minimum viable product)","value":"29.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) thousand/kg of hardware","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study M, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab not given, estimated by Metzger for much smaller system (fn 6,9)"},{"id":"P0870","domain":"technology","parameter":"mass of lunar-surface ISRU capital (plant)","scope":"Metzger et al. (strip mine, beneficiate; minimum viable product)","value":"2.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study M, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab not given, estimated by Metzger for much smaller system (fn 6,9); lifetime 5 y, output 27.9 t/yr at LS"},{"id":"P0871","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual operations cost of lunar ISRU plant","scope":"Metzger et al. (strip mine, beneficiate; minimum viable product)","value":"10.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) million/yr","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study M, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab not given, estimated by Metzger for much smaller system (fn 6,9)"},{"id":"P0872","domain":"technology","parameter":"operational life of lunar ISRU plant","scope":"Metzger et al. (strip mine, beneficiate; minimum viable product)","value":"5","low":"","high":"","unit":"years","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study M, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab not given, estimated by Metzger for much smaller system (fn 6,9)"},{"id":"P0873","domain":"technology","parameter":"yearly propellant output at lunar surface","scope":"Metzger et al. (strip mine, beneficiate; minimum viable product)","value":"27.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"t/yr","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Metzger 2023 re-tabulation of study M, normalised to 2022 USD; dev/fab not given, estimated by Metzger for much smaller system (fn 6,9); plant mass 2.5 t, buildup 3 y"},{"id":"P0874","domain":"technology","parameter":"plant mass productivity (annual output / LS capital mass)","scope":"Metzger et al. (strip mine, beneficiate; minimum viable product)","value":"11.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant per kg plant per yr","year":"2023","method":"derived","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1; yearly product / mass of LS capital","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 27.9 t/yr / 2.5 t from the Table A-1 rows for study M; excludes space segment (RLL/OTV) mass; compare lifetime phi in P0334-P0342"},{"id":"P0875","domain":"technology","parameter":"mass of lunar-surface ISRU capital (plant)","scope":"Metzger 2023 baseline model","value":"25","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"baseline chosen mid-range among extant TEAs; space segment 5 t, capacity 35 t, IMF 0.10"},{"id":"P0876","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual operations cost of lunar ISRU plant","scope":"Metzger 2023 baseline model","value":"50","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2022) million/yr","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"baseline; 2022 USD"},{"id":"P0877","domain":"technology","parameter":"yearly propellant output at lunar surface","scope":"Metzger 2023 baseline model","value":"500","low":"","high":"","unit":"t/yr","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"baseline; operational life 10 y, buildup 5 y"},{"id":"P0878","domain":"technology","parameter":"plant mass productivity (annual output / LS capital mass)","scope":"Metzger 2023 baseline model","value":"20","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant per kg plant per yr","year":"2023","method":"derived","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.50, Table A-1; 500 t/yr / 25 t","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived from Table A-1 baseline column; excludes space segment"},{"id":"P0879","domain":"economics","parameter":"years of operation until lunar propellant gains absolute advantage over Earth-launched","scope":"lunar propellant delivered to LEO (Metzger 2023 baseline)","value":"19","low":"19","high":"23","unit":"years","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.26, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"optimistic market 19 y, moderate (10% market) 21 y, pessimistic (1% market) 23 y; baseline technology, SEP delivery"},{"id":"P0880","domain":"economics","parameter":"years of operation until lunar propellant gains absolute advantage over Earth-launched","scope":"lunar propellant delivered to GTO (Metzger 2023 baseline)","value":"6","low":"6","high":"7","unit":"years","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.26, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"optimistic market 6 y, moderate (10% market) 7 y, pessimistic (1% market) 7 y; baseline technology, SEP delivery"},{"id":"P0881","domain":"economics","parameter":"years of operation until lunar propellant gains absolute advantage over Earth-launched","scope":"lunar propellant delivered to DRO (Metzger 2023 baseline)","value":"3","low":"3","high":"3","unit":"years","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.26, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"optimistic market 3 y, moderate (10% market) 3 y, pessimistic (1% market) 3 y; baseline technology, SEP delivery"},{"id":"P0882","domain":"economics","parameter":"years of operation until lunar propellant gains absolute advantage over Earth-launched","scope":"lunar propellant delivered to GEO (Metzger 2023 baseline)","value":"2","low":"2","high":"2","unit":"years","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.26, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"optimistic market 2 y, moderate (10% market) 2 y, pessimistic (1% market) 2 y; baseline technology, SEP delivery"},{"id":"P0883","domain":"economics","parameter":"years of operation until lunar propellant gains absolute advantage over Earth-launched","scope":"lunar propellant delivered to EML1 (Metzger 2023 baseline)","value":"1","low":"1","high":"1","unit":"years","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.26, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"optimistic market 1 y, moderate (10% market) 1 y, pessimistic (1% market) 1 y; baseline technology, SEP delivery"},{"id":"P0884","domain":"economics","parameter":"reduction of year-1 lunar-surface propellant cost from commercial capital launch (G 64.9 to 8)","scope":"Charania & DePascuale study re-run by Metzger 2023 (curve 3)","value":"59","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.29, sec. 6.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Curve (3) also adds 5% ice yield (curve 2), reliability optimisation and SEP; reaches DRO advantage year 15, GTO year 18"},{"id":"P0885","domain":"economics","parameter":"years until lunar propellant gains absolute advantage in GTO, CD study with PPP","scope":"Charania & DePascuale re-run (curve 5), 12% discount rate","value":"8","low":"8","high":"13","unit":"years","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.30, sec. 6.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"at commercial 27.2% discount rate with 50% government-paid development and 4-y buildup: year 13 (p.30)"},{"id":"P0886","domain":"economics","parameter":"years until lunar propellant gains absolute advantage in GTO, Jones/Bennett re-run","scope":"Jones et al. and Bennett et al. re-run with baseline capital transport, SEP, finance and ops costs","value":"20","low":"","high":"","unit":"years","year":"2023","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.31, sec. 6.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"DRO advantage not until year 16; competitive at LS from start"},{"id":"P0887","domain":"technology","parameter":"lunar ice concentration assumed","scope":"Charania & DePascuale 2007 (per Metzger 2023)","value":"1","low":"","high":"","unit":"wt%","year":"2007","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.29, sec. 6.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"pre-LCROSS assumption; Metzger curve 2 raises yield to 5%"},{"id":"P0888","domain":"economics","parameter":"assumed price of water sold in space","scope":"asteroid water mining (Hein et al. 2020)","value":"20000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (dollar year not stated)","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836","locator":"arXiv 1810.03836 PDF p.6, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"breakeven model without interest; 150 kg spacecraft, propellant-less propulsion (solar/electric sail), 100-day mining, dollar year not stated"},{"id":"P0889","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific spacecraft production cost, conservative (SMAD, Calla et al.)","scope":"asteroid mining spacecraft (Hein et al. 2020)","value":"1000000","low":"10000","high":"1000000","unit":"USD/kg spacecraft (dollar year not stated)","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836","locator":"arXiv 1810.03836 PDF p.6, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"optimistic (mass production, OneWeb-like) 10,000 USD/kg; same in Table 2"},{"id":"P0890","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific spacecraft development cost, conservative","scope":"asteroid mining spacecraft (Hein et al. 2020)","value":"5453333","low":"500000","high":"5453333","unit":"USD/kg spacecraft (dollar year not stated)","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836","locator":"arXiv 1810.03836 PDF p.6, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"optimistic 500,000 USD/kg"},{"id":"P0891","domain":"economics","parameter":"specific transportation cost to/from asteroid","scope":"asteroid mining (Hein et al. 2020)","value":"35000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (dollar year not stated)","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836","locator":"arXiv 1810.03836 PDF p.6, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"same in both scenarios; platinum case doubles launch cost for Earth return"},{"id":"P0892","domain":"economics","parameter":"operations cost per mission, conservative","scope":"asteroid mining (Hein et al. 2020)","value":"5.7","low":"0.1","high":"5.7","unit":"USD million (dollar year not stated)","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836","locator":"arXiv 1810.03836 PDF p.6, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"optimistic 0.1 M USD"},{"id":"P0893","domain":"technology","parameter":"throughput rate needed for reasonable breakeven, water","scope":"C-type asteroid water mining (Hein et al. 2020)","value":"0.00023","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg processed per s per kg spacecraft","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836","locator":"arXiv 1810.03836 PDF p.6, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"5% water yield of processed material; 100 days mining"},{"id":"P0894","domain":"economics","parameter":"profit per venture, water mining","scope":"asteroid water mining (Hein et al. 2020), conservative","value":"139","low":"139","high":"293","unit":"USD million (dollar year not stated)","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836","locator":"arXiv 1810.03836 PDF p.6, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"optimistic 293 M USD"},{"id":"P0895","domain":"economics","parameter":"years to breakeven, water mining","scope":"asteroid water mining (Hein et al. 2020), conservative","value":"5.9","low":"0.26","high":"5.9","unit":"years","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836","locator":"arXiv 1810.03836 PDF p.6, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"optimistic 0.26 y; no time value of money"},{"id":"P0896","domain":"technology","parameter":"bootstrapping factor (mass delivered / spacecraft mass), water","scope":"asteroid water mining (Hein et al. 2020), conservative","value":"14.3","low":"0.62","high":"14.3","unit":"kg product per kg spacecraft","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836","locator":"arXiv 1810.03836 PDF p.6, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"optimistic column 0.62 (as printed); material processed 42,944 kg vs 1,868 kg"},{"id":"P0897","domain":"economics","parameter":"assumed platinum price","scope":"asteroid platinum mining (Hein et al. 2020)","value":"70000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (dollar year not stated)","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836","locator":"arXiv 1810.03836 PDF p.7-8, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"sensitivity case at 30,000 USD/kg: only 10-spacecraft case breaks even within 10 y (conservative)"},{"id":"P0898","domain":"technology","parameter":"throughput rate needed, platinum","scope":"asteroid platinum mining (Hein et al. 2020)","value":"0.35","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg processed per s per kg spacecraft","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836","locator":"arXiv 1810.03836 PDF p.7-8, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"platinum fraction 1e-5 (Blair); authors call 0.35 very high"},{"id":"P0899","domain":"economics","parameter":"profit per venture, platinum mining","scope":"asteroid platinum mining (Hein et al. 2020), conservative","value":"149","low":"149","high":"303","unit":"USD million (dollar year not stated)","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836","locator":"arXiv 1810.03836 PDF p.7-8, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"optimistic 303 M USD; breakeven 5.5 y conservative, 0.25 y optimistic"},{"id":"P0900","domain":"economics","parameter":"five-year average platinum price used to anchor demand curve","scope":"platinum, world (Hein et al. 2020)","value":"40449","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (nominal)","year":"2018","method":"measured","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836","locator":"arXiv 1810.03836 PDF p.5, sec. 3.3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"paired with global demand 254,582 kg; demand slope range -0.5 to -0.6 assumed; miner borrows at 10%"},{"id":"P0901","domain":"economics","parameter":"discount rate in supply-demand breakeven analysis","scope":"asteroid platinum mining (Hein et al. 2020)","value":"10","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836","locator":"arXiv 1810.03836 PDF p.9, note to Table 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Table 3 (p.10): profitable and breaking even within 30 y only in a slim range of elasticity and terrestrial supply response"},{"id":"P0902","domain":"economics","parameter":"first-unit cost of asteroid water-mining spacecraft (SSCM)","scope":"small-spacecraft NEA water mining (Calla et al.)","value":"113.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2010) million","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1808.05099","locator":"arXiv 1808.05099v2 p.15, Table 6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"swarm of <500 kg spacecraft, 100 kg water delivered per trip, learning slope 0.85, Falcon Heavy 64 t LEO; SSCM CERs in FY10 $K (Tables 4-5, p.14); total first mission 145.7 M + 90 M launch"},{"id":"P0903","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual operations cost","scope":"small-spacecraft NEA water mining (Calla et al.)","value":"5.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million/yr (average)","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1808.05099","locator":"arXiv 1808.05099v2 p.15, Table 6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"swarm of <500 kg spacecraft, 100 kg water delivered per trip, learning slope 0.85, Falcon Heavy 64 t LEO"},{"id":"P0904","domain":"economics","parameter":"assumed value of water delivered (Earth-launch cost)","scope":"water at LEO (Calla et al.)","value":"3000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (dollar year not stated)","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1808.05099","locator":"arXiv 1808.05099v2 p.15, Table 6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"price set equal to cost of launching 1 kg from Earth; GTO from Falcon 9, GSO from Proton-M"},{"id":"P0905","domain":"economics","parameter":"assumed value of water delivered (Earth-launch cost)","scope":"water at GTO (Calla et al.)","value":"7500","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (dollar year not stated)","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1808.05099","locator":"arXiv 1808.05099v2 p.15, Table 6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"price set equal to cost of launching 1 kg from Earth; GTO from Falcon 9, GSO from Proton-M"},{"id":"P0906","domain":"economics","parameter":"assumed value of water delivered (Earth-launch cost)","scope":"water at GSO (Calla et al.)","value":"21500","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (dollar year not stated)","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1808.05099","locator":"arXiv 1808.05099v2 p.15, Table 6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"price set equal to cost of launching 1 kg from Earth; GTO from Falcon 9, GSO from Proton-M"},{"id":"P0907","domain":"economics","parameter":"assumed value of water delivered (Earth-launch cost)","scope":"water at cis-lunar space (Calla et al.)","value":"35000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (dollar year not stated)","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1808.05099","locator":"arXiv 1808.05099v2 p.15, Table 6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"price set equal to cost of launching 1 kg from Earth; GTO from Falcon 9, GSO from Proton-M"},{"id":"P0908","domain":"economics","parameter":"spacecraft fleet needed for break-even within ~10 years","scope":"small-spacecraft NEA water mining, sales in cis-lunar space","value":"200","low":"","high":"","unit":"spacecraft","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1808.05099","locator":"arXiv 1808.05099v2 p.16, sec. 4.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"profit after ~10 y of operation; ~400 spacecraft break even in ~8 y; abstract: >100 spacecraft for >5 y"},{"id":"P0909","domain":"economics","parameter":"up-front investment for 200-spacecraft fleet","scope":"small-spacecraft NEA water mining (Calla et al.)","value":"7","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion (approx., dollar year not stated)","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1808.05099","locator":"arXiv 1808.05099v2 p.17, sec. 5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"swarm of <500 kg spacecraft, 100 kg water delivered per trip, learning slope 0.85, Falcon Heavy 64 t LEO"},{"id":"P0910","domain":"technology","parameter":"energy per kg water extracted, microwave heating","scope":"NEA regolith water extraction (Calla et al.)","value":"2","low":"","high":"","unit":"kWh/kg","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1808.05099","locator":"arXiv 1808.05099v2 p.1 abstract; p.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2 Wh/g assumed efficiency; 250 kg water extracted per mission (150 kg for return propellant)"},{"id":"P0911","domain":"technology","parameter":"spacecraft dry mass","scope":"small-spacecraft NEA water miner (Calla et al.)","value":"372.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1808.05099","locator":"arXiv 1808.05099v2 p.20, App. A","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"delivers 100 kg water per trip; round-trip water propellant ~150 kg"},{"id":"P0912","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per vehicle used in ISRU breakeven","scope":"SLS Block 1B cargo, 40 t to TLI (Jones IAC-19)","value":"1000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2019) million/launch","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200002704/downloads/20200002704.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20200002704 PDF p.3, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"nominal commercial: 200 M USD for 15 t to TLI; implies 25,000 vs 13,333 USD/kg to TLI"},{"id":"P0913","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost per vehicle used in ISRU breakeven","scope":"nominal commercial launcher, 15 t to TLI (Jones IAC-19)","value":"200","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2019) million/launch","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200002704/downloads/20200002704.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20200002704 PDF p.3, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"costs in FY2019 dollars"},{"id":"P0914","domain":"economics","parameter":"propellant demand at lunar surface per crewed mission","scope":"reusable lunar lander, 2 crew (Jones IAC-19)","value":"17.0","low":"8.5","high":"34.0","unit":"t per mission","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200002704/downloads/20200002704.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20200002704 PDF p.9, sec. 5.3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"notional cadences 8.5, 17.0, 34.0 t/yr (one mission per 2 y, 1/y, 2/y)"},{"id":"P0915","domain":"economics","parameter":"time for lunar ISRU to break even with Earth-delivered propellant","scope":"Duke ISRU plant, 3-y lifetime, 17.0 t/yr demand (Jones IAC-19)","value":"2.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"years","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200002704/downloads/20200002704.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20200002704 PDF p.9, Table 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"cumulative-cost breakeven; ISRU technology development to TRL 6 not costed; MREE with 1-y life never breaks even"},{"id":"P0916","domain":"economics","parameter":"time for lunar ISRU to break even with Earth-delivered propellant","scope":"Duke ISRU plant, 1-y lifetime, 17.0 t/yr demand (Jones IAC-19)","value":"6.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"years","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200002704/downloads/20200002704.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20200002704 PDF p.9, Table 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"cumulative-cost breakeven; ISRU technology development to TRL 6 not costed; MREE with 1-y life never breaks even"},{"id":"P0917","domain":"economics","parameter":"time for lunar ISRU to break even with Earth-delivered propellant","scope":"Duke ISRU plant, 3-y lifetime, 34.0 t/yr demand (Jones IAC-19)","value":"1.1","low":"","high":"","unit":"years","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200002704/downloads/20200002704.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20200002704 PDF p.9, Table 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"cumulative-cost breakeven; ISRU technology development to TRL 6 not costed; MREE with 1-y life never breaks even"},{"id":"P0918","domain":"economics","parameter":"time for lunar ISRU to break even with Earth-delivered propellant","scope":"MREE ISRU plant, 3-y lifetime, 17.0 t/yr demand (Jones IAC-19)","value":"2.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"years","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200002704/downloads/20200002704.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20200002704 PDF p.9, Table 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"cumulative-cost breakeven; ISRU technology development to TRL 6 not costed; MREE with 1-y life never breaks even"},{"id":"P0919","domain":"economics","parameter":"time for lunar ISRU to break even with Earth-delivered propellant","scope":"MREE ISRU plant, 5-y lifetime, 8.5 t/yr demand (Jones IAC-19)","value":"4.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"years","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200002704/downloads/20200002704.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20200002704 PDF p.9, Table 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"cumulative-cost breakeven; ISRU technology development to TRL 6 not costed; MREE with 1-y life never breaks even"},{"id":"P0920","domain":"technology","parameter":"ISRU plant specific mass","scope":"lunar ice-to-propellant plant, MREE model (Jones 2020)","value":"1.1101","low":"","high":"","unit":"t plant per t/yr propellant","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205007564/downloads/ISRU-Paper3-Final.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20205007564 PDF p.8, Table 5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"linear scaling; includes acquisition, processing, liquefaction"},{"id":"P0921","domain":"technology","parameter":"ISRU plant specific power","scope":"lunar ice-to-propellant plant, MREE model (Jones 2020)","value":"5.6976","low":"","high":"","unit":"kWe per t/yr propellant","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205007564/downloads/ISRU-Paper3-Final.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20205007564 PDF p.8, Table 5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"fission surface power assumed"},{"id":"P0922","domain":"technology","parameter":"plant mass productivity","scope":"lunar ice-to-propellant plant, MREE model (Jones 2020)","value":"0.901","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant per kg plant per yr","year":"2020","method":"derived","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205007564/downloads/ISRU-Paper3-Final.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20205007564 PDF p.8, Table 5; 1/specific mass","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 1/1.1101"},{"id":"P0923","domain":"technology","parameter":"electric energy per kg propellant (continuous operation)","scope":"lunar ice-to-propellant plant, MREE model (Jones 2020)","value":"49.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"kWh/kg","year":"2020","method":"derived","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205007564/downloads/ISRU-Paper3-Final.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20205007564 PDF p.8, Table 5; specific power x 8,766 h / 1,000 kg","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 5.6976 kWe per t/yr x 8766 h/yr / 1000 kg/t; assumes year-round operation"},{"id":"P0924","domain":"technology","parameter":"ISRU plant specific mass","scope":"lunar ice-to-propellant plant, Duke model (Jones 2020)","value":"0.1331","low":"","high":"","unit":"t plant per t/yr propellant","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205007564/downloads/ISRU-Paper3-Final.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20205007564 PDF p.8, Table 5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"linear scaling; includes acquisition, processing, liquefaction"},{"id":"P0925","domain":"technology","parameter":"ISRU plant specific power","scope":"lunar ice-to-propellant plant, Duke model (Jones 2020)","value":"0.6174","low":"","high":"","unit":"kWe per t/yr propellant","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205007564/downloads/ISRU-Paper3-Final.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20205007564 PDF p.8, Table 5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"fission surface power assumed"},{"id":"P0926","domain":"technology","parameter":"plant mass productivity","scope":"lunar ice-to-propellant plant, Duke model (Jones 2020)","value":"7.51","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg propellant per kg plant per yr","year":"2020","method":"derived","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205007564/downloads/ISRU-Paper3-Final.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20205007564 PDF p.8, Table 5; 1/specific mass","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 1/0.1331"},{"id":"P0927","domain":"technology","parameter":"electric energy per kg propellant (continuous operation)","scope":"lunar ice-to-propellant plant, Duke model (Jones 2020)","value":"5.41","low":"","high":"","unit":"kWh/kg","year":"2020","method":"derived","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205007564/downloads/ISRU-Paper3-Final.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20205007564 PDF p.8, Table 5; specific power x 8,766 h / 1,000 kg","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 0.6174 kWe per t/yr x 8766 h/yr / 1000 kg/t; assumes year-round operation"},{"id":"P0928","domain":"economics","parameter":"lunar surface propellant demand, pre-transition","scope":"NASA lunar campaign canonical case (Jones 2020)","value":"17","low":"8.5","high":"34","unit":"t/yr","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205007564/downloads/ISRU-Paper3-Final.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20205007564 PDF p.6, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"post-transition lunar surface demand 0 t/yr; sensitivity 8.5-34 t/yr"},{"id":"P0929","domain":"economics","parameter":"cislunar propellant demand for Mars campaign, post-transition","scope":"NASA Mars campaign (Jones 2020)","value":"59","low":"47","high":"71","unit":"t/yr","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205007564/downloads/ISRU-Paper3-Final.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20205007564 PDF p.6, Table 1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"for 14 years; sensitivity 47-71 t/yr"},{"id":"P0930","domain":"economics","parameter":"DDT&E cost of 40 kWe fission surface power system","scope":"lunar ISRU power (Jones 2020 CER)","value":"1726","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2019) million","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205007564/downloads/ISRU-Paper3-Final.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20205007564 PDF p.10, Table 7","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"unit cost 265 M USD per 40 kWe unit (C = 265n)"},{"id":"P0931","domain":"economics","parameter":"DDT&E cost of front-end loaders and haulers","scope":"lunar ice ISRU (Jones 2020 CER)","value":"473.73","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2019) million","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205007564/downloads/ISRU-Paper3-Final.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20205007564 PDF p.10, Table 7","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"unit cost 32.27 M USD per unit"},{"id":"P0932","domain":"technology","parameter":"fission surface power specific mass","scope":"40 kWe fission system (Mason), used by Jones 2020","value":"174","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg/kWe","year":"2020","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205007564/downloads/ISRU-Paper3-Final.pdf","locator":"NTRS 20205007564 PDF p.7, sec. V.D","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0933","domain":"technology","parameter":"electrolysis energy per kg water to LOX/LH2","scope":"CLPA lunar propellant plant (Kornuta et al. 2019)","value":"4.41","low":"","high":"","unit":"kWh/kg water","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.58 (printed p.40), Power Requirements","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2,450 t/yr water = 280 kg/h; 1,235 kWe for electrolysis; +765 kWe other loads"},{"id":"P0934","domain":"technology","parameter":"total plant power","scope":"CLPA lunar propellant plant, 2,450 t/yr water","value":"2.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"MW","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.58 (printed p.40)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2 MWe electric + 0.8 MWt thermal (580 kWt at 4 wt% water, rounded up)"},{"id":"P0935","domain":"technology","parameter":"thermal sublimation energy per kg water (continuous)","scope":"CLPA tent sublimation, 4 wt% ice","value":"2.08","low":"","high":"","unit":"kWh(th)/kg water","year":"2019","method":"derived","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.58: 580 kWt for 2,450 t/yr","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 580 kW x 8766 h / 2,450,000 kg; worst case 4 wt% water; assumes year-round operation"},{"id":"P0936","domain":"technology","parameter":"total energy per kg propellant (continuous)","scope":"CLPA lunar propellant plant","value":"54.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"kWh/kg propellant","year":"2019","method":"derived","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.58 (2.8 MW) and p.6 (450 t/yr propellant)","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 2.8 MW x 8766 h / 450,000 kg; total incl. thermal; P0326 gives 450 t/yr propellant"},{"id":"P0937","domain":"economics","parameter":"propellant demand at lunar surface, NASA crewed + cargo","scope":"CLPA customer estimate (Kornuta et al. 2019)","value":"100","low":"","high":"","unit":"t/yr","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.118 (printed p.100)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"two crewed missions x 25 t + one cargo mission x 50 t; landers need 14-50 t each; 150 t/yr water at MR 5.35"},{"id":"P0938","domain":"economics","parameter":"propellant demand at EML1 for Mars Base Camp","scope":"Lockheed Martin Mars Base Camp (CLPA)","value":"140","low":"","high":"","unit":"t/yr","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.119 (printed p.101)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"280 t per mission every 2 y; equals 280 t/yr at lunar surface, 420 t/yr water"},{"id":"P0939","domain":"economics","parameter":"propellant demand in LEO for refuelled upper stages","scope":"ULA-type LEO refuelling, three super-heavy GEO missions/yr (CLPA)","value":"210","low":"","high":"","unit":"t/yr","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.119 (printed p.101)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"1,260 t/yr at lunar surface after transport losses; 1,880 t/yr water"},{"id":"P0940","domain":"economics","parameter":"discount to Earth-delivered price sought by lunar propellant buyers","scope":"CLPA pricing rule, NRHO/EML1 customers","value":"25","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI manuscript PDF p.119 (printed p.101), Propellant Pricing","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"10,000 USD/kg Earth-to-EML1 becomes 7,500 USD/kg lunar; 100 t/yr cycler pays 750 M vs 1 B USD/yr"},{"id":"P0941","domain":"economics","parameter":"propellant demand, commercial ISRU provider max capacity","scope":"Spaceworks SMR case 1A, lunar surface","value":"49.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"t/yr","year":"2007","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI 1503160 PDF p.132 (printed p.114), Table 18","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Spaceworks 2007 (Charania & DePascuale, IAC-07-A5.1.03) reproduced in CLPA; primary not openly accessible; dollar year not stated; case 1B adds 19.7 t/yr excess oxygen"},{"id":"P0942","domain":"economics","parameter":"propellant demand, government reusable lander","scope":"Spaceworks SMR case 2A, LLO","value":"21.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"t/yr","year":"2007","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI 1503160 PDF p.132 (printed p.114), Table 18","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Spaceworks 2007 (Charania & DePascuale, IAC-07-A5.1.03) reproduced in CLPA; primary not openly accessible; dollar year not stated"},{"id":"P0943","domain":"economics","parameter":"propellant demand, commercial satellite tug","scope":"Spaceworks SMR case 3A, GEO","value":"0.45","low":"","high":"","unit":"t/yr","year":"2007","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI 1503160 PDF p.132 (printed p.114), Table 18","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Spaceworks 2007 (Charania & DePascuale, IAC-07-A5.1.03) reproduced in CLPA; primary not openly accessible; dollar year not stated"},{"id":"P0944","domain":"economics","parameter":"breakeven propellant price at WACC 21.7%","scope":"Spaceworks case 1A, propellant on lunar surface","value":"26845","low":"7327","high":"26845","unit":"USD/kg (dollar year not stated)","year":"2007","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI 1503160 PDF p.133 (printed p.115), Table 19","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Spaceworks 2007 (Charania & DePascuale, IAC-07-A5.1.03) reproduced in CLPA; primary not openly accessible; dollar year not stated; cost-only with inflation 7,327 USD/kg"},{"id":"P0945","domain":"economics","parameter":"breakeven propellant price at WACC 21.7%","scope":"Spaceworks case 2A, propellant to LLO","value":"133947","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (dollar year not stated)","year":"2007","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI 1503160 PDF p.133 (printed p.115), Table 19","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Spaceworks 2007 (Charania & DePascuale, IAC-07-A5.1.03) reproduced in CLPA; primary not openly accessible; dollar year not stated; 2B with oxygen sales 126,243 (cost-only 31,056)"},{"id":"P0946","domain":"economics","parameter":"breakeven propellant price at WACC 21.7%","scope":"Spaceworks case 3A, propellant to GEO","value":"7053265","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (dollar year not stated)","year":"2007","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI 1503160 PDF p.133 (printed p.115), Table 19","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Spaceworks 2007 (Charania & DePascuale, IAC-07-A5.1.03) reproduced in CLPA; primary not openly accessible; dollar year not stated; 3C with oxygen and surface sales 1,663,560"},{"id":"P0947","domain":"economics","parameter":"breakeven price of excess oxygen on lunar surface at WACC 21.7%","scope":"Spaceworks case 1B","value":"3196","low":"872","high":"3196","unit":"USD/kg (dollar year not stated)","year":"2007","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1503160","locator":"OSTI 1503160 PDF p.133 (printed p.115), Table 19","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Spaceworks 2007 (Charania & DePascuale, IAC-07-A5.1.03) reproduced in CLPA; primary not openly accessible; dollar year not stated; cost-only with inflation 872 USD/kg"},{"id":"P0948","domain":"economics","parameter":"development cost of lunar propellant plant","scope":"lunar ice mining plant, 30 t (Sommariva/Vittori 2019)","value":"3.0","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://edoardo-v.github.io/downloads/Presentation_2019_SEE_Lab_Mining_the_Moon_for_Profit.pdf","locator":"slide 14","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"SDA Bocconi SEE Lab presentation 2019 (Sommariva group); plant mass from Colorado School of Mines CLPA, 2,450 t/yr water; the 2020 Acta Astronautica paper (Sommariva et al.) reports negative NPV for a purely private model; 100,000 USD/kg x 30,000 kg; transport to Moon 1.08 B (36,000 USD/kg); total 4.08 B"},{"id":"P0949","domain":"economics","parameter":"exploration (prospecting) mission cost","scope":"lunar prospecting, 3 t (Sommariva/Vittori 2019)","value":"408","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://edoardo-v.github.io/downloads/Presentation_2019_SEE_Lab_Mining_the_Moon_for_Profit.pdf","locator":"slide 14","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"SDA Bocconi SEE Lab presentation 2019 (Sommariva group); plant mass from Colorado School of Mines CLPA, 2,450 t/yr water; the 2020 Acta Astronautica paper (Sommariva et al.) reports negative NPV for a purely private model; in line with Resource Prospector"},{"id":"P0950","domain":"economics","parameter":"discount rate used","scope":"lunar propellant venture (Sommariva/Vittori 2019)","value":"16","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://edoardo-v.github.io/downloads/Presentation_2019_SEE_Lab_Mining_the_Moon_for_Profit.pdf","locator":"slide 17","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"SDA Bocconi SEE Lab presentation 2019 (Sommariva group); plant mass from Colorado School of Mines CLPA, 2,450 t/yr water; the 2020 Acta Astronautica paper (Sommariva et al.) reports negative NPV for a purely private model; CAPM with levered mining/oil betas gives 9.1% (slide 21); 21% Luxembourg tax"},{"id":"P0951","domain":"economics","parameter":"probability of non-transferable failure (NO-GO)","scope":"lunar propellant venture (Sommariva/Vittori 2019)","value":"30","low":"","high":"","unit":"%","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://edoardo-v.github.io/downloads/Presentation_2019_SEE_Lab_Mining_the_Moon_for_Profit.pdf","locator":"slide 16","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"SDA Bocconi SEE Lab presentation 2019 (Sommariva group); plant mass from Colorado School of Mines CLPA, 2,450 t/yr water; the 2020 Acta Astronautica paper (Sommariva et al.) reports negative NPV for a purely private model; from oil and gas experience"},{"id":"P0952","domain":"economics","parameter":"NPV if GO, 16 years","scope":"lunar propellant venture (Sommariva/Vittori 2019)","value":"1.48","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD billion","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://edoardo-v.github.io/downloads/Presentation_2019_SEE_Lab_Mining_the_Moon_for_Profit.pdf","locator":"slide 18","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"SDA Bocconi SEE Lab presentation 2019 (Sommariva group); plant mass from Colorado School of Mines CLPA, 2,450 t/yr water; the 2020 Acta Astronautica paper (Sommariva et al.) reports negative NPV for a purely private model; NO-GO NPV -0.436 B; weighted NPV 0.906 B; PI 1.10; revenue 1,640 t x 1,482 USD/kg = 2.43 B/yr"},{"id":"P0953","domain":"economics","parameter":"IRR of lunar propellant venture, 30% NO-GO risk","scope":"lunar propellant venture (Sommariva/Vittori 2019, Monte Carlo)","value":"24","low":"20","high":"31","unit":"% per year","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://edoardo-v.github.io/downloads/Presentation_2019_SEE_Lab_Mining_the_Moon_for_Profit.pdf","locator":"slide 30","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"SDA Bocconi SEE Lab presentation 2019 (Sommariva group); plant mass from Colorado School of Mines CLPA, 2,450 t/yr water; the 2020 Acta Astronautica paper (Sommariva et al.) reports negative NPV for a purely private model; 5th pct 20%, 95th pct 31%; slide 30 shows deterministic weighted NPV 1,000 M vs 906 M on slide 18; sign conflicts with 2020 paper's private case"},{"id":"P0954","domain":"economics","parameter":"revenue per service","scope":"GEO on-orbit refuelling (Sarton du Jonchay et al. 2021)","value":"15","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million per service","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2103.08962","locator":"arXiv 2103.08962 PDF p.25, Table 9","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"GEO on-orbit servicing model assumption; revenues cite ref [7]; dollar year not stated"},{"id":"P0955","domain":"economics","parameter":"revenue per service","scope":"GEO on-orbit inspection (Sarton du Jonchay et al. 2021)","value":"10","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million per service","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2103.08962","locator":"arXiv 2103.08962 PDF p.25, Table 9","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"GEO on-orbit servicing model assumption; revenues cite ref [7]; dollar year not stated"},{"id":"P0956","domain":"economics","parameter":"revenue per service","scope":"GEO on-orbit station keeping (Sarton du Jonchay et al. 2021)","value":"20","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million per service","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2103.08962","locator":"arXiv 2103.08962 PDF p.25, Table 9","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"GEO on-orbit servicing model assumption; revenues cite ref [7]; dollar year not stated"},{"id":"P0957","domain":"economics","parameter":"revenue per service","scope":"GEO on-orbit repair (Sarton du Jonchay et al. 2021)","value":"30","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million per service","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2103.08962","locator":"arXiv 2103.08962 PDF p.25, Table 10","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"assumed; repositioning and retirement 10 M, mechanism deployment 25 M"},{"id":"P0958","domain":"economics","parameter":"orbital depot manufacturing cost","scope":"GEO depot (Sarton du Jonchay et al. 2021)","value":"200","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2103.08962","locator":"arXiv 2103.08962 PDF p.26","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"operating cost 13,000 USD/day; resupplied by Falcon 9 every 30 days, 8,300 kg"},{"id":"P0959","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch cost to resupply GEO depot","scope":"Falcon 9 (Sarton du Jonchay et al. 2021)","value":"11300","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2103.08962","locator":"arXiv 2103.08962 PDF p.26","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"assumed"},{"id":"P0960","domain":"economics","parameter":"commodity price, hydrazine","scope":"monopropellant delivered via GEO depot (Sarton du Jonchay et al. 2021)","value":"230","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2103.08962","locator":"arXiv 2103.08962 PDF p.26","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"ground price tag; MMH 180 USD/kg; spares 1,000 USD/kg"},{"id":"P0961","domain":"economics","parameter":"servicer manufacturing cost","scope":"versatile GEO servicer, 3,000 kg dry (Sarton du Jonchay et al. 2021)","value":"75","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2103.08962","locator":"arXiv 2103.08962 PDF p.26, Table 11","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"specialised 2,000 kg servicers 50 M; ops 13,000 USD/day"},{"id":"P0962","domain":"technology","parameter":"specific energy of ISRU reactor","scope":"soil/water extraction, 3% water (Chen et al. 2021)","value":"13.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"kWh/kg water","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.04265","locator":"arXiv 1910.04265 PDF p.27, Table 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"ISRU sizing model extrapolated from historical design concepts and prototypes (Chen et al. ref [27]); per kg/h of reference product; specific power 13.7 kW per kg/h; specific mass 357 kg per kg/h"},{"id":"P0963","domain":"technology","parameter":"reactor mass productivity","scope":"soil/water extraction, 3% water (Chen et al. 2021)","value":"24.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg product per kg reactor per yr","year":"2021","method":"derived","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.04265","locator":"arXiv 1910.04265 PDF p.27, Table 3; 8,766 h / specific mass","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 8766/357; reactor only, excludes power, excavation, storage; continuous operation"},{"id":"P0964","domain":"technology","parameter":"specific energy of ISRU reactor","scope":"soil/water extraction, 8% water (Chen et al. 2021)","value":"7","low":"","high":"","unit":"kWh/kg water","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.04265","locator":"arXiv 1910.04265 PDF p.27, Table 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"ISRU sizing model extrapolated from historical design concepts and prototypes (Chen et al. ref [27]); per kg/h of reference product; specific power 7 kW per kg/h; specific mass 195 kg per kg/h"},{"id":"P0965","domain":"technology","parameter":"reactor mass productivity","scope":"soil/water extraction, 8% water (Chen et al. 2021)","value":"45","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg product per kg reactor per yr","year":"2021","method":"derived","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.04265","locator":"arXiv 1910.04265 PDF p.27, Table 3; 8,766 h / specific mass","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 8766/195; reactor only, excludes power, excavation, storage; continuous operation"},{"id":"P0966","domain":"technology","parameter":"specific energy of ISRU reactor","scope":"direct water electrolysis (Chen et al. 2021)","value":"5.83","low":"","high":"","unit":"kWh/kg O2","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.04265","locator":"arXiv 1910.04265 PDF p.27, Table 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"ISRU sizing model extrapolated from historical design concepts and prototypes (Chen et al. ref [27]); per kg/h of reference product; specific power 5.83 kW per kg/h; specific mass 83.3 kg per kg/h"},{"id":"P0967","domain":"technology","parameter":"reactor mass productivity","scope":"direct water electrolysis (Chen et al. 2021)","value":"105","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg product per kg reactor per yr","year":"2021","method":"derived","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.04265","locator":"arXiv 1910.04265 PDF p.27, Table 3; 8,766 h / specific mass","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 8766/83.3; reactor only, excludes power, excavation, storage; continuous operation"},{"id":"P0968","domain":"technology","parameter":"specific energy of ISRU reactor","scope":"molten regolith electrolysis (Chen et al. 2021)","value":"26.94","low":"","high":"","unit":"kWh/kg O2","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.04265","locator":"arXiv 1910.04265 PDF p.27, Table 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"ISRU sizing model extrapolated from historical design concepts and prototypes (Chen et al. ref [27]); per kg/h of reference product; specific power 26.94 kW per kg/h; specific mass 197.58 kg per kg/h"},{"id":"P0969","domain":"technology","parameter":"reactor mass productivity","scope":"molten regolith electrolysis (Chen et al. 2021)","value":"44.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg product per kg reactor per yr","year":"2021","method":"derived","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.04265","locator":"arXiv 1910.04265 PDF p.27, Table 3; 8,766 h / specific mass","verification":"derived","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"derived 8766/197.58; reactor only, excludes power, excavation, storage; continuous operation"},{"id":"P0970","domain":"technology","parameter":"fission surface power specific mass","scope":"FSPS (Chen et al. 2021)","value":"150","low":"","high":"","unit":"kg/kW","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.04265","locator":"arXiv 1910.04265 PDF p.27, Table 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"PV 6.8 kg/kW at 1 AU; ISRU maintenance 10% of system mass per year (Table 4)"},{"id":"P0971","domain":"economics","parameter":"discounted NPV return on investment over 20 years","scope":"commercial asteroid mining architecture (Andrews et al. 2015)","value":"22","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year","year":"2015","method":"model","source_url":"https://thedragonstales.blogspot.com/2014/12/u-washington-paper-22-profit-over-20.html","locator":"abstract","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"abstract text quoted on blog; primary Acta Astronautica 2015 (pii S0094576514004123) not opened; University of Washington design class; initial investment equivalent to US North Slope oil field"},{"id":"P0972","domain":"economics","parameter":"LOX/LH2 propellant available in LEO","scope":"commercial asteroid mining architecture (Andrews et al. 2015)","value":"1500","low":"","high":"","unit":"t/yr","year":"2015","method":"model","source_url":"https://thedragonstales.blogspot.com/2014/12/u-washington-paper-22-profit-over-20.html","locator":"abstract","verification":"snippet-only","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"abstract text quoted on blog; primary Acta Astronautica 2015 (pii S0094576514004123) not opened; University of Washington design class; also PGM world supply +50%"},{"id":"P0973","domain":"economics","parameter":"production learning factor (Crawford unit curve) assumed for launcher hardware","scope":"commercial smallsat launch vehicles (Drenthe, Zandbergen, van Pelt T1+TRANSCOST model)","value":"0.90","low":"","high":"","unit":"ratio (unit cost after doubling of units produced)","year":"2017","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.eucass.eu/doi/EUCASS2017-286.pdf","locator":"PDF p.8, Sect. 2.4.1 and footnote 5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Valid for production batches of 11-50 units (fn. 5); 12 identical elements at 90% give an average batch factor of 0.78 (Sect. 2.3.2)."},{"id":"P0974","domain":"economics","parameter":"typical range of manufacturing learning factors","scope":"aerospace production (Fox et al., as cited by Drenthe et al. 2017)","value":"","low":"0.82","high":"0.96","unit":"ratio (unit cost per doubling)","year":"2017","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.eucass.eu/doi/EUCASS2017-286.pdf","locator":"PDF p.12-13, Sect. 4.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Choosing 82% vs 96% can over- or under-estimate manufacturing cost by up to +39% / -54%. Secondary: Fox et al. not opened."},{"id":"P0975","domain":"economics","parameter":"learning factor for production and for refurbishment","scope":"European reusable first stages (DLR ENTRAIN study)","value":"0.85","low":"","high":"","unit":"ratio (cost per doubling of units produced / refurbished)","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.7, Sect. 3.2-3.3, Eq. 5 and 8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Wilken, Herberhold, Sippel, CEAS Space J. 2024. Same 0.85 applied to refurbishment learning across reflights."},{"id":"P0976","domain":"economics","parameter":"cost learning-by-doing progress ratio (assumed)","scope":"US space launch industry (Su, Yang, Sweeting dynamic model)","value":"0.85","low":"","high":"","unit":"ratio (cost per doubling of know-how)","year":"2026","method":"model","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.34, Sect. 5.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"gamma_e = 0.234 assumed, not estimated; authors say consistent with NASA progress ratios for aerospace. Robustness check uses no cost LBD. Working paper 21 Jan 2026."},{"id":"P0977","domain":"economics","parameter":"elasticity of launch cost per kg w.r.t. cumulative payload to orbit","scope":"global launch 1960-2025 (Terzi & Nicoli)","value":"-0.34","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (dln cost/kg / dln cumulative payload)","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Results, Wright's Law","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Same regression as P0223 expressed as elasticity (2^-0.34 = 0.79, i.e. 21% per doubling). Read via HTML fetch; PDF blocked."},{"id":"P0978","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual decline of average launch cost per kg (time trend)","scope":"global launch 1960-2025 (Terzi & Nicoli)","value":"2.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Results, Wright's Law (Moore's-law fit)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"R^2 0.739 full sample, 0.914 this century (per page)."},{"id":"P0979","domain":"economics","parameter":"within-family learning rate, post-Cold War","scope":"rocket families after 1989 (Terzi & Nicoli)","value":"0.08","low":"","high":"","unit":"fraction per doubling of family cumulative payload","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Results, Wright's Law","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Extends P0226 (6% full sample); fixed-effects R^2 < 0.5."},{"id":"P0980","domain":"economics","parameter":"growth of payload to orbit, central forecast scenario","scope":"global launch (Terzi & Nicoli)","value":"13.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Results, Technological forecasting; Methods, Out of sample predictions","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Observed 2010-2025 average used as central scenario (Methods round it to 13%)."},{"id":"P0981","domain":"economics","parameter":"growth of payload to orbit, conservative scenario","scope":"global launch (Terzi & Nicoli)","value":"7.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Methods, Out of sample predictions","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"1995-2025 average used as conservative scenario."},{"id":"P0982","domain":"economics","parameter":"growth of payload to orbit, bullish scenario","scope":"global launch (Terzi & Nicoli)","value":"21","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Methods, Out of sample predictions","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"2016-2025 average used as bullish scenario."},{"id":"P0983","domain":"economics","parameter":"forecast annual capacity to LEO, central scenario","scope":"global launch, 2030 (Terzi & Nicoli)","value":"9100","low":"","high":"","unit":"t per year","year":"2030","method":"model","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Discussion","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Paper equates this to roughly 80 Starship flights."},{"id":"P0984","domain":"economics","parameter":"estimated launch cost per kg at entry into service","scope":"Starship (Terzi & Nicoli)","value":"1000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (paper's 2024 USD basis assumed)","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Discussion","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'from day one ... around 1,000 USD/kg'; dollar year not stated in the sentence."},{"id":"P0985","domain":"economics","parameter":"expected launch cost per kg within a few years of service","scope":"Starship (Terzi & Nicoli)","value":"","low":"","high":"500","unit":"USD/kg (paper's 2024 USD basis assumed)","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Discussion","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'possibly bringing costs below 500 USD/kg over the next few years' (upper bound)."},{"id":"P0986","domain":"economics","parameter":"estimated initial launch cost per kg","scope":"New Glenn (Terzi & Nicoli)","value":"1500","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD/kg (paper's 2024 USD basis assumed)","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Discussion","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'roughly 1,500 USD/kg'."},{"id":"P0987","domain":"economics","parameter":"SpaceX share of total payload mass sent to orbit","scope":"world (Terzi & Nicoli)","value":"75","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of payload mass","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/doi/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag217/8732400","locator":"Discussion","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"BryceTech 2025 upmass gives ~82% (derived row in this batch)."},{"id":"P0988","domain":"economics","parameter":"annual decline of real launch prices, hedonic (baseline)","scope":"commercial satellite launch market 1996-2025 (Rouillon & Senegas)","value":"3.3","low":"2.7","high":"3.3","unit":"% per year (real, 2025 USD)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://spaceeconomics.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/SEWP-10-2026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.5 (findings) and p.17 (Sect. results)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Falls to 2.7%/yr once regional controls are added. Prices reconstructed from expert per-vehicle cost estimates scaled to regional revenue (SIA, ASD-Eurospace). Working paper SEWP 10-2026."},{"id":"P0989","domain":"economics","parameter":"hedonic elasticity of launch price w.r.t. payload mass","scope":"commercial satellite launches 1996-2025 (Rouillon & Senegas)","value":"0.44","low":"0.41","high":"0.44","unit":"elasticity","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://spaceeconomics.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/SEWP-10-2026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.5 and p.17","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Panel A 0.44, Panel B 0.41; significant at 1% under CR2."},{"id":"P0990","domain":"economics","parameter":"hedonic elasticity of launch price w.r.t. target apogee","scope":"commercial satellite launches 1996-2025 (Rouillon & Senegas)","value":"0.15","low":"0.14","high":"0.15","unit":"elasticity","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://spaceeconomics.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/SEWP-10-2026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.5 and p.17","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0991","domain":"economics","parameter":"European launch price premium relative to US","scope":"commercial satellite launches 1996-2025 (Rouillon & Senegas)","value":"0.55","low":"","high":"","unit":"log points","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://spaceeconomics.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/SEWP-10-2026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Rest of the world: discount of about 0.60 log points (next row)."},{"id":"P0992","domain":"economics","parameter":"Rest-of-world launch price discount relative to US","scope":"commercial satellite launches 1996-2025 (Rouillon & Senegas)","value":"-0.60","low":"","high":"","unit":"log points","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://spaceeconomics.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/SEWP-10-2026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P0993","domain":"economics","parameter":"decline of launch cost per kg to LEO (Adilov et al. 2023)","scope":"2,787 LEO satellites 2000-2020","value":"6","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year","year":"2020","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://spaceeconomics.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/SEWP-10-2026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.3 (literature review)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"As reported by Rouillon & Senegas; also ~10%/yr per satellite. Primary (Adilov et al. 2023) not opened; costs mapped from Roberts 2022 / GAO 2017 per-kg estimates, flagged as fragile."},{"id":"P0994","domain":"economics","parameter":"trend in NASA launch service cost per kg (Kim 2025)","scope":"88 NASA launches 1996-2024 (ONCE database)","value":"3","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year increase","year":"2024","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://spaceeconomics.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/SEWP-10-2026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.3 (literature review)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"As reported by Rouillon & Senegas: NASA's cost per kg rises ~3%/yr; primary (Kim 2025) not opened. Contrasts with falling commercial prices."},{"id":"P0995","domain":"economics","parameter":"short-run own-price elasticity of demand, Atlas V (government buyer)","scope":"US national-security launch procurement, era 2 (Su, Yang, Sweeting)","value":"-1.885","low":"-3.479","high":"-1.756","unit":"elasticity","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.42, Table 5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Value = high know-how state (15,15) under duopoly; range spans all know-how states under duopoly and monopoly. Structural dynamic model."},{"id":"P0996","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run own-price elasticity of demand, Atlas V, duopoly","scope":"US national-security launch procurement, era 2 (Su, Yang, Sweeting)","value":"-1.885","low":"-14.398","high":"-1.885","unit":"elasticity","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.42, Table 6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Permanent 5% bid cut, forward-looking buyer re-optimises; far more elastic at low know-how."},{"id":"P0997","domain":"economics","parameter":"long-run own-price elasticity of demand, Atlas V, ULA monopoly","scope":"US national-security launch procurement, era 2 (Su, Yang, Sweeting)","value":"-1.885","low":"-6.232","high":"-1.279","unit":"elasticity","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.42, Table 6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Value = state (15,15)."},{"id":"P0998","domain":"economics","parameter":"buyer willingness to pay for a doubling of rocket know-how","scope":"typical 15 t LEO launch, US government (Su, Yang, Sweeting)","value":"25","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD million per launch (paper's real dollars; base year not checked)","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.37, Sect. 5.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"must-check","note":"Computed by the authors from baseline price and know-how coefficients; dollar base year to check."},{"id":"P0999","domain":"economics","parameter":"std. dev. of procurement-level cost shock","scope":"US launch procurements (Su, Yang, Sweeting)","value":"21","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of bidder cost (one s.d.)","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.37, Sect. 5.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P1000","domain":"economics","parameter":"within-family launch price trend with years since first launch","scope":"rockets of all countries (Su, Yang, Sweeting, App. A.1)","value":"-0.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"% per year","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.72, Appendix Table A.1 col. (1)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Overall R^2 0.86, within-family R^2 0.07; reuse indicator coefficient negative."},{"id":"P1001","domain":"economics","parameter":"price effect of doubling procurement lot size","scope":"US government launch procurements (Su, Yang, Sweeting)","value":"-5","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of price per launch","year":"2026","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.14 and PDF p.77, App. A.2.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Coefficient -0.05, statistically insignificant."},{"id":"P1002","domain":"economics","parameter":"price elasticity of launch demand if post-2019 trend persists","scope":"global launch market (Metzger crude estimate)","value":"3.8","low":"","high":"","unit":"elasticity (abs.)","year":"2022","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.19, Sec. 4.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Companion to P0221 (1.9); author calls both crude."},{"id":"P1003","domain":"economics","parameter":"decline in global-average launch cost since 2005","scope":"global launch market (Metzger)","value":"40","low":"","high":"","unit":"% decline","year":"2022","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.19, Sec. 4.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'rough estimate' used to back out elasticity 1.9."},{"id":"P1004","domain":"economics","parameter":"growth rate of cumulative mass in orbit, 1980-2005","scope":"objects in Earth orbit (Metzger, citing ref. 77)","value":"140","low":"","high":"","unit":"t per year","year":"2005","method":"measured","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.19, Sec. 4.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Then ~280 t/y from 2005 and ~550 t/y since 2019 (next rows)."},{"id":"P1005","domain":"economics","parameter":"growth rate of cumulative mass in orbit, 2005-2019","scope":"objects in Earth orbit (Metzger, citing ref. 77)","value":"280","low":"","high":"","unit":"t per year","year":"2019","method":"measured","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.19, Sec. 4.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P1006","domain":"economics","parameter":"growth rate of cumulative mass in orbit, since 2019","scope":"objects in Earth orbit (Metzger, citing ref. 77)","value":"550","low":"","high":"","unit":"t per year","year":"2022","method":"measured","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09011","locator":"arXiv 2303.09011 PDF p.19, Sec. 4.8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Mass remaining in orbit, not mass launched; far below P0384-P0386 launched payload mass."},{"id":"P1007","domain":"economics","parameter":"refurbishment effort per flight, winged reusable stage","scope":"VTHL first stage, Space-Shuttle-derived (DLR ENTRAIN)","value":"2.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of theoretical first unit cost per flight","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.7, Sect. 3.3.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Baseline 50 reuses; factor derived from Shuttle data in TRANSCOST (Koelle)."},{"id":"P1008","domain":"economics","parameter":"refurbishment effort per flight, vertical-landing stage","scope":"VTVL first stage (DLR ENTRAIN)","value":"5","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of theoretical first unit cost per flight","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.7, Sect. 3.3.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Baseline 25 reuses; authors note Falcon 9 actuals are not public."},{"id":"P1009","domain":"economics","parameter":"refurbishment effort per flight, engines on VTVL stage","scope":"rocket engines, VTVL stage (DLR ENTRAIN)","value":"7","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of engine first unit cost per flight","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.8, Sect. 3.3.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"20 engine reuses assumed."},{"id":"P1010","domain":"economics","parameter":"refurbishment effort per flight, engines on winged stage","scope":"rocket engines, VTHL stage (DLR ENTRAIN)","value":"4","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of engine first unit cost per flight","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.8, Sect. 3.3.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"25 engine reuses assumed."},{"id":"P1011","domain":"economics","parameter":"refurbishment plus recovery cost relative to new launcher production cost","scope":"Falcon 9 (SpaceX statement, as of 2020)","value":"","low":"","high":"10","unit":"% of new production cost","year":"2020","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.7, Sect. 3.3.1 (ref. 17, Musk 2020)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Upper bound; company claim relayed by DLR."},{"id":"P1012","domain":"economics","parameter":"refurbishment cost of a flown first stage relative to a new one","scope":"Falcon 9 (Shotwell, 2017)","value":"","low":"","high":"50","unit":"% of new first-stage cost","year":"2017","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200001093/downloads/20200001093.pdf","locator":"PDF p.5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"'substantially less than half' (quoted from Morris 2017). Jones: reuse may cut costs by a factor of two."},{"id":"P1013","domain":"economics","parameter":"fixed recovery cost per flight, downrange landing or in-air capture","scope":"European reusable first stage (DLR ENTRAIN)","value":"850","low":"","high":"","unit":"kEUR(2022) per flight","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.7, Sect. 3.3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"From Stappert et al. recovery model rescaled to 370 kEUR work-year."},{"id":"P1014","domain":"economics","parameter":"fixed recovery cost per flight, return to launch site","scope":"European reusable first stage (DLR ENTRAIN)","value":"310","low":"","high":"","unit":"kEUR(2022) per flight","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.7, Sect. 3.3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P1015","domain":"economics","parameter":"work-year cost, European space industry","scope":"Europe (TRANSCOST WYr extrapolated)","value":"370","low":"","high":"","unit":"kEUR(2022) per work-year","year":"2022","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.6, Sect. 3.2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P1016","domain":"economics","parameter":"recovery cost per launch, return to launch site","scope":"VTVL first stage at 15 launches/yr (Stappert et al.)","value":"250","low":"","high":"","unit":"kUSD(2021) per launch","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/187238/1/EUCASS2022-4838.pdf","locator":"PDF p.11, Sect. 4, Fig. 10","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Overhead and vessel depreciation (15-yr life) dominate."},{"id":"P1017","domain":"economics","parameter":"recovery cost per launch, drone-ship landing (SpaceX method)","scope":"VTVL first stage at 15 launches/yr (Stappert et al.)","value":"700","low":"","high":"","unit":"kUSD(2021) per launch","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/187238/1/EUCASS2022-4838.pdf","locator":"PDF p.11, Sect. 4, Fig. 10","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P1018","domain":"economics","parameter":"recovery cost per launch, single large ship (Blue Origin method)","scope":"VTVL first stage at 15 launches/yr (Stappert et al.)","value":"1100","low":"","high":"","unit":"kUSD(2021) per launch","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/187238/1/EUCASS2022-4838.pdf","locator":"PDF p.11, Sect. 4, Fig. 10","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'almost 1.1 million US$'."},{"id":"P1019","domain":"economics","parameter":"recovery cost per launch, in-air capturing","scope":"winged first stage at 15 launches/yr (Stappert et al.)","value":"","low":"650","high":"1250","unit":"kUSD(2021) per launch","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/187238/1/EUCASS2022-4838.pdf","locator":"PDF p.11, Sect. 4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Depends on aircraft (A380 at top)."},{"id":"P1020","domain":"economics","parameter":"direct recovery operations cost per mission","scope":"fuel, crew, port and landing fees (Stappert et al.)","value":"100","low":"","high":"","unit":"kUSD(2021) per mission","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/187238/1/EUCASS2022-4838.pdf","locator":"PDF p.11, Sect. 4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"1.5-2.5 MUSD per year depending on method."},{"id":"P1021","domain":"economics","parameter":"cost premium of fully expendable launcher over reusable-first-stage equivalent","scope":"European heavy launcher options (DLR ENTRAIN)","value":"","low":"36","high":"41","unit":"% higher total cost","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.15, Sect. 5.5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Averaged over 280 market scenarios; ELV never cheaper."},{"id":"P1022","domain":"economics","parameter":"break-even number of launches, reusable vs expendable","scope":"DRL CC GG Med vs EL CC GG Med (DLR ENTRAIN)","value":"40","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.15, Sect. 5.5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Equivalent to < 2.6 launches per year over 20 years."},{"id":"P1023","domain":"economics","parameter":"average launch cost, reusable first stage (lowest-cost scenario)","scope":"DRL CC GG Med (DLR ENTRAIN)","value":"186","low":"","high":"","unit":"MEUR(2022) per launch","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.15, Sect. 5.5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Text prints '186 EUR'; M implied by context. Non-recurring 13 BEUR."},{"id":"P1024","domain":"economics","parameter":"average launch cost, expendable equivalent (lowest-cost scenario)","scope":"EL CC GG Med (DLR ENTRAIN)","value":"314","low":"","high":"","unit":"MEUR(2022) per launch","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.15, Sect. 5.5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Non-recurring 8 BEUR."},{"id":"P1025","domain":"economics","parameter":"development cost, reusable configuration","scope":"DRL CC GG Med (DLR ENTRAIN)","value":"13","low":"","high":"","unit":"BEUR(2022)","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.15, Sect. 5.5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P1026","domain":"economics","parameter":"development cost, expendable configuration","scope":"EL CC GG Med (DLR ENTRAIN)","value":"8","low":"","high":"","unit":"BEUR(2022)","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.15, Sect. 5.5","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P1027","domain":"economics","parameter":"average launch cost in most-launch scenarios","scope":"DRL KK GG Med (DLR ENTRAIN, kerosene VTVL)","value":"66","low":"","high":"","unit":"MEUR(2022) per launch","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.14, Sect. 5.2.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Compared with Falcon 9 internal cost 20-30 MUSD; gap attributed to payload, dry mass, cadence (~36 vs ~100 launches/yr), CER basis."},{"id":"P1028","domain":"economics","parameter":"speculated internal cost per launch","scope":"Falcon 9","value":"","low":"20","high":"30","unit":"MUSD per launch (c. 2024)","year":"2024","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.13-14, Sect. 5.2.1 (ref. 20, Lionnet)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"'speculated to be between 20 M$ and 30 M$'."},{"id":"P1029","domain":"economics","parameter":"published launch price","scope":"Falcon 9 (as cited by DLR)","value":"69.75","low":"","high":"","unit":"MUSD(2024) per launch","year":"2024","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.13, Sect. 5.2.1 (ref. 19, SpaceX)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Between P0180 (67 M, 2022) and P0179 (70 M, 2025)."},{"id":"P1030","domain":"economics","parameter":"development cost, Ariane 6","scope":"Ariane 6 excl. engines and P120C","value":"4","low":"","high":"","unit":"BEUR (mixed economic conditions), lower bound","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.14, Sect. 5.2.2 (ref. 21, ESA)","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'more than 4 BEUR'; ENTRAIN comparable concept modelled at ~6.9 BEUR(2022) incl. new engine."},{"id":"P1031","domain":"economics","parameter":"recurring cost advantage of hydrocarbon over hydrogen engines","scope":"rocket engines per unit thrust (DLR ENTRAIN assumption)","value":"30","low":"","high":"","unit":"% lower production cost","year":"2024","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/210214/1/s12567-024-00577-5.pdf","locator":"PDF p.8, Sect. 3.3.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Assumption, not data."},{"id":"P1032","domain":"economics","parameter":"Falcon 9 development cost incl. reusability, DLR reverse-engineered estimate","scope":"Falcon 9 (Stappert et al.)","value":"2.6","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD(2021)","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/187238/1/EUCASS2022-4838.pdf","locator":"PDF p.7, Sect. 2.4, Fig. 6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"Stages ~750 MUSD, Merlin 1D ~500 MUSD, reusability ~1.3 BUSD. Conflicts with Drenthe (372 MUSD 2010) and NASA/Jones (443 MUSD) which exclude reuse and Merlin 1D work."},{"id":"P1033","domain":"economics","parameter":"development cost of adding reusability","scope":"Falcon 9 (DLR estimate)","value":"1.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD(2021)","year":"2021","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/187238/1/EUCASS2022-4838.pdf","locator":"PDF p.7, Sect. 2.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Musk stated ~1 BUSD (next row)."},{"id":"P1034","domain":"economics","parameter":"development cost of adding reusability (company statement)","scope":"Falcon 9 (Musk, as cited by Stappert et al.)","value":"1","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD (nominal)","year":"2017","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/187238/1/EUCASS2022-4838.pdf","locator":"PDF p.6, Sect. 2.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"Year of statement approximate (Jones/space press: March 2017)."},{"id":"P1035","domain":"economics","parameter":"TRANSCOST estimate of Falcon 9 development cost","scope":"Falcon 9 (TRANSCOST standard CERs)","value":"25.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"BEUR(2019)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/187238/1/EUCASS2022-4838.pdf","locator":"PDF p.6, Sect. 2.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"With Koelle's commercial factors: 10 BEUR. Shows traditional CERs overstate commercial development ~10-40x."},{"id":"P1036","domain":"economics","parameter":"TRANSCOST estimate of Falcon 9 development cost with commercial factors","scope":"Falcon 9 (TRANSCOST commercial CERs)","value":"10","low":"","high":"","unit":"BEUR(2019)","year":"2019","method":"model","source_url":"https://elib.dlr.de/187238/1/EUCASS2022-4838.pdf","locator":"PDF p.6, Sect. 2.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P1037","domain":"economics","parameter":"NASA NAFCOM estimate of Falcon 9 development under traditional contracting","scope":"Falcon 9 (NASA 2010 comparison, via Jones 2018)","value":"1383","low":"","high":"","unit":"MUSD (nominal, c. 2010)","year":"2010","method":"model","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200001093/downloads/20200001093.pdf","locator":"PDF p.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Primary NASA/AF cost model report not opened."},{"id":"P1038","domain":"economics","parameter":"estimated actual SpaceX development cost","scope":"Falcon 9 (NASA 2010 comparison, via Jones 2018)","value":"443","low":"","high":"","unit":"MUSD (nominal, c. 2010)","year":"2010","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200001093/downloads/20200001093.pdf","locator":"PDF p.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"68% below NAFCOM. Drenthe Table 6 reports 372 MUSD(2010); DLR 2.6 BUSD incl. reuse."},{"id":"P1039","domain":"economics","parameter":"reported development cost","scope":"Falcon 9 (Drenthe et al. Table 6, ref. 43)","value":"372","low":"","high":"","unit":"MUSD(2010)","year":"2010","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.eucass.eu/doi/EUCASS2017-286.pdf","locator":"PDF p.11, Table 6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"Model estimate 419 MUSD (+13%). See NASA/Jones 443 MUSD row."},{"id":"P1040","domain":"economics","parameter":"reported development cost","scope":"Falcon 1 (Drenthe et al. Table 6)","value":"90","low":"","high":"","unit":"MUSD(2010)","year":"2010","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.eucass.eu/doi/EUCASS2017-286.pdf","locator":"PDF p.11, Table 6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Model 96 MUSD (+7%)."},{"id":"P1041","domain":"economics","parameter":"reported development cost","scope":"Pegasus (Drenthe et al. Table 6)","value":"50","low":"","high":"","unit":"MUSD(1988)","year":"1988","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.eucass.eu/doi/EUCASS2017-286.pdf","locator":"PDF p.11, Table 6","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Model 56 MUSD (+12%)."},{"id":"P1042","domain":"economics","parameter":"reported manufacturing cost per vehicle","scope":"Falcon 1 (Drenthe et al. Table 7)","value":"5.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"MUSD(2005)","year":"2005","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.eucass.eu/doi/EUCASS2017-286.pdf","locator":"PDF p.11, Table 7","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Model 6.1 MUSD (+3.4%)."},{"id":"P1043","domain":"economics","parameter":"reported launch price","scope":"Falcon 1 (Drenthe et al. Table 8)","value":"7.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"MUSD(2008) per launch","year":"2008","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://www.eucass.eu/doi/EUCASS2017-286.pdf","locator":"PDF p.11, Table 8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Model 8.7 MUSD at 10 launches/yr, subsidy-adjusted."},{"id":"P1044","domain":"economics","parameter":"reported launch price","scope":"Pegasus XL (Drenthe et al. Table 8)","value":"20.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"MEUR(2015) per launch","year":"2015","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://www.eucass.eu/doi/EUCASS2017-286.pdf","locator":"PDF p.11, Table 8","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Model 20.0 MEUR at 12 launches/yr."},{"id":"P1045","domain":"economics","parameter":"profit margin added to cost per flight","scope":"commercial launchers (Drenthe et al. pricing rule)","value":"8","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of cost per flight","year":"2017","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.eucass.eu/doi/EUCASS2017-286.pdf","locator":"PDF p.10, Sect. 2.7, Eq. 13","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Nominal margin from ref. 34."},{"id":"P1046","domain":"economics","parameter":"operations share of recurring cost at >= 4 launches per year","scope":"small launch vehicles (Drenthe et al.)","value":"","low":"","high":"35","unit":"% of recurring cost","year":"2017","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.eucass.eu/doi/EUCASS2017-286.pdf","locator":"PDF p.13, Sect. 4.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"At low launch rates indirect operating costs can double small-launcher cost."},{"id":"P1047","domain":"economics","parameter":"manufacturing share of launcher life-cycle cost (work-years)","scope":"launch vehicles (Drenthe et al., ref. 35)","value":"","low":"","high":"75","unit":"% of LCC in work-years","year":"2017","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.eucass.eu/doi/EUCASS2017-286.pdf","locator":"PDF p.7, Sect. 2.4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'reaching values up to 75%'."},{"id":"P1048","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch-rate exponent of flight and mission operations cost (TRANSCOST CER)","scope":"expendable launch vehicles (Koelle, via Drenthe Table 4)","value":"-0.65","low":"","high":"","unit":"exponent on launches per year","year":"2013","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.eucass.eu/doi/EUCASS2017-286.pdf","locator":"PDF p.9, Table 4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"CER: W*20*QN*LpA^-0.65*fv*f8."},{"id":"P1049","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch-rate exponent of indirect operating cost (TRANSCOST CER)","scope":"launch service providers (Koelle, via Drenthe Table 4)","value":"-0.379","low":"","high":"","unit":"exponent on launches per year","year":"2013","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.eucass.eu/doi/EUCASS2017-286.pdf","locator":"PDF p.9, Table 4","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"CER: 40*S + 22.5*LpA^-0.379*W."},{"id":"P1050","domain":"economics","parameter":"total programme cost 1971-2010","scope":"Space Shuttle (Pielke & Byerly, Nature 472:38)","value":"192","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD(2010), lower bound","year":"2010","method":"measured","source_url":"https://rogerpielkejr.blogspot.com/2011/04/space-shuttle-costs-1971-2011.html","locator":"letter text reproduced on author's blog, 2011-04-06","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"131 flights."},{"id":"P1051","domain":"economics","parameter":"average cost per launch, operational years 1982-2010","scope":"Space Shuttle (Pielke & Byerly)","value":"1.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD(2010) per launch","year":"2010","method":"derived","source_url":"https://rogerpielkejr.blogspot.com/2011/04/space-shuttle-costs-1971-2011.html","locator":"letter text","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Programme spending / flights."},{"id":"P1052","domain":"economics","parameter":"lifetime average cost per launch incl. development","scope":"Space Shuttle (Pielke & Byerly)","value":"1.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD(2010) per launch","year":"2010","method":"derived","source_url":"https://rogerpielkejr.blogspot.com/2011/04/space-shuttle-costs-1971-2011.html","locator":"letter text","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P1053","domain":"economics","parameter":"actual flight rate 1991-2010 vs projection of 8","scope":"Space Shuttle (Pielke & Byerly)","value":"4.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"flights per year","year":"2010","method":"measured","source_url":"https://rogerpielkejr.blogspot.com/2011/04/space-shuttle-costs-1971-2011.html","locator":"letter text","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Projected cost/flight ~800 MUSD vs actual ~1 BUSD; annual cost 4.7 BUSD actual vs 6.2 projected. Shows fixed-cost dominance of reusable system at low cadence."},{"id":"P1054","domain":"economics","parameter":"cost per launch (Adler 2023, as cited)","scope":"Space Shuttle","value":"450","low":"","high":"","unit":"MUSD per launch (dollar year not stated)","year":"2023","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.51, footnote 56","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"Disagrees with Pielke & Byerly ~1.2 BUSD(2010) average; likely marginal vs average cost."},{"id":"P1055","domain":"economics","parameter":"production and operations cost per launch","scope":"SLS/Orion, Artemis I-IV (NASA OIG IG-22-003)","value":"4.1","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD (nominal, FY2021-22) per launch","year":"2021","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://oig.nasa.gov/docs/IG-22-003.pdf","locator":"PDF p.29","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"At ~1 mission/yr; excludes development. SLS 2.2 B, Orion 1 B, ESA service module 0.3 B, ground systems 0.568 B/yr."},{"id":"P1056","domain":"economics","parameter":"production cost of one SLS rocket","scope":"SLS Block 1 (NASA OIG IG-22-003)","value":"2.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD (nominal, FY2021-22) per launch","year":"2021","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://oig.nasa.gov/docs/IG-22-003.pdf","locator":"PDF p.29 and fn. 47","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Two stages, two SRBs, four RS-25, two adapters."},{"id":"P1057","domain":"economics","parameter":"ground systems cost per year","scope":"SLS/Orion Exploration Ground Systems, KSC (NASA OIG)","value":"568","low":"","high":"","unit":"MUSD (nominal) per year","year":"2021","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://oig.nasa.gov/docs/IG-22-003.pdf","locator":"PDF p.29","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Fixed cost charged to one launch per year."},{"id":"P1058","domain":"economics","parameter":"Artemis programme spending FY2012-FY2025","scope":"NASA Artemis (OIG projection)","value":"93","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD (nominal)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://oig.nasa.gov/docs/IG-22-003.pdf","locator":"PDF p.4 (summary) and Sect. 'Total Artemis Costs'","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P1059","domain":"economics","parameter":"development cost (as cited)","scope":"Vulcan Centaur (Gruss 2016, via Su et al.)","value":"6","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD (nominal)","year":"2016","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.34, Sect. 5.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Used to calibrate innovation cost."},{"id":"P1060","domain":"economics","parameter":"development cost (as cited)","scope":"New Glenn (Bogaisky 2025, via Su et al.)","value":"10","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD (nominal)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.34, Sect. 5.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P1061","domain":"economics","parameter":"development cost (as cited)","scope":"Space Launch System (Spaceflight News 2025, via Su et al.)","value":"40","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD (nominal)","year":"2025","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.34-35, Sect. 5.1","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Mean innovation cost across Vulcan/Starship/New Glenn/SLS: 16.5 BUSD (s.d. 15.8)."},{"id":"P1062","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch contract value, single launch","scope":"Falcon 9, GPS III-3 (USAF 2017)","value":"96.5","low":"","high":"","unit":"MUSD(2017) per launch","year":"2017","method":"contract","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.14, footnote 21","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P1063","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch contract value per launch, 3-launch lot","scope":"Falcon 9, GPS III-4/5/6 (USAF 2018)","value":"96.7","low":"","high":"","unit":"MUSD(2018) per launch","year":"2018","method":"derived","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.14, footnote 21","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"290 MUSD / 3."},{"id":"P1064","domain":"economics","parameter":"launch price paid","scope":"Atlas V 401, 18 Apr 2017 launch","value":"150","low":"","high":"","unit":"MUSD(2017) per launch","year":"2017","method":"contract","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.70, footnote 64","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Above ULA 2017 list price of 109 MUSD (next row)."},{"id":"P1065","domain":"economics","parameter":"list price","scope":"Atlas V 401 (ULA, 2017)","value":"109","low":"","high":"","unit":"MUSD(2017) per launch","year":"2017","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://econweb.umd.edu/~sweeting/Space_LBD_01212026.pdf","locator":"PDF p.70, footnote 64","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P1066","domain":"economics","parameter":"approx. launch price per kg to LEO","scope":"Pegasus XL, 443 kg to 200 km x 90 deg (Crisp et al. 2014)","value":"45100","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2014)/kg","year":"2014","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/tastj/12/ists29/12_Tf_39/_pdf","locator":"p. Tf_40, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Vehicle price 25 MUSD; dollar year assumed = publication year."},{"id":"P1067","domain":"economics","parameter":"approx. launch price per kg to LEO","scope":"Minotaur I, 580 kg to 185 km (Crisp et al. 2014)","value":"34500","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2014)/kg","year":"2014","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/tastj/12/ists29/12_Tf_39/_pdf","locator":"p. Tf_40, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"20 MUSD; US government payloads only."},{"id":"P1068","domain":"economics","parameter":"approx. launch price per kg","scope":"Vega, 1500 kg to 700 km polar (Crisp et al. 2014)","value":"23300","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2014)/kg","year":"2014","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/tastj/12/ists29/12_Tf_39/_pdf","locator":"p. Tf_40, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"conflict","note":"35 MUSD. Disagrees with P0157/P0167 (10,000-20,000/kg LEO); different reference orbit."},{"id":"P1069","domain":"economics","parameter":"approx. launch price per kg to LEO","scope":"PSLV-CA, 2100 kg to 200 km (Crisp et al. 2014)","value":"7100","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2014)/kg","year":"2014","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/tastj/12/ists29/12_Tf_39/_pdf","locator":"p. Tf_40, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"15 MUSD."},{"id":"P1070","domain":"economics","parameter":"approx. launch price per kg to LEO","scope":"Rockot, 2140 kg to 200 km (Crisp et al. 2014)","value":"9300","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2014)/kg","year":"2014","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/tastj/12/ists29/12_Tf_39/_pdf","locator":"p. Tf_40, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"20 MUSD."},{"id":"P1071","domain":"economics","parameter":"approx. launch price per kg to LEO","scope":"Falcon 1e, 1000 kg to 185 km (Crisp et al. 2014)","value":"10900","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2014)/kg","year":"2014","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/tastj/12/ists29/12_Tf_39/_pdf","locator":"p. Tf_40, Table 2","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"10.9 MUSD; vehicle discontinued."},{"id":"P1072","domain":"economics","parameter":"rideshare price per kg, 180 kg microsatellite","scope":"Spaceflight Services (Falcon 9, EELV, Antares, PSLV), 2014","value":"27500","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2014)/kg","year":"2014","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/tastj/12/ists29/12_Tf_39/_pdf","locator":"p. Tf_41, Table 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"4.95 MUSD per slot; 300 kg slot 6.95 MUSD (23,200/kg)."},{"id":"P1073","domain":"economics","parameter":"ESPA-class rideshare price per kg","scope":"Falcon 9, 180 kg (Crisp et al. 2014)","value":"","low":"22200","high":"27800","unit":"USD(2014)/kg","year":"2014","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/tastj/12/ists29/12_Tf_39/_pdf","locator":"p. Tf_41, Table 3","verification":"page-checked","bias":"company","status":"ok","note":"4-5 MUSD per slot; compare P0186/P0187 (6,500-7,000/kg, 2023-26)."},{"id":"P1074","domain":"economics","parameter":"rideshare price per kg (Dnepr, PSLV)","scope":"rideshare launches c. 2014 (Crisp et al.)","value":"10000","low":"","high":"","unit":"USD(2014)/kg","year":"2014","method":"list-price","source_url":"https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/tastj/12/ists29/12_Tf_39/_pdf","locator":"p. Tf_41, text","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'approximate cost of $10k/kg'."},{"id":"P1075","domain":"economics","parameter":"global space transportation industry revenue","scope":"world, 2016 (FAA AST)","value":"6","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD (nominal 2016)","year":"2016","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/ast/media/2018_ast_compendium.pdf","locator":"PDF p.15","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'nearly $6B'."},{"id":"P1076","domain":"economics","parameter":"commercial orbital launch revenue","scope":"world, 33 commercial launches 2017 (FAA AST)","value":"3","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD (nominal 2017)","year":"2017","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/ast/media/2018_ast_compendium.pdf","locator":"PDF p.46","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"'just over $3B'; 2016: 2.5 BUSD; US providers 1.7 BUSD in 2017."},{"id":"P1077","domain":"economics","parameter":"internationally competed launch revenue of US providers","scope":"US, 2016 (FAA AST)","value":"2.2","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD (nominal 2016)","year":"2016","method":"estimated","source_url":"https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/ast/media/2018_ast_compendium.pdf","locator":"PDF p.16","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"40% of global; FAA-licensed launches 784 MUSD."},{"id":"P1078","domain":"economics","parameter":"forecast average commercial launches per year 2018-2027","scope":"world commercial launch demand (FAA AST 2018 forecast)","value":"42.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches per year","year":"2018","method":"model","source_url":"https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/ast/media/2018_ast_compendium.pdf","locator":"PDF p.51, Table 11","verification":"page-checked","bias":"none","status":"ok","note":"Industry-survey method; 18 GSO + 24.3 NGSO. Forecast 2025: 36 launches vs 296 commercially procured launches actual (SIA) -> forecast missed constellation demand by ~8x."},{"id":"P1079","domain":"economics","parameter":"commercial launch revenue","scope":"world, 2025 (SIA 29th State of the Satellite Industry)","value":"12.4","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD (nominal 2025)","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://sia.org/affordability-productivity-drive-historic-satellite-industry-growth-satellite-industry-association-releases-29th-annual-state-of-the-satellite-industry-report/","locator":"press release 13 May 2026, Launch Services","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"+33% vs 2024. SIA counts commercially procured launches incl. those carrying operators' own satellites (definition not stated on page)."},{"id":"P1080","domain":"economics","parameter":"commercial launch revenue","scope":"world, 2024 (SIA 28th State of the Satellite Industry)","value":"9.3","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD (nominal 2024)","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://sia.org/historic-number-of-launches-powers-commercial-satellite-industry-growth-satellite-industry-association-releases-the-28th-annual-state-of-the-satellite-industry-report/","locator":"press release 13 May 2025, Launch Services","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"+30% vs 2023."},{"id":"P1081","domain":"economics","parameter":"commercial launch revenue (implied)","scope":"world, 2023","value":"7.15","low":"","high":"","unit":"BUSD (nominal 2023)","year":"2023","method":"derived","source_url":"https://sia.org/historic-number-of-launches-powers-commercial-satellite-industry-growth-satellite-industry-association-releases-the-28th-annual-state-of-the-satellite-industry-report/","locator":"derived: 9.3 / 1.30","verification":"derived","bias":"advocacy","status":"must-check","note":"Derived from the 2024 figure and its stated 30% growth."},{"id":"P1082","domain":"economics","parameter":"commercially procured launches","scope":"world, 2025 (SIA)","value":"296","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://sia.org/affordability-productivity-drive-historic-satellite-industry-growth-satellite-industry-association-releases-29th-annual-state-of-the-satellite-industry-report/","locator":"press release 13 May 2026","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"Of 325 launches worldwide."},{"id":"P1083","domain":"economics","parameter":"commercially procured launches","scope":"world, 2024 (SIA)","value":"224","low":"","high":"","unit":"launches","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://sia.org/historic-number-of-launches-powers-commercial-satellite-industry-growth-satellite-industry-association-releases-the-28th-annual-state-of-the-satellite-industry-report/","locator":"press release 13 May 2025","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"Of 259 launches."},{"id":"P1084","domain":"economics","parameter":"US share of commercially procured launch revenue","scope":"world, 2025 (SIA)","value":"59","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of revenue","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://sia.org/affordability-productivity-drive-historic-satellite-industry-growth-satellite-industry-association-releases-29th-annual-state-of-the-satellite-industry-report/","locator":"press release 13 May 2026","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":"US providers 63% of launches. 2024: 65% (next row)."},{"id":"P1085","domain":"economics","parameter":"US share of commercial launch revenue","scope":"world, 2024 (SIA)","value":"65","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of revenue","year":"2024","method":"measured","source_url":"https://sia.org/historic-number-of-launches-powers-commercial-satellite-industry-growth-satellite-industry-association-releases-the-28th-annual-state-of-the-satellite-industry-report/","locator":"press release 13 May 2025","verification":"page-checked","bias":"advocacy","status":"ok","note":""},{"id":"P1086","domain":"economics","parameter":"average revenue per commercially procured launch","scope":"world, 2025","value":"41.9","low":"","high":"","unit":"MUSD (nominal 2025) per launch","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://sia.org/affordability-productivity-drive-historic-satellite-industry-growth-satellite-industry-association-releases-29th-annual-state-of-the-satellite-industry-report/","locator":"derived: 12.4 BUSD / 296","verification":"derived","bias":"advocacy","status":"must-check","note":"2024: 9.3/224 = 41.5 MUSD. Mixes Electron-class and Falcon 9 launches."},{"id":"P1087","domain":"economics","parameter":"share of orbital launches by commercial providers","scope":"world, 2025 (BryceTech)","value":"87","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of launches","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/global-orbital-activity-2025/BryceTech_Orbital_Launches_2025.pdf","locator":"Year in Review, panel 'Total Orbital Launches by Type'","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"ok","note":"325 orbital launches, 4,544 spacecraft."},{"id":"P1088","domain":"economics","parameter":"spacecraft upmass launched","scope":"world, 2025 (BryceTech)","value":"2712","low":"","high":"","unit":"t","year":"2025","method":"measured","source_url":"https://www.brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/global-orbital-activity-2025/BryceTech_Orbital_Launches_2025.pdf","locator":"Year in Review, panel 'Spacecraft Launched and Total Upmass by Mass Class'","verification":"page-checked","bias":"consultancy","status":"conflict","note":"2,712,023 kg incl. estimates; McDowell gives 3,194.0 t (P0386)."},{"id":"P1089","domain":"economics","parameter":"SpaceX share of spacecraft upmass","scope":"world, 2025 (BryceTech)","value":"82","low":"","high":"","unit":"% of upmass","year":"2025","method":"derived","source_url":"https://www.brycetech.com/reports/report-documents/global-orbital-activity-2025/BryceTech_Orbital_Launches_2025.pdf","locator":"derived: 2,225,403 / 2,712,023 kg, panel 'Spacecraft Upmass Carried by Launch Provider'","verification":"derived","bias":"consultancy","status":"must-check","note":"Terzi & Nicoli say ~75% (row in this batch)."}]